Home Slice Pizza
A buzzing downtown spot renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza with creative toppings and a lively, multi-level atmosphere.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Home Slice Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A buzzing downtown spot renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza with creative toppings and a lively, multi-level atmosphere.
"Outstanding pizza! Not recalled a pizza in 5+ years that matches!"
Check Busyness Before Visiting
Call ahead to gauge wait times, especially during peak hours, to ensure a smoother visit.
Upgrade Your Pizza
Add steak or other toppings to your favorite pizzas for an enhanced flavor experience.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza, Italian
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Unique Pizza Creations
Explore adventurous pizzas like the potato pizza or the DeCarlo. They offer a delightful twist on classic pies.
Vibrant Multi-Level Ambiance
Enjoy a lively atmosphere across two stories, complete with inviting patios for a relaxed dining experience.
Exceptional Italian Subs & Sides
Beyond pizza, discover incredible Italian subs and highly praised sides like cheese bread, loved by many.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Check Busyness Before Visiting
Call ahead to gauge wait times, especially during peak hours, to ensure a smoother visit.
Upgrade Your Pizza
Add steak or other toppings to your favorite pizzas for an enhanced flavor experience.
Upstairs Bar for Leisure
Consider the upstairs bar area for a more relaxed and leisurely dining experience.
Don't Forget the Wings!
Pair your delicious pizzas with their must-try wings for a complete meal.
Tips
from all over the internet
Check Busyness Before Visiting
Call ahead to gauge wait times, especially during peak hours, to ensure a smoother visit.
Upgrade Your Pizza
Add steak or other toppings to your favorite pizzas for an enhanced flavor experience.
Upstairs Bar for Leisure
Consider the upstairs bar area for a more relaxed and leisurely dining experience.
Don't Forget the Wings!
Pair your delicious pizzas with their must-try wings for a complete meal.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Home Slice Pizza garners significant praise for its unique and delicious pizzas, with many highlighting the creative toppings and thin, crispy crust. Diners also rave about the friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere across its two levels and patios. While most experiences are overwhelmingly positive, some have noted issues with the dining area being too hot or dissatisfaction with paper plates and plastic utensils during busy periods.
"When I want a pizza that isn’t the usual, this is my go too. My personal favorite here is the potato pizza and its description reads ; A favorite blend of red skin and garlic mashed potatoes, bacon and cheddar cheese Served with a side of ranch or sour cream.
Upgrade this masterpiece for $1.50 to add Steak and Al sauce. And the pictures in this review are of just that. Upgraded with the steak and a-1. Another favorite we are always getting is the DeCarlo ; Cream cheese, five cheese blend, BBQ sauce, bacon, chicken, cheddar cheese and drizzled with a little hot sauce. Amazing pizzas.
I would highly suggest you call to see if they are extremely busy as some peak hours have really long wait times. And also that plays into if you want to come visit in person as it is downtown and busy hours apply with it getting harder to park."
Alexa Keel (Lexxi)
"Outstanding pizza! Not recalled a pizza in 5+ years that matches! Still have my faves but they get an A+ in (just) pizza, service, pizza, and overall quality in food and service. My atmosphere is also a 5/5 - try them-worth it! 2 pizzas shown taken to Hensville to watch the game! Easy walk!"
Matt N
"Holy smokes. The best pizza? I don’t wanna go too far but WOW! Don’t sleep on the cheese bread. Staff was super warm and friendly. 5 star experience!"
Samantha Hondorp
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The Potato Pizza and the DeCarlo are frequently recommended for their unique and delicious flavor combinations.
Yes, Home Slice Pizza features patios where guests can enjoy their meal, adding to the dining experience.
With its two stories and patios, it offers a lively atmosphere suitable for dining with friends and family.
Yes, they offer slices daily for a quick and convenient bite, perfect for a solo lunch.
While not explicitly detailed, they do offer cheese pizza and a 'Vegan Cheese' option on their slices menu.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Restaurant Week in Toledo: A Taste of the World
Participants in the 2022 Restaurant Week Toledo include: Adams Street Café, Balance Pan Asian Grille, Basil Pizza & Wine Bar, The Blarney Irish Pub, BREW Coffee Bar, The Brick Bar, Charlie’s Homemade Ice Cream & Burgers, The Chop House, Ciao, Deet’s BBQ, Fowl & Fodder Downtown, Hannon’s Block, Home Slice Pizza, Inside the Five Brewing Co., Jera’s Heavenly Sweet, The Leaf and Seed, Local Roots Juice Co., Loma Linda, Maddie & Bella Coffee Roasters, Mancy’s Ideal, Mancy’s Steakhouse, Manhattan’s Pub ‘n Cheer, Nagoya Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi, Poco Piatti, Rayoka Japanese Steakhouse, Real Seafood Company, Registry Bistro, Rosie’s Italian Grille, Shorty’s True American Roadhouse, Sidon Lebanese Grille & Bakery, SIP Coffee, Souk Mediterranean Kitchen & Bar, Stella’s Restaurant & Bar, The Whitehouse Inn, Ye Olde Durty Bird and Zia’s Italian.
Dog-Friendly Patios: A Toledo Guide
419-724-7437 28 S St. Clair St. homeslice419.com Sunday-Thursday, 11am-11pm; Friday-Saturday, 11am-2am Grab your favorite authentic New York style pizza or sandwich at any of their locations.
10 Best Toledo, OH Pizzerias
Home Slice Pizza delivers top-quality New York-style pizza to all of Toledo. Their thin crust is cooked to perfection, with a lovely combo of sauce, cheese, and toppings to round it out. When you go to Home Slice Pizza you can rest assured that you will receive only the finest service and eat only the finest pizza.
Support These Local Restaurants While Dining on Toledo's Best Patios
When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie, that's amore" (aka love in Italian as sang by crooner Dean Martin way back in the day). Want a slice of an authentic, flavorful, delightful dish?. Hit up Home Slice Pizza because they got your order downtown whether it's just a piece or an entire pie.
Best Food and Places to Eat on the I-80 East
For driving professionals in search of the best restaurants on the I-80 East, Home Slice Pizza is a paradise for pizza lovers. Their menu imaginative and will tantalize your taste buds. A visit here wouldn't be complete without savoring their famous loaded potato pizza.
Northwest Ohio Foodie Trail: Where To Eat In Downtown Toledo
Whether you want a quick slice of pizza or a whole pizza, Home Slice Pizza has you covered. This family-run pizza has been serving thin-crust “New York” style pizza since 2006. Grab a slice daily for just $2!
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit