Spearfish Grille takes pride in offering the locals and visitors to Siesta Key some of the freshest locally caught seafood in the area. Since March 2018, Spearfish has been serving creative interpretations of local ingredients inside an atmosphere that is both modern and respectful of the community’s past. The menu puts new twists on your favorite seafood classics, from starters like cheesy Gulf shrimp and grits or crispy fried grouper cheeks to entrees like middle grounds fresh tacos or the fried oyster po boy.

SPEARFISH GRILLE, nestled in the scenic Siesta Key Marina at 1265 Old Stickney Point Road, is a seafood haven that beckons both locals and visitors seeking an exceptional dining experience. Its idyllic setting overlooking the inland waterway and bustling marina sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. However, recent parking experiences adjacent to the restaurant have raised concerns, detracting from an otherwise stellar dining outing.

It’s hard to get closer to the waves than at Spearfish Grille, located right inside of Siesta Key Marina!. They’ve been serving locals and visitors alike since 2018, as a proven local staple with friendly staff and spectacular fresh local fish. Enjoy menu options like the Caribbean Chicken Sammy, the Marina Burger, and the Gulf Shrimp Po-Boy, and finish it all off with a slice of delicious Siesta Key Lime Pie!

For a more eclectic dining experience, venture to the Spearfish Grille located at Safe Harbor Marina. This quaint venue draws you in with its vibrant ambiance and a menu filled with innovative dishes that celebrate the local fishing heritage. Offering freshly caught seafood prepared with an inventive flair, Spearfish Grille doses each plate with creativity that resonates with the laid-back island vibe.

When you wade westward along the canal that follows Stickney Point Road, you’ll coast into the Safe Harbor Siesta Key docks outside of Spearfish Grille. This casual waterfront restaurant is a picturesque spot to stop in for an easygoing afternoon meal. Enjoy the modern farmhouse décor, and street food-style plating, and get a true taste of the Gulf when you order local, fresh-caught seafood.

As you might guess by the name, Spearfish Grille is your destination for incredible seafood. Opened in March 2018, Spearfish Grille has already made a name for itself thanks to the welcoming owners and staff, quaint atmosphere, and unique interpretations of classic seafood dishes. Come try out the crispy fried grouper cheeks, cheesy Gulf shrimp and grits, Cuban sammy, and more.

1265 Old Stickney Point Road, Sarasota, (941) 349-1970, spearfishgrille.com. Tucked into a small space at Siesta Key Marina, Spearfish is a no-frills shack where your server can fetch you an estimate on your boat repairs and serve up a mean grouper sandwich, too. The shop sells fish and shellfish straight from the Gulf, with an emphasis on hogfish, blue crabs and shrimp.

Last, but certainly not least, on our list of the top Siesta Key seafood restaurants is Spearfish Grille. Nestled inside the heart of the island at the Tropical Breeze Resort, Spearfish Grille is a hidden gem worth discovering. Spearfish Grille prides itself on serving locally sourced, sustainable seafood in a casual, island-themed setting.

For a true local experience, head to Spearfish Grille, where the seafood is as fresh as it gets. Their Blackened Grouper Sandwich and Ahi Tuna Poke Bowl are crowd-pleasers, and their laid-back outdoor seating area makes it a perfect spot to unwind. Address: 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242Phone: (941) 349-1971

Here you can have a delicious meal and look into the natural beauty of the Gulf Of Mexico. The restaurant will give a vibe like it is situated on a deck, where you were fishing and now having those fish as lunch or dinner. Spearfish Grille serves casual and fresh seafood in a pocket friendly price range.

Spearfish Grille, located at Safe Harbor Marina, is a seafood lover’s dream, offering some of the freshest local catches on the Gulf Coast. Their daily specials feature fish caught within 24 hours ensuring a true dock-to-dish experience. Selections often include: hog fish, grouper, and amber jack.

Experience the laid-back charm of coastal living at Spearfish Grille, a hidden gem tucked into Siesta Key Marina. From mouthwatering grouper sandwiches to succulent blue crabs, each dish is prepared with fresh seafood straight from the Gulf. This ensures a taste of the sea in every bite.

1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242Phone: 941-349-1971 Visit Website. A post shared by Spearfish_grille (@spearfish_grille). If you’re looking for a casual seafood spot with a hip vibe, Spearfish Grille is the perfect place to go.

Spearfish Grille: Tucked into the Safe Harbor Marina on Old Stickney Point Rd., Spearfish is just a short walk from the Sea Shell. They serve fresh, local fish, sandwiches, nibbles, and burgers. Wine and beer only; not a full bar.

Spearfish opened in march 2018 and is located at siesta key marina on siesta key. spearfish has been serving quality interpretations of classic dishes and new and creative ventures into island food and amazingly fresh local fish.

Located on Avenida Messina, Spearfish Grille offers a delightful brunch menu alongside their regular fare. Their outdoor seating area is perfect for people-watching while enjoying your meal.