Prairie Pie
A charming bakery offering unique sweet and savory pies, creative cookies, and gourmet pizzas with a cozy atmosphere.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Prairie Pie
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A charming bakery offering unique sweet and savory pies, creative cookies, and gourmet pizzas with a cozy atmosphere.
"The recipes are original, visually appealing, and taste fantastic!"
Pizza Nights
Visit on Friday or Saturday nights for pizza by the slice starting at 5pm.
Cocktail Bar
Explore the quaint bar in the back for cocktail or local beer selections.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Bakery
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Signature Sweet & Savory Pies
Indulge in a wide array of pies, from sweet flavors like Honey Sea Salt to savory Chicken Pot Pie. All made with artisanal butter crust.
Unique Cookie Creations
Explore creative cookie flavors such as Rosemary Shortbread and Nori Black Sesame Chocolate. Perfect with tea or as a small treat.
Gourmet Pizza & Cocktails
Enjoy gourmet pizzas with unique toppings and a chewy sourdough crust, complemented by creative cocktails and local beers.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Pizza Nights
Visit on Friday or Saturday nights for pizza by the slice starting at 5pm.
Cocktail Bar
Explore the quaint bar in the back for cocktail or local beer selections.
Herbaceous Pot Pie
The chicken pot pie is rich in herb flavor, a great choice for herb lovers.
Mini Pies for Gifting
Consider mini pies as stocking stuffers or host gifts.
Tips
from all over the internet
Pizza Nights
Visit on Friday or Saturday nights for pizza by the slice starting at 5pm.
Cocktail Bar
Explore the quaint bar in the back for cocktail or local beer selections.
Herbaceous Pot Pie
The chicken pot pie is rich in herb flavor, a great choice for herb lovers.
Mini Pies for Gifting
Consider mini pies as stocking stuffers or host gifts.
Cookie & Tea Pairing
Rosemary Shortbread Cookie complements warm tea exceptionally well.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Prairie Pie is highly praised for its inventive and delicious sweet and savory pies, with a standout flaky butter crust that reviewers can't get enough of. Customers also rave about their gourmet pizzas and creative cocktail offerings. While most reviews are glowing, a few diners noted issues with burnt crusts on pizzas.
"Great restaurant, that's super inviting. The person that helped me with my order was very friendly and easy to talk with! I got 2 of each of their frozen pot pies and 2 pieces of their honey sea salt pie and pecan pie. The dessert pies are unmatched from anything I've ever had, I'd highly recommend getting either one. So far I've only had the chicken pot pie and it was phenomenal. They have cooking instructions that come with them to make it easy. I can't wait to try the other type I got. This place has made it on to my list of "must visit" for when I'm in town. They're awesome and definitely worth checking out!"
Alex Johansson
"My first time trying a pot pie, my husband grew up eating them and was looking forward to the Chicken pot pie. We ordered two, but they only had one left so I ordered the Curry vegetable and I am so glad. They were both absolutely delicious, but I loved the curry vegetable. The flavor was impeccable."
Nora S
"The two savory pies we had were excellent. I had a chicken pot pie and it was delicious. My wife had the vegetable curry pot pie. She says it had the right degree of spice. We both thought the crusts were delicious.
We had a slice of apple pie but it was not as good. I thought it was too sweet and my wife didn’t like the crust.
Overall it was very good."
James Nahach
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Customers highly recommend the Honey Sea Salt pie, Chicken Pot Pie, and their gourmet pizzas. The Rosemary Shortbread Cookie is also a unique treat.
Yes, they offer delicious savory pies like Chicken Pot Pie, Beef & Mushroom, and Bianca broccoli, as well as gourmet pizzas.
While not explicitly stated, they offer a vegetarian pie and many cookie flavors that might be adaptable. It's best to inquire directly.
Pizza by the slice is available on Friday and Saturday nights, starting at 5pm.
Yes, you can order full-size pies, mini pies, and slices to go. They also provide cooking instructions for frozen pot pies.
They have a selection of wine, local beers on tap, and creative cocktails, including a Hot Buttered Rum.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
What to Eat in Springfield, MO According to Local Foodies
When it comes to indulgences, Katie Baker rarely gives in, but when she does, she always goes for Prairie Pie. “I don’t know what she does,” Baker says. “It’s just pie, but pie that your grandma would make—like, the best pie ever.” Baker and her husband frequent Cherry Picker Package x Fare, where Baker can’t resist snagging a piece of Eleanor Taylor’s inventively flavored concoctions packed into a traditional butter crust.
From Pie to Ice Cream: 6 Desserts You Have To Try In Springfield
Right in the heart of downtown Springfield, Prairie Pie emerges as a dessert haven that demands recognition. Here, you'll discover an extensive selection of delectable fruit pies, hand pies, and cookies to appease your sweet cravings. Whether you're in the mood for a warm cup of coffee, a glass of wine, or a delightful sweet treat, Prairie Pie is the perfect destination to satisfy your dessert desires.
Shop local this holiday season with Feast’s Springfield gift guide
Packaged individually or boxed as a set of four, Prairie Pie’s mini pies make for an ideal stocking stuffer or host gift. Snag one or more in flavors such as honey-sea salt, lemon chess, pecan or chocolate-peppermint online, at the brick-and-mortar bakery or at local retailers, including Mama Jean’s Natural Market and Culture Counter. (Photo courtesy of Prairie Pie)
7 places to eat fall-inspired dishes right now in Springfield
The closest thing to a classic buttery homemade potpie that grandma or your mom would make is the chicken potpie from Prairie Pie. Yes, she makes amazing, sweet pies but her savory options are also delicious. Owner Eleanor Taylor is known for her flakey all-butter crust, which is the cradle of this comforting dish.
Best Treats in Springfield, MO
The holidays are upon us and a staple at everyone’s feast always includes pie. Located out of Vito’s Kitchen in downtown Springfield, Eleanor Taylor is crafting handmade pies using seasonal and local ingredients. They offer a wide variety of flavors in 10-inch full-size pies or even mini pies.
10 Date Nights in Springfield, MO
Prairie Pie When it comes to date night in Springfield, one of my absolute favorite spots has to be Prairie Pie. My wife and I have spent countless memorable evenings savoring their delectable creations. Now, what makes this place truly special?.
Highest-rated Restaurants With Outdoor Seating in Springfield, According to Yelp
- Rating: 5.0/5 (5 reviews)- Address: 307 S Jefferson Ave Springfield, MO 65806- Categories: Bakeries, Desserts, Sandwiches- Read more on Yelp
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit