Rick's New York Pizza of Tarpon Springs
A beloved pizzeria serving authentic NY-style pizza and classic Italian-American dishes with a strong emphasis on friendly, attentive service. [^R2, ^...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Rick's New York Pizza of Tarpon Springs
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved pizzeria serving authentic NY-style pizza and classic Italian-American dishes with a strong emphasis on friendly, attentive service. +1
"The pizza crust at Rick's was awesome - to the extent that it almost doesn't matter what you order to put on the pizza, it was amazing. "
Ask for Recommendations
Don't hesitate to ask for recommendations, especially from staff like Stephanie, who are knowledgeable about the menu.
Try the Garlic Knots
Don't miss the garlic knots; they're a highly praised side that comes with pasta dishes and are considered a must-try.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(727) 934-5297
Address
905 E Klosterman Rd, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689, USA
Website
ricksnyspizza.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic NY-Style Pizza
Experience a taste of New York with their authentic, brick-oven pizza, hailed as some of the best outside of NYC. The crust is a standout, praised by pizza aficionados.
Flavorful Pasta Dishes
Beyond pizza, discover rich and flavorful pasta dishes, with Chicken Alfredo and Shrimp Caesar Salad receiving special mentions for their deliciousness.
Exceptional Service
The staff, including notable mentions like Stephanie and Charles, are known for their friendly demeanor and extensive menu knowledge, enhancing the dining experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Calzone
Chicken Parmesan
Spaghetti
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Ask for Recommendations
Don't hesitate to ask for recommendations, especially from staff like Stephanie, who are knowledgeable about the menu.
Try the Garlic Knots
Don't miss the garlic knots; they're a highly praised side that comes with pasta dishes and are considered a must-try. +1
Clarify Toppings/Ingredients
If you have specific preferences, such as no meat, clarify your order to avoid any mix-ups with toppings or ingredients.
Lunch Menu Deals
Take advantage of their lunch menu, which offers great prices and deals, running until 4 PM.
Tips
from all over the internet
Ask for Recommendations
Don't hesitate to ask for recommendations, especially from staff like Stephanie, who are knowledgeable about the menu.
Try the Garlic Knots
Don't miss the garlic knots; they're a highly praised side that comes with pasta dishes and are considered a must-try. +1
Clarify Toppings/Ingredients
If you have specific preferences, such as no meat, clarify your order to avoid any mix-ups with toppings or ingredients.
Lunch Menu Deals
Take advantage of their lunch menu, which offers great prices and deals, running until 4 PM.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Rick's New York Pizza garners praise for its authentic NY-style pizza and flavorful pasta dishes, often complemented by excellent and friendly customer service. However, some diners have reported significant quality dips in recent times, with complaints about tough dough, flavorless sauce, and inconsistent topping distribution, leading to disappointment given the price. +2
"Great pizza…we had the tavern pizza both nights…sat up at the bar with a glass of wine, husband had a beer…excellent pizza and service. Staff is very friendly and a bunch of hard workers!
We stayed at the Quality Inn next door, would be nice if Rick’s offered a 10% discount to Quality Inn guests…😀"
Sue S
"First of all the service was amazing!! I wish I remembered the gentleman’s name that took our order and helped us, but we had just drove down from Savannah and my brain was a mess! The food was so good, and my my the cannolis were {muah}. Definitely stop in and give them a try. If we find our way back to Tampa we will be back here!"
Demia Beaver
"I really enjoyed coming here for lunch with my husband and father. We each picked a different items off of the menu. My father did a shrimp Caesar salad which he absolutely loved, my husband did a 14” supreme pizza which so hot and the crust was to die for, I did the chicken Alfredo which was excellent and came out so hot! They have the best garlic rolls which took me by surprise that it came with the pasta. The man who sat us was so sweet and always came to check in on our table, the atmosphere was quiet but that’s what we enjoyed. There lunch menu is until for which is amazing and bad so many great prices and deals. They have different pastries and cookies, we absolutely loved the assorted box of cookies. We will definitely be coming back for more:) thank you so much for an amazing lunch’s"
Katheryn Kriegsmann
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Rick's New York Pizza is most celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, which many consider to be among the best outside of NYC. They also receive praise for their pasta dishes and garlic knots. +2
Yes, the staff, including individuals like Stephanie, are known for their excellent menu knowledge and are happy to provide recommendations to enhance your dining experience.
Besides pizza, popular choices include flavorful pasta dishes like Chicken Alfredo and Spaghetti, as well as appetizers like garlic knots and desserts like cannoli. +1
Rick's offers a lunch menu with great prices and deals, available until 4 PM, making it a good option for an affordable midday meal.
While many praise the pizza, some recent reviews indicate inconsistencies, with complaints about tough dough and flavorless sauce. It's advisable to clarify specific order details.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit