Pizza Time
A no-frills, authentic New York-style pizzeria in St. Augustine known for massive slices and friendly service. A must-try for pizza lovers!
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Pizza Time
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A no-frills, authentic New York-style pizzeria in St. Augustine known for massive slices and friendly service. A must-try for pizza lovers!
"Ranked as one of the best pizza spots in the US, this place offers a true taste of Brooklyn."
Cash Only - Be Prepared
Pizza Time is a cash-only establishment. An ATM is available inside, but it charges a fee.
Order Quickly
The service is fast; be ready to order to avoid feeling rushed by the efficient staff.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(904) 819-0133
Address
124 St George St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Brooklyn-Style Pizza
Experience massive, New York-style pizza slices crafted with fresh ingredients and a perfect crust, a true taste of Brooklyn in St. Augustine.
Unique Slice Selection Experience
Choose your perfect slice from a vibrant display of freshly made pizzas at the counter, a dynamic and delicious way to order.
Must-Try Garlic Knots
Don't miss the highly-praised, warm garlic knots, often served with a side of pizza sauce for dipping.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Cash Only - Be Prepared
Pizza Time is a cash-only establishment. An ATM is available inside, but it charges a fee.
Order Quickly
The service is fast; be ready to order to avoid feeling rushed by the efficient staff.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
For a shorter wait and a more relaxed experience, consider visiting outside of peak dining times.
Explore Beyond Pizza
In addition to pizza, try their signature garlic rolls and potato balls for a complete meal.
Tips
from all over the internet
Cash Only - Be Prepared
Pizza Time is a cash-only establishment. An ATM is available inside, but it charges a fee.
Order Quickly
The service is fast; be ready to order to avoid feeling rushed by the efficient staff.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
For a shorter wait and a more relaxed experience, consider visiting outside of peak dining times.
Explore Beyond Pizza
In addition to pizza, try their signature garlic rolls and potato balls for a complete meal.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Pizza Time is lauded for its authentic Brooklyn-style pizza, with many praising the fresh ingredients and delicious crust, as well as the friendly service and unique counter-selection ordering. However, some diners find the prices to be high for the quality, and the cash-only policy can be an inconvenience.
"The staff were very helpful and kind! Absolutely fantastic pizza!! The sauce was absolutely perfect, not too thick and seasoned beautifully. The crust was excellent, not overly thick and didn’t taste heavy. Highly recommend the garlic rolls! They include warm pizza sauce for dipping so it was really easy to run out quickly!"
Aaron Darling
"Our family recommended us this place. Pizza was pretty good. However, if you coming from NYC/NJ areas, you gotta lower your expectations when you hear second best pizza in the US. The place is cash only. A bit pricey, but had to try it! 5 stars for decent pizza!"
cristina marin
"Cash only! Which I actually love… as long as I don’t have to pay the tax 😄.
There’s an ATM on site, but it charges a fee to withdraw. 💰🤑
Well… a trip to St. Augustine isn’t cheap anyway!
The pizza has an authentic, delicious flavor with a great variety to choose from. Staff are super friendly and welcoming. 👌🏻❤️
Honestly, it was really tasty, but I think the prices could be a bit more reasonable. Still, a delicious and memorable experience ✌🏻"
Sasan Maj
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Pizza Time is a cash-only establishment. There is an ATM on-site, but it does charge a fee for withdrawals.
Besides their famous New York-style pizza by the slice, patrons highly recommend the garlic knots and potato balls.
Yes, Pizza Time offers a variety of vegan and vegetarian-friendly pizza options.
Customers consistently praise the friendly, charismatic, and welcoming staff, contributing to a positive dining experience.
You select your slice directly from the display counter, and they heat it up for you. Be prepared to order quickly due to fast service.
Many reviewers, including those from the New York area, confirm that Pizza Time offers authentic New York-style pizza with a great crust and fresh toppings.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The Best St. Augustine Restaurants
Sometimes nothing satisfies the stomach quite like a slice of New York pizza. If you're looking for a quick bite (especially after a night out), this spot is a winner, hawking “the biggest pizza in town,” with 20-inch round pies as well as a selection of NY Pizzeria staples like cheese calzones, house-made arancini (rice balls and Italian potato rolls), and strombolis. For a real treat, get some garlic knots and a meat lover's pie with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatballs, and cheese.
Restaurants in Downtown St. Augustine Are Steps Away from Our Inns
White’s Seafood & Spirits · Old City House Inn & Restaurants · One Twenty-Three Burger House · Pizza Time · Pizzalley’s · Preserved Restaurant · Prince of Wales · Prohibition Kitchen · Raintree Restaurant · Sakada Steak House · Sangrias Wine & Piano Bar · Spanish Bakery · St. Augustine Seafood Company · Taberna Del Caballo · The Blue Hen Cafe · The Chatsworth Publick House · The Cuban Cafe & Bakery · The Floridian · The Oak Room Restaurant & Lounge · White Lion Restaurant & Pub
Best Pizza in St. Augustine | The Local
Pizza Time serves Brooklyn-style pizza both by the slice and as whole made-to-order pies. Each pizza is crafted using only the freshest ingredients and a true New York-style crust for the perfect bite every time. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick family meal or just want to enjoy a slice as you walk around St. George Street, Pizza Time never disappoints.
6 Amazing Restaurants to Grab Lunch in Downtown St. Augustine
Pizza Time, another pizza hot spot in St. Augustine, offers authentic Italian pizza!. They provide excellent service, fresh slices, and vegan/vegetarian-friendly options!. Whether you like pepperoni polka-dotted pizzas or fresh salad pizzas, Pizza Time has got you covered.
17 Best Restaurants In Saint Augustine, FL, You Shouldn't Miss
If looking for one of the restaurants in Saint Augustine serving up some of the best Brooklyn-style pizza, head to Pizza Time. Pizza Time sells pizza by the slice or a whole pie. It is one of the restaurants in downtown Saint Augustine on St. George Street.
5 Delicious St. Augustine, FL Pizza Restaurants To Try
To many, Pizza Time is the defining pizza place in St. Augustine. This downtown favorite is highly acclaimed, winning awards for years and years back-to-back. Most notably, TripAdvisor ranked Pizza Time as the second best pizza spot in the country in 2015.
Where To Find The Best Pizza
In recent years, Pizza Time earned national acclaim from TripAdvisor by ranking as the second best pizza place in United States. Pizza Time is located in the heart of St. George Street, a busy pedestrian shopping destination in the Oldest City.
Best Restaurants in St. Augustine
Located on George St., this local pizza shop has a line outside the small place when it gets closer to dinnertime. The restaurant serves pizza similar to that of New York. There are vegetarian options toppings for those who don't eat meat.
Visiting St. Augustine with Kids - A Family Travel Guide
This was some really delicious pizza and this is coming from someone who eats a lot of pizza. More of the NY style, the toppings were fresh and the crust was crunchy with tons of flavor.
The Best Places to Eat in St. Augustine, Florida
Unforgettable pizza with generous and creative Italian-entree-style toppings in a fast-casual environment. See the slices before your order. The line moves quickly!
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit