Cafe Bagel
A beloved bagel shop renowned for its freshly baked bagels piled high with cream cheese and delicious breakfast sandwiches.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Cafe Bagel
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved bagel shop renowned for its freshly baked bagels piled high with cream cheese and delicious breakfast sandwiches.
"Cafe Bagel has the absolute best bagels in Venice—and quite possibly the finest in all of Sarasota County."
Arrive Early
Popular items sell out quickly; arriving early ensures you get your first choice.
Communicate Toasting Needs
Clearly state if you prefer your bagel toasted to avoid disappointment.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Bagel Shop
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Generous Cream Cheese Bagels
Experience bagels piled high with cream cheese, a true indulgence that's gone viral!
Best Bagels in Sarasota County
Praised by locals and critics alike, these bagels are worth a special trip.
Signature Breakfast Sandwiches
Savor delicious breakfast sandwiches on perfectly toasted bagels with quality ingredients.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Arrive Early
Popular items sell out quickly; arriving early ensures you get your first choice.
Communicate Toasting Needs
Clearly state if you prefer your bagel toasted to avoid disappointment.
Consider Ordering Ahead
Especially if you have dietary needs, ordering in advance can prevent errors.
Embrace the Generous Portions
Cream cheese portions are huge; consider sharing or ordering a mini size.
Tips
from all over the internet
Arrive Early
Popular items sell out quickly; arriving early ensures you get your first choice.
Communicate Toasting Needs
Clearly state if you prefer your bagel toasted to avoid disappointment.
Consider Ordering Ahead
Especially if you have dietary needs, ordering in advance can prevent errors.
Embrace the Generous Portions
Cream cheese portions are huge; consider sharing or ordering a mini size.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Cafe Bagel is highly praised for its exceptional bagels, generous cream cheese portions, and friendly service, making it a top spot in Sarasota County. While many rave about the breakfast sandwiches and unique flavors, some customers have noted issues with bagels running out early and occasional service hiccups when requests aren't met perfectly.
"Seriously the best bagels in the area! We drive from 30 min away because it’s worth the drive!
I love the spinach bagel and sundried tomato the most! The breakfast sandwiches on bagels are also awesome.
They have ice coffee and pastries too.
Everyone is very nice.
We love this place."
Amanda Williams
"Get here early, or you'll miss out on some of the best bagels you'll ever try locally. There are so many bagels along with cream cheese options and our favorite the Bacon egg and cheese! You will usually have a small wait for to go orders, but it's worth it! Hot and fresh bacon always crispy, cheese melty, and eggs cooked perfectly. Everybody's friendly, great prices, delicious food, and always a great way to start the day! This is become a regular spot for a quick breakfast. Jalapeno bacon egg and cheese bagel sandwich in the picture"
Shane H
"Being from NJ, this felt like home. Great Taylor ham, egg, & cheese sandwich. Even have Kaiser rolls if you prefer over a bagel. Bagels are excellent with many varieties to pick from. Generous portion of cream cheese for those who like a bagel with cream cheese 😋! Plenty of space to sit inside or out. Venice is lucky to have this place!"
Roy Bailey
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, many customers drive significant distances, stating the bagels are the best in the area and worth the trip.
Spinach, sundried tomato, and everything bagels are frequently mentioned as favorites.
Absolutely! Breakfast sandwiches on bagels are a popular item, with the Bacon Egg and Cheese receiving high praise. [^data, ^R2]
The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating. It can get busy, so arriving early is recommended, especially for popular items. [^data, ^R4]
Yes, they ask if you want your bagel toasted. However, some customers have reported issues with the toasting not being adequate or the cheese not melting.
Yes, the portions are famously generous, often described as 'piled high.' Some find them overwhelmingly large. +1
Yes, they offer muffins, breakfast and deli sandwiches, salads, and fresh baked goods. [^R2, ^tripadvisor_data]
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The Best Restaurants in Venice, Florida
Tamiami Trail, Venice, (941) 493-2095, ordercafebagelvenice.com. We're saying it: Café Bagel has the absolute best bagels in Venice—and, in fact, makes the list of top spots for the circular snack in Sarasota County. Warm, chewy bagels come with an assortment of spreads or can be made into a breakfast sandwich.
Venice, Florida's Best-Kept Dining Secrets
Tamiami Trail, Café Bagel has quietly earned a reputation that extends far beyond Venice’s city limits. According to local food critics and countless devoted customers, this unassuming spot serves the absolute best bagels in Venice—and quite possibly the finest in all of Sarasota County.
Best Breakfast in Venice, FL (2025) — 20 Top Places!
This cafe in the city center is where you can have the best breakfast in Venice for its delicious bagels, muffins and other baked goods, plus early-morning platters.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit