"The pizza here was DELICIOUS. And the vibe and decor of the place were super cute! It’s conveniently right outside of the park with quick-ish service. Thankfully this was one of the few places that were still open/serving lunch when we got there. We sat outside with views of the mountains. There were a lot of mosquitos in the area, but we just had to keep the box closed while eating.

Our pizza had a lot of spinach which we forgot to exclude, so we just picked it off 😂 absolutely delicious!!

It was a cute area to walk around afterwards with ice cream spots and souvenir shops next door as well as other cute spots in the streets over. It was a cute and unique town!"

Maham Boghani

"After a long day exploring Yellowstone, we returned to Gardiner and decided to grab a bite at Yellowstone Pizza Company, conveniently located right by the North Entrance. The place was quite busy — though not necessarily because the food is incredible, but more likely because dining options in town are pretty limited.

We ordered a pepperoni and a veggie pizza. Both were decent — not amazing, but they got the job done after a full day in the park. What was a bit disappointing, though, was noticing that the pizzas are made using pre-baked crusts, which takes away from the freshness you’d expect (you can even see it clearly in one of my photos).

The service wasn’t particularly warm or attentive, and the prices felt high for what you get — especially considering it’s just pizza. It seems like the restaurant relies more on the steady stream of one-time tourists than on delivering a memorable experience or building loyalty.

I hope they put a bit more care into both the food and customer experience moving forward. The location is great, and with a little more effort, this spot could be much better."

Ali F.

"The pizza here was a bit pricey for the size and quality, but it was good and hit the spot. The staff was very friendly and very fast! I ordered mozzarella sticks, expecting 6-8…I think I got 12! The marinara was amazing that came with them. We got a Canadian pizza and the pineapple did not have a lot of flavor but the rest of it was good. We also got a mean lovers and that was wonderful! The crust has no seasonings or anything special so definitely get some kind of dipping sauce for that!"

Madison Schueth