
Mancy's Italian Grill
A relaxed Italian trattoria known for its wood-fired pizzas, authentic pasta dishes, and sophisticated yet cozy atmosphere.

Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Mancy's Italian Grill

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A relaxed Italian trattoria known for its wood-fired pizzas, authentic pasta dishes, and sophisticated yet cozy atmosphere.
"From the attentive service to the phenomenal cheesecake, Mancy's Italian Grill is a must-visit for a delightful dining experience."
Reserve Your Table
Make reservations in advance to ensure a timely seating experience, especially during peak hours.
Must-Try Menu Items
Don't miss popular dishes like Brussel sprouts, Caprese salad, Vesuvio, Tiramisu, Pollo Picatta, and Lasagna Pinwheels.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Authentic Italian Flavors
Indulge in delicious, authentic Italian cuisine, with highlights like Marsala and Chicken Parmesan that keep guests coming back for more.

Wood-Fired Pizzas
Savor artisanal wood-fired pizzas, from classic pepperoni to unique creations, all crafted with a perfect crust and flavorful toppings.

Cozy & Sophisticated Atmosphere
Enjoy a relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere, ideal for intimate dinners, celebrations, or casual meetups with friends.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Reserve Your Table
Make reservations in advance to ensure a timely seating experience, especially during peak hours.
Must-Try Menu Items
Don't miss popular dishes like Brussel sprouts, Caprese salad, Vesuvio, Tiramisu, Pollo Picatta, and Lasagna Pinwheels.
Visit During Opening Hours
Consider visiting during opening hours to avoid waiting for a table.
Explore the Wine Bottle Shop
Discover a fully stocked bottle shop with expert recommendations for wines to complement your meal.
Tips
from all over the internet
Reserve Your Table
Make reservations in advance to ensure a timely seating experience, especially during peak hours.
Must-Try Menu Items
Don't miss popular dishes like Brussel sprouts, Caprese salad, Vesuvio, Tiramisu, Pollo Picatta, and Lasagna Pinwheels.
Visit During Opening Hours
Consider visiting during opening hours to avoid waiting for a table.
Explore the Wine Bottle Shop
Discover a fully stocked bottle shop with expert recommendations for wines to complement your meal.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Mancy's Italian Grill offers a sophisticated dining experience with excellent service and a cozy atmosphere, though some find the food to be inconsistent in flavor and temperature. While many rave about signature dishes and desserts, a few reviews mention blandness and issues with food quality. The wine selection and overall ambiance are frequently praised.
"In all of my 661 reviews of restaurants i gotta say this is one of the few times I give a restaurant a 9.5 outta 10. We came here on a whim from Michigan for a date night and from the beginning we knew it was the right choice. Our waitress Dina was very attentive and made sure we had water and bread throughout the night. It had a great crust and soft inside. The butter was flavorful and whipped with herbs that you could taste. The oil that came with it was ok. I'd stick to the butter. I got the chicken picatta and it was packed with flavor. That lemon herb butter sauce was perfect and balanced the dish. For dessert got the limoncello cheesecake and it was phenomenal. Such a wonderful date night and great restaurant. Definitely coming back."
Jerry Karadesheh
"Beautiful restaurant and vibe. Food was kind of bland. Waiter showed no sense of urgency. Waited over 10 minutes for water and bread. Gnats were conversing with us while eating as well. My first time here was a 4/10. I ordered the short rib pasta and it wasn’t served hot."
Qualyn C
"Highly recommend reservations *The food was amazing! Started with the appetizer which we chose the Brussel sprouts and the Caprese both were delicious. The vesuvio was amazing the shrimp had such a great texture and flavor the sausage in this dish can be on the spicy side well balanced with the sauce though. Last we had tiramisu omg delicious. Over all great food great service great atmosphere."
Destiny Dotson
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
It is highly recommended to make reservations in advance to ensure a timely seating experience, especially during busy times.
Guests frequently recommend trying the Brussel sprouts appetizer, Caprese salad, Vesuvio dish, Tiramisu dessert, Pollo Picatta, and Lasagna Pinwheels.
Yes, Mancy's Italian Grill has a well-stocked bottle shop with wine experts and also offers wine on tap.
Yes, the cozy and sophisticated atmosphere is perfect for celebrating special occasions or enjoying a date night.
Yes, they offer happy hour deals on woodfired pizza, draft & craft beer, cocktails, and tap wines from Monday through Friday, 4-6 PM.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Highest-rated Italian Restaurants in Toledo, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4.0 / 5 (192 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.0/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (3.5/5), Atmosphere (4.5/5)- Type of cuisine: Pizza, Italian- Price: $$ - $$$- Address: 5453 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43623-2817- Read more on Tripadvisor. You may also like:Cities with the fastest-growing home prices in the Toledo metro area
5 Excellent Italian Restaurants Near Toledo
When you step inside Mancy’s Italian Grill, you’ll discover a sophisticated restaurant with modern decor and an open kitchen. The wood-fired pizzas are a popular menu option. Consider the pollo, which has roasted chicken, bechamel, oven-roasted tomatoes, green Italian olives, mozzarella, red pepper, and fresh basil.
8 Awesome Toledo Restaurants To Grab A Bite At
This beautiful restaurant has a relaxed vibe that pairs perfectly with its delicious food. With housemade pasta and hand-cut steaks, you know that the food will be top-notch!. Be sure to also check out their fully stocked bottle shop, with friendly wine experts who can help you choose a bottle you’ll love.
11 Exceptional Places to Get Wine in the Toledo Area
This is another Italian restaurant in town with a wonderful wine selection. Order a red or white by the glass, or order from their new “wine on tap” list!. This trend-setting method of wine delivery provides a single glass of fresh wine, just as the winemaker intended it to be.
Dog-Friendly Patios: A Toledo Guide
419-882-9229 5453 Monroe St.mancysitalian.com Monday, 4pm-9pm; Tuesday-Thursday, 12pm-2:30pm, 4pm-9pm; Friday, 12pm-2:30pm, 4pm-10pm; Saturday, 4pm-10pm. Enjoy flatbreads, pasta, pizza and more at this Italian trattoria.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit