.
1 / 10

Extra Virgin Bistro

4.6
·491k reviews·,

An upscale Italian bistro in St. John, renowned for its house-made pasta, fresh ingredients, and sophisticated cocktails. A culinary gem for a memorab...

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
.

Extra Virgin Bistro

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

An upscale Italian bistro in St. John, renowned for its house-made pasta, fresh ingredients, and sophisticated cocktails. A culinary gem for a memorable dining experience.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"A must-visit for its spectacular three-course meals and handcrafted Italian delights."

TIP

Reservations Recommended

Secure your table in advance to guarantee a spot at this popular dining destination.

Don't Miss the Ricotta

Consider the house-made ricotta starter for a delightful and unexpected taste sensation.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Cuisine

Italian

Price

$$$

Phone

+1 340-715-1864

Address

6D Cruz Bay, Saint John, VI 00830, U.S. Virgin Islands

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Handcrafted Italian Delights

Handcrafted Italian Delights

Experience authentic Italian cuisine with pasta, breads, and more made entirely in-house, ensuring peak freshness and flavor in every bite.

Google Review+1
Three-Course Culinary Journey

Three-Course Culinary Journey

Indulge in a thoughtfully curated three-course meal, offering vibrant flavors and surprising combinations for a truly memorable dining experience.

Top 4 Fine Dining Experiences in St. John | BlogGoogle Review+1
Unique & Flavorful Cocktails

Unique & Flavorful Cocktails

Complement your meal with an exceptional selection of handcrafted cocktails, featuring unique ingredients and house-made brines for a perfect pairing.

TikTokOur Guide to the Top 8 Restaurants in St JohnGoogle Review
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

that three course meal at Extra Virgin was soooo good I mean the fresh, handmade pasta I can taste it now @Virgin Voyages #cruisetok #valiantlady #baecation
@uniqueajana
100 likes • 779 views

Reservations Recommended

Secure your table in advance to guarantee a spot at this popular dining destination.

Don't Miss the Ricotta

Consider the house-made ricotta starter for a delightful and unexpected taste sensation.

@mandyvegadorantes2
8 likes • 314 views
Italian granny eating at Extra Virgin italian restaurant on #virginvoyages #BadGranny
@grannysoffherrocker
11.7K likes • 125.9K views

Try the Signature Martini

Savor the exceptional dirty martini, featuring house-made brine for a truly unique cocktail experience.

Explore the Three-Course Meal

The $100 three-course meal offers a perfect amount of food with spectacular dishes.

Although we dined at extra virgin on our last night, we thoroughly enjoyed it. We found it to be the best and fastest service on the ship. I loved the menu variety and the classic and specialty Italian style cocktails. I chose the limoncello spritz and my wife had a Bellini. A great experience all together and come hungry there are 4 courses. #virginvoyages #foodie #cruise #cruisetok #travel
@thedriftingash
12 likes • 382 views

Tips

from all over the internet

Reservations Recommended

Secure your table in advance to guarantee a spot at this popular dining destination.

Don't Miss the Ricotta

Consider the house-made ricotta starter for a delightful and unexpected taste sensation.

Try the Signature Martini

Savor the exceptional dirty martini, featuring house-made brine for a truly unique cocktail experience.

Explore the Three-Course Meal

The $100 three-course meal offers a perfect amount of food with spectacular dishes.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Extra Virgin Bistro offers a refined, upscale dining experience with many praising the exceptional service and the quality of their house-made Italian dishes, particularly the pasta. While some diners found the flavors to be good but not mind-blowing, the overall consensus leans towards a delightful meal, especially for special occasions. The unique cocktails and sophisticated ambiance also contribute to its popularity. However, a few reviews mentioned high prices and inconsistent service.

"I'm giving this fine establishment all of my stars, an excellent night out here for my wife and I and the food was so amazing. A three course venue is offered and each course was simply new and vibrant. All of this was well executed by the fantastic staff.

Behind the scenes the chef is brilliant. Offering an exquisite display with tastes that force you to slow down and just enjoy each moment. The atmosphere was really superb for our last evening in St John.

The "house made ricotta" was such a great surprise, unexpected I must say ! This was a phenomenal blend of tastes...

To the staff- Thank you Mike and team for making our experience wonderful and a perfect grand finale to other great restaurants we visited in St John's.. Yet Extra Virgin Bistro was our favorite restaurant we enjoyed during our stay.

We will be back... to visit St.John again and also to re-visit "Extra Virgin Bistro" so we can share this experience with some friends. When we return, we'd love to meet the chef!"

Bonds Garage

"While we were wowed with the plating and presentation of each dish, we weren’t super wowed with the flavor of each dish. It wasn’t bad by any means, I think we had just expected more! The Pappardelle was very good, but the other dishes we weren’t blown away with (aside from the presentation, which was great). We felt like there are better places on the island to get more out of your money! Still a great atmosphere and good drinks, just not a place we feel like is a must."

Morgan

"Everything went right at this restaurant. Just walked up and host found us a place said it would be a few minutes, we were waiting out by the street and it started raining and the host came and got us and said he wasn't going to have us waiting in the rain and got a table ready immediately. Mark and the girls running the bar were great people. Food was outstanding with everything made in house and I mean everything. The breads, the pasta, everything! Will be back again!"

Chris Monk

What People Like

Handmade pasta and breads
Exceptional and attentive service
Unique and flavorful cocktails

What People Dislike

Can be expensive
Flavors sometimes don't meet high expectations
Inconsistent service noted by some

Frequently Asked Questions

Extra Virgin Bistro primarily serves Italian cuisine, with a focus on fresh, house-made pasta, breads, and other handcrafted dishes.

TikTokSt John US Virgin Islands Travel Guide — Best St John USVI Rentals, Restaurants, Beaches, Hotels

Yes, it is highly recommended to make reservations in advance as the restaurant is quite popular.

Patrons rave about the house-made ricotta, duck confit, wild mushroom pappardelle, and the signature dirty martini.

Our Guide to the Top 8 Restaurants in St JohnSt John US Virgin Islands Travel Guide — Best St John USVI Rentals, Restaurants, Beaches, HotelsGoogle Review+1

Yes, they offer an exclusive three-course tasting menu for $100 per person, featuring appetizer, salad, and entrée.

Top 4 Fine Dining Experiences in St. John | BlogGoogle Review

While specific dishes vary, the focus on fresh ingredients and pasta often provides vegetarian choices. It's best to inquire about current options.

Many guests choose Extra Virgin Bistro for celebrations like birthdays, noting the exceptional service and fine dining experience.

Google Review+1

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

oktzm.uccmea.com

See Tripadvisor's St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands hotel deals and special … St. John Provisions, Cruz Bay: See 28 unbiased reviews of St. John Provisions, … Sailing, diving, fishing and soaking up the sun on perfect beaches is what it's all … May 15, 2023 - View the Best 2,331 villas with Prices in St. John with Tripadvisor's … Breakfast Restaurants in Cruz Bay; Lunch Restaurants in Cruz Bay; Dinner … 167 reviews #17 of 19 Restaurants in St. John $$ - $$$ American Bar Pub 300A … Restaurants in St. John Fodor’s Travel St John USVI Restaurants - Dining Guide In The Virgin … WebJun 5, 2022 · St. John, USVI CONTACT US800-727-6610BOOK NOW Mobile Logo STAY Book by Villa Sales & Rentals EXPERIENCE Overview Photo Gallery Dining Weddings … Coral Bay, St John USVI: Complete Coral Bay Visiter St John USVI Restaurants - Dining Guide In The Virgin Islands WebThe Tap Room– $$ – St John Brewer’s bar, pub Uncle Joe’s BBQ– $ – BBQ Viva Cantina– $$$ – Mexican Woody’s Seafood Saloon– $ – bar, American, seafood, pub Cruz Bay Restaurants – Fine Dining Café Roma– $$$ – Cruz Bay – Italian, pizza, 340-776-6524 Extra Virgin Bistro– $$$$ – Cruz Bay – Seafood, Italian, American, Mediterranean, 340-715-1864 14 Incredible Things to Do in St. John, US Virgin Islands snake pit mtg DiveIn Private Catering Chef St. Thomas & St. John Virgin Islands WebMar 6, 2023 · Caneel Bay Resort St John, USVI Beachfront Resort Video unavailable This video is not available Watch on Planning for the Future Save Caneel Bay Resort The Virgin Islands needs Caneel Bay Resort rebuilt NOW – the historic crown jewel of the Virgin Islands tourism. snake pit taylor swift Guide to the Best Restaurants in St. John USVI - Fueled By … Bed & Breakfast - Vacation in St Thomas, US Virgin … The Longboard St. John Seafood restaurant in Cruz Bay, USVI snake pit indy 500 201 WebThe restaurant is located in Cruz Bay, St. John, and is open daily from 5:30 PM to 10 PM.

Visit Source →
vtxzd.protech-uae.com

This food truck opened in the Lumberyard parking lot of Cruz Bay … SUN DOG CAFE, Cruz Bay - Menu, Prices & Restaurant … MEADA THE 10 BEST Breakfast Restaurants in Cruz Bay - Tripadvisor Maho Bay Beach in St. John USVI: How to Have the Perfect Day WebCRUZ BAY – FINE DINING. Café Roma – $$$ – Cruz Bay – Italian, pizza, 340-776-6524 Extra Virgin Bistro – $$$$ – Cruz Bay – Seafood, Italian, American, Mediterranean, 340-715-1864 High Tide Restaurant – $$$ – Cruz Bay – bar, seafood, American, Caribbean, 340-714-6169 La Tapa – $$$$ – Cruz Bay – seafood, Italian, Mediterranean, Spanish, 340-693-7755 THE BEST Street Food in Cruz Bay (Updated 2023) - Tripadvisor Web23 thg 5, 2022 · Woody's Seafood Saloon.

Visit Source →
TRIP.COM

Shopping itineraries in Kro-gu in March (updated in 2025)

Dave & Jerry's Island Steakhouse | The Lime Inn | The Beach Bar | Zozo’s at Caneel Bay | Rhumb Lines | Drink St. John | Sam & Jack's Deli | The Terrace Restaurant | The Banana Deck | Cafe Roma | Extra Virgin Bistro | Joe's Rum Hut | The Tap Room | Meada's Garden | Snorkels Bar & Grill | Sogo's | The Dugout at 420 to Center | High Tide Bar & Seafood Grill | Woody's Seafood Saloon | Yogurt In Love USVI | Our Market Smoothies | Ocean Grill | Estela's Classic | QUIET MON PUB | Margarita Phil's | Candi's Barbecue | Morgan's Mango Restaurant | Lucky Chops Lounge | St. John Catering & Mathayom Private Chefs | Sun Dog Cafe

Visit Source →
zszqi.theartoffloating.com

Guide to the Best Restaurants in St. John USVI - Fueled By Wanderlust WebThe Tap Room– $$ – St John Brewer’s bar, pub Uncle Joe’s BBQ– $ – BBQ Viva Cantina– $$$ – Mexican Woody’s Seafood Saloon– $ – bar, American, seafood, pub Cruz Bay Restaurants – Fine Dining Café Roma– $$$ – Cruz Bay – Italian, pizza, 340-776-6524 Extra Virgin Bistro– $$$$ – Cruz Bay – Seafood, Italian, American, Mediterranean, 340-715-1864 WebRequest a suite reservation for one of our St. John hotel rooms at our cozy, Caribbean bed and breakfast. Visit St. John's only true bed and breakfast, a boutique hotel for ADULTS. St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands, 00831.

Visit Source →
tropicalpropertiesvi.com

7 Best New Restaurants in St John | Blog

Extra Virgin Bistro stands out as a chic and stylish dining destination, drawing patrons with its sophisticated ambiance and tantalizing menu offerings. Specializing in Mediterranean-inspired cuisine crafted from locally sourced, organic ingredients, Extra Virgin Bistro elevates dining to an art form, blending bold flavors and creative culinary techniques to create dishes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. The restaurant's menu changes daily to reflect the seasonal bounty of St. John's local produce, ensuring each dish bursts with freshness and flavor.

Visit Source →
fqrq.moralesgroupinc.com

Food cruz bay st john St John Gourmet Market (Cruz Bay) - Tripadvisor St. John Dinner Delivery: STJ To Go - News of St. John Web26 thg 1, 2021 · STJ To Go currently offers dinner delivery from five Cruz Bay restaurants – 18°64, Banana Deck, Cruz Bay Landing, Extra Virgin Bistro and The Tap Room. (We’re adding more soon, so stay tuned!) We deliver seven days a week, and orders can be placed securely online 24 hours a day and up to 14 days in advance. chasten related words Webhttp://www.VInow.comCruz Bay is the main town on St. John.

Visit Source →
jrwnm.buyfromken.com

Café Roma – $$$ – Cruz Bay – Italian, pizza, 340-776-6524 Extra Virgin Bistro – $$$$ – Cruz Bay – Seafood, Italian, American, Mediterranean, 340-715-1864 High Tide Restaurant – $$$ – Cruz Bay – bar, seafood, American, Caribbean, 340-714-6169 La Tapa – $$$$ – Cruz Bay – seafood, Italian, … coalition matrix https://www.fueledbywanderlust.com/best-restaurants-st-john-usvi/ WebThis restaurant is located in Cruz Bay on St. John's in the Warfside Shopping area. We parked at Slim Jim's parking just a few steps away from the restaurant.

Visit Source →
bonvihospitalitygroup.com

Top 4 Fine Dining Experiences in St. John | Blog

Extra Virgin Bistro is proud to present an exclusive dining experience with our three-course tasting menu, featuring an appetizer, salad, and entrée for $100.00 per person. Catering to our youngest guests, children under five can choose delights from our Kid's Menu. We are committed to the ethos of local sustainability, with a garden of herbs flourishing on our premises and a preference for local fishermen's catch, proudly displaying their names alongside their contributions on our menu.

Visit Source →
cimmaronstjohn.com

Our Guide to the Top 8 Restaurants in St John

The Extra Virgin Bistro in St. John is dedicated to providing locally grown and sourced products, and the restaurant’s herbs are grown on-site. At this fine dining location, start off with a grapefruit margarita or Old San Juan before crispy calamari, potato gnocchi, lump crab cakes, or duck confit warm sweet potato salad. Then enjoy a premier entree, selecting from dishes such as local panko fried smashed conch, surf & turf, and cioppino.

Visit Source →
Town & Country

St John US Virgin Islands Travel Guide — Best St John USVI Rentals, Restaurants, Beaches, Hotels

Italian" may not be the first thing that leaps to mind when you think of the Caribbean, but you won't want to miss this local- and seasonally-focused spot (for more oceanic flare, try their sister restaurant 1864) The pastas, including the fan-favorite Wild Mushroom Pappardelle, are particular stand-outs, as are hearty salads and lavish entrees like Double Cut Pork Chops. Their signature martini is not to be missed.

Visit Source →
lumberyardstjohn.com

St John, U.S. Virgin Islands – Lumberyard

Italian” may not be the first thing that leaps to mind when you think of the Caribbean, but you won’t want to miss this local- and seasonally-focused spot (for more oceanic flare, try their sister restaurant 1864) The pastas, including the fan-favorite Wild Mushroom Pappardelle, are particular stand-outs, as are hearty salads and lavish entrees like Double Cut Pork Chops. Their signature martini is not to be missed.

Visit Source →
Marketplace Suites

Things to Do in St John USVI

Extra Virgin Bistro has garnered quite a following since they opened in 2015, and one main reason for that is that the fresh and delicious food at this Cruz Bay is epic. Produce can be hard to come by in the Virgin Islands and Extra Virgin gets around that by sourcing it and various herbs from the ones they grow on their rooftop. Most of their fish come from local fishermen, whose names they print on their menus.

Visit Source →
Love City Excursions

Our Favorite Saint John Restaurants

Extra Virgin Bistro- Another new restaurant on island and entering their second year Extra Virgin Bistro has quickly become a local favorite. Located up the road from Woody’s and across from the school ball field before you get to the round about, this restaurant is absolutely worth the short walk. With an amazing wine list and the best short rib I’ve ever had, you have to try this restaurant at least once.

Visit Source →
Blue Sky Luxury Travels

Five Hotspots for Fine Dining on St. John

Extra Virgin Bistro is perched on a hillside overlooking Cruz Bay, and it’s a bit away from the hustle and bustle of town. The chefs are dedicated to locally grown, and sourced products and they cure their own meats, make fresh pasta daily and grow their own herbs on their rooftop garden. They purchase fish from local fishermen and print their names on the daily menu with the fish they catch each day.

Visit Source →
ignitospace.com

restaurants st john usvi

This is especially true for popular places like ZoZo's, Morgan's Mango, and Extra Virgin Bistro. Our hours are 11 am - 8 pm Tuesday through Saturday. Located in the downtown Coral Bay, St. John, USVI. Find the best restaurants, food, and dining in St. John, Virgin Islands, make a reservation, or order delivery on Yelp: search reviews of 302 St. John restaurants by price, type, or location.

Visit Source →
The Hills, St. John

Why You Should Consider a Destination Wedding in the USVI

Children of the bride and groom or guests can enjoy their time in St. John too. There are several kid-friendly activities, such as swimming with dolphins and turtles, paddle boarding, sunset gazing and visiting the Virgin Islands National Park. There are also beaches that feature shallow tranquil waters, such as Cinnamon Bay Beach, which is perfect for little ones.

Visit Source →
stjohntour.com

Discovering the Best St. John, USVI, Bars and Restaurants

Extra Virgin Bistro offers a farm-to-table dining experience with a focus on fresh and locally sourced ingredients. The menu showcases dishes inspired by Mediterranean and Caribbean flavors, including grilled local fish, braised lamb shank, and roasted vegetable tart. The intimate setting and attentive service add to the overall dining experience.

Visit Source →
stjohnisland.com

Best Restaurants in St. John Island for Awesome Foodie Experiences

Extra Virgin Bistro is one of the romantic restaurants on the island, ideal for date night. Nestled in the heart of Cruz Bay, this farm-to-table restaurant features creative dishes made with locally sourced ingredients. The menu at Extra Virgin Bistro is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to sourcing only the freshest ingredients.

Visit Source →
Island Life Caribbean | The Best Of The Caribbean

15 Best US Virgin Islands Restaurants In 2025

Just about any restaurant can claim to utilize fresh ingredients but how many can say they grow the majority of their herbs onsite?. Extra Virgin Bistro guarantees the highest quality ingredients, including the fish that are delivered daily by local fishermen. As a result, the menu changes daily to reflect the local produce on hand.

Visit Source →
stjohnvillacompany.com

Where to eat on St. John

Extra Virgin Bistro is one of the romantic restaurants on the island, ideal for date night. Nestled in the heart of Cruz Bay, this farm-to-table restaurant features creative dishes made with locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant features a wide wine selection that includes both local and international wines to match the menu.

Visit Source →
The Honeyed

25 Most Breathtaking Things to Do in St John USVI

Head over to Extra Virgin Bistro for some of the best local fare in town. Best known for their tasty pasta dishes, Extra Virgin features locally grown herbs (most of which are actually grown on site) and fresh caught fish along with a variety of other decadent dishes. This one dinner venue you won’t want to miss during your trip.

Visit Source →
US Virgin Islands

Restaurants Perfect for a Romantic Rendezvous

Extra Virgin Bistro is so dedicated to locally grown and sourced products that most herbs served here are grown in the bistro’s on-site garden. And all cheeses, including creamy burrata and ricotta, are made in-house. Local fishermen even have their names printed on the menu next to the catch they brought in that day.

Visit Source →
St John Ultimate Villas

Best Eats in Cruz Bay

Cozy and cultured and eclectic Extra Virgin has the extra special feature of having their own rooftop and wall garden of herbs, greens and edible flowers. The pasta is handmade and they pride themselves on sourcing local ingredients. They also have fresh locally caught fish and feature new menus weekly.

Visit Source →
Sunshine Daydream Boat Charters

Top 3 Restaurants in St. John

In this blog, I will be sharing my top three favorite dining destinations in St. John: La Tapa, Morgan’s Mango, and Extra Virgin. These establishments not only offer delectable cuisine but also provide an ambiance that complements the island’s charm. Join me on this gastronomic journey through St. John!

Visit Source →
The Hills St. John

Top 8 Anniversary Getaway Ideas in the USVI (St. John Focus)

For most, it isn’t an anniversary celebration without a fancy dinner and drinks. The Extra Virgin Bistro in Cruz Bay, with its extensive wine menu and three course tasting menu, fits the bill nicely. For your date night, the bistro’s three-course tasting menu features appetizers, salads, and entrees.

Visit Source →
CORAL BAY VIEWS

Cruz Bay-St John, USVI- Restaurants & Bars

Extra Virgin Bistro is dedicated to locally grown and sourced products, so much so that they grow most of their our own herbs on site. They buy most of their fish from local fishermen and you will often find their names printed on the menu next to the fish they brought in that day.

Visit Source →
Fueled By Wanderlust

Best Restaurants in St John USVI: The Ultimate Food Guide (2025)

Visit Source →
villa-agel.com

Visitor Guide – Villa Agel Vacation Rental

Extra Virgin – dedicated to locally grown and sourced products, grow most of their herbs on site, and most of the fish from local fishermen (you will often find their names printed on our menu next to the fish they caught that day). www.extravirginbistro.com

Visit Source →
Finisterre

Top 10 Must-Try Restaurants in St. John, USVI: A Foodie's Guide to Island Dining

If you are looking for a more upscale dining experience, Extra Virgin Bistro is a must. It focuses on locally sourced produce and fresh seafood. The rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere make it the perfect place for a romantic dinner or a family gathering.

Visit Source →
Windspree Vacation Homes

U.S. Virgin Islands Archives | Page 4 of 11

He along with his partners currently own and manage Extra Virgin and will be opening the doors of their new venture soon. Their reputation has been built on providing fresh cuisine and it will continue in their new spot. Their roof top garden … Continued

Visit Source →
ritzycharters.com

BVI FOOD BARS AND NIGHTLIFE

Another USVI gem is the Extra Virgin Bistro in Cruz Bay, St John which has an outstanding reputation. Chefs combine locally grown ingredients with freshly caught fish, providing much-appreciated support for local businesses.

Visit Source →
Escape From New York

St. John, USVI, Part 1: Chicken(s) of the Sea

Although we had reservations for later in the week and hate to repeat a restaurant on vacation, Extra Virgin's gracious service, fabulous drinks, and excellent food definitely warrant doubling or even tripling up.

Visit Source →
Book VI

Restaurants -

New sister restaurant to Extra Virgin Bistro in Mongoose Junction, Cruz Bay. Named for St. John’s coordinates, 18/64 is now open for lunch, raw bar, and dinner.

Visit Source →
Honeymoons.com

Top Resorts, Tips & Packages

Whether you opt for the three-course tasting menu or choose one of the renowned main dishes, dinner at Extra Virgin Bistro is a must for a romantic evening.

Visit Source →
Enriching Pursuits

9 Day St. John Itinerary: Beach. Snorkel. Lime-N-Da-Coconut. Repeat.

When we come back, I would love to check out Lime Out (the floating taco bar) and Extra Virgin Bistro (which has great craft cocktails).

Visit Source →
Be My Travel Muse

How to Spend One Glorious Week in St John USVI

Visit Source →
sundancer.com

Island Info – Sundancer Villa St John US Virgin Islands

Visit Source →
montebaystjohn.com

St John Guide – Monte Bay Villa St John Vacation Rental

Visit Source →
destinationstjohn.com

Uncategorized – Destination: St. John

Visit Source →