Another Broken Egg Cafe
1 / 10

Another Broken Egg Cafe

4.6
·491k reviews·,

A popular brunch spot known for creative, globally-inspired egg dishes, generous portions, and friendly service in Siesta Key.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Another Broken Egg Cafe

Another Broken Egg Cafe

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A popular brunch spot known for creative, globally-inspired egg dishes, generous portions, and friendly service in Siesta Key.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"This is the best place to have breakfast, you can not beat this breakfast!"

TIP

Visit on Weekdays

Consider visiting on weekdays to potentially avoid the longer wait times common on weekends.

Outdoor Seating Option

Enjoy dining al fresco with outdoor seating, perfect for pleasant weather and a relaxed experience.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens Friday 7AM

Cuisine

American Brunch

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(941) 552-8320

Address

140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Creative Pancakes with Global Flavors

Creative Pancakes with Global Flavors

Indulge in unique pancake creations like Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese & Peach Cobbler, inspired by Creole and Latin cuisines.

Kid Friendly Restaurants Near Siesta Key
Generous Portions & Flavorful Dishes

Generous Portions & Flavorful Dishes

Enjoy large portions of flavorful breakfast and brunch favorites, from cinnamon roll French toast to savory omelets.

Google Review
Exceptional, Personalized Service

Exceptional, Personalized Service

Experience outstanding service from attentive staff, like Brook and Anna, who offer personalized recommendations.

Google Review+1
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Breakfast at another Broken Egg Cafe#creatorsearchinsights#liveyourbestlife#breakfastwithmom
@roxycan2
16 likes • 212 views

Visit on Weekdays

Consider visiting on weekdays to potentially avoid the longer wait times common on weekends.

Outdoor Seating Option

Enjoy dining al fresco with outdoor seating, perfect for pleasant weather and a relaxed experience.

Another Broken Egg review !🤯10/10 definitely recommend #fyp #viral #foodreview
@alexisayleace
49 likes • 534 views
Come for the chicken salad, stay for the southern hospitality 👩‍🍳 #AnotherBrokenEggCafe #Brunch #RestaurantFL #chickensalad #Foodie
@anotherbrokenegg
1.2K likes • 48K views

Ask for Recommendations

Server recommendations can guide you to new favorite dishes on their extensive menu.

Parking Tips

If parking is full, consider walking to enjoy the day, especially if staying nearby.

Best breakfast in Sarasota Florida 🌴🎀✌️
@lllwithjoanie
8 likes • 743 views

Tips

from all over the internet

Visit on Weekdays

Consider visiting on weekdays to potentially avoid the longer wait times common on weekends.

Outdoor Seating Option

Enjoy dining al fresco with outdoor seating, perfect for pleasant weather and a relaxed experience.

Ask for Recommendations

Server recommendations can guide you to new favorite dishes on their extensive menu.

Parking Tips

If parking is full, consider walking to enjoy the day, especially if staying nearby.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Another Broken Egg Cafe is widely praised for its creative and delicious brunch and breakfast offerings, with generous portions and consistently good flavors. Diners frequently highlight the exceptional service, with many servers going above and beyond. While most reviews are glowing, some patrons have experienced longer-than-expected wait times and occasionally lukewarm food.

"This brunch place is the place to good. The mimosas are really tasty. I had the eggs Benedict and we had the bourbon pancakes, still drooling! I am not a fan of sitting in 90 degree heat while a fan blows more hot air but that is all they had at that time."

tiffany peterson

"Highly recommended breakfast spot!
They offer both indoor and outdoor seating, with fast and friendly service. The hostess was especially welcoming—she even chatted with us since we were all from PA.

I ordered the half and half special which included chicken and waffles and gumbo. The chicken and waffles with chipotle honey sauce were absolutely delicious. The waffle was perfectly cooked, and the chicken was tender. Gumbo was packed with flavor! The biscuits were huge and satisfying. If you enjoy mimosas, don’t miss the lemon blueberry mimosa—my first time trying that combo, and it won’t be my last. 10/10!

The only minor downside was that some of the food arrived lukewarm, as if it had been waiting on the rest of the order. Still, I would absolutely go back and highly recommend this spot in the charming Siesta Key Village."

Kish A.

"The Another Broken Egg was a pleasure to eat at. It was busy, so I would get there early or get your name in, and then u can come back. Parking in front gets taken up, so if nearby, I would walk and enjoy the day. Lots to select from on the menu. Everything pictured was delicious. Mimosas with summer heat just hit different. Recommend that you stop by at least once if you are in Siesta Keys."

Mike Miller

What People Like

Unique pancake and egg dishes
Generous portion sizes
Friendly and attentive service

What People Dislike

Occasional long wait times
Food arriving lukewarm

Frequently Asked Questions

Guests rave about the unique pancakes like Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese and Peach Cobbler. The shrimp and grits and various omelets are also highly recommended.

Yes, the restaurant offers vegetarian and gluten-free choices to accommodate dietary needs.

Seniors' Favorite Restaurants in Sarasota

Visiting on weekdays is generally recommended for shorter wait times compared to the busy weekends.

Yes, outdoor seating is available and is a popular option for diners looking to enjoy the weather.

Yes, the cafe offers a pet-friendly patio, so you can bring your furry companion.

Seniors' Favorite Restaurants in Sarasota

Reviewers frequently mention that the portion sizes are generous, ensuring a filling meal.

Google Review+1

They offer a variety of drinks including mimosas, Bloody Marys, coffee, juices, and lemonades.

Google Review+2

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

fodors.com

Sarasota/Siesta Key Restaurants - Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

For a good breakfast or lunch on Siesta, try the Broken Egg. Another good lunch spot is the Main Bar downtown. There are several good little casual restaurants in Siesta Village.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Luxury Rental Properties

Dining in Siesta Key

The king of breakfast in Siesta Key, Another Broken Egg Café combines an appetizing selection of fresh ingredients to create an incredibly flavorful experience and is one of the highest-rated Siesta Key restaurants. A favorite dish is the Bacquezo, cream cheese, and bacon-filled omelet with breakfast chorizo, Monterey Jack, and green onions. Feeding your indulgent side before noon is something the chefs at Another Broken Egg Café have mastered and is a great change from typical breakfast entrées.

Visit Source →
Peppertree Bay | Monthly Rentals on Siesta Key

Kid Friendly Restaurants Near Siesta Key

With banana pancakes, famously soft beignets, and an extensive menu served right in the heart of Siesta Village, and you have the ingredients for possibly the best breakfast or brunch experience on the island. Another Broken Egg is welcoming to families of all culinary preferences who are seeking a tasty and personalized breakfast or brunch during their Siesta Key stay. The team just launched a brand new menu, including Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese Pancakes and Peach Cobbler Pancakes.

Visit Source →
Crystal Sands on Siesta Key

Cafes To Try In Siesta Key

If you are looking for a gourmet experience right on the beach, check out Another Broken Egg Café which serves both breakfast and brunch. It is a chain of 30 casual restaurants that have been opened to national acclaim, and the Siesta Key location opened only a few years ago. You can expect to find numerous signature items on the menu inspired by Creole and Latin cuisines such as a spicy shrimp & grits, Louisiana crawfish egg skillet, and huevos rancheros as just a few options.

Visit Source →
vacationhomerents.com

Must See Sights and Landmarks in Sarasota Area

Visit Source →
Fronteras Mexican Restaurant and Cantina

Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Siesta Key

Another Broken Egg Cafe, nestled in the bustling heart of Siesta Key, stands as a beacon of delightful breakfast and brunch options, enchanting patrons with its delectable offerings and vibrant ambiance. Renowned for its flavorful creations and welcoming atmosphere, this establishment has cemented its place as a go-to spot for an exceptional morning meal experience. From the moment you step into Another Broken Egg, the excitement for an outstanding breakfast journey begins.

Visit Source →
Tropical Breeze Inn

Siesta Key Restaurants | Siesta Key Hotel

For a taste of Creole and Cajun style dishes that boast colorful flair, this highly popular café provides a great breakfast menu and is conveniently located near Tropical Breeze Resort. The food is known to be rich and tasty with more than friendly servers, but arrive early because its popularity tends to make it one of the busiest dining locations!. With traditional and healthy options available, visiting this café for breakfast is quite the way to start the day.

Visit Source →
Wandering our World

Shortlisted: Eight Breakfast Spots In Siesta Key That Locals Love!

Another Broken Egg Cafe is one of America’s most loved breakfast chains, so if you happen to be in Siesta Key and are looking for a reliably good breakfast, you know where to go!. Despite plenty of comfortable indoor seating and a spacious, shaded patio with lots of tables, you’ll face a wait on most days. But things move fast here, and you’ll find it all worth the wait once you take a look at their menu.

Visit Source →
Aviva Senior Living

Seniors' Favorite Restaurants in Sarasota

Another Broken Egg has a wide selection of breakfast, brunch and lunch options — from your favorite traditional dishes to unique gourmet creations. They also offer seasonal specials, gluten-free and vegetarian choices, and a vast drink menu. Another Broken Egg has indoor and outdoor seating, and a pet-friendly patio so that you can bring your favorite companion along on your adventure.

Visit Source →
avivaseniorlife.org

Aviva Senior Living - Seniors' Favorite Restaurants in Sarasota

Visit Source →
Sarasota Helicopter Tours

15 Top Picks for a Delicious Breakfast in Sarasota

Another Broken Egg Café is a popular breakfast spot for locals and tourists alike. Their traditional menu is full of classic breakfast favorites (such as their signature shrimp ‘n grits) – while their seasonal menu showcases some of their more creative dishes. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with plenty of outdoor seating for those looking to soak up some sunshine while they dine.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Helicopter

15 Top Picks for a Delicious Breakfast in Sarasota

Visit Source →
Liberty Savings Bank

Rise and Shine! Your Guide to the Best Breakfast Spots in Sarasota, Florida

If you're an adventurous foodie seeking a breakfast experience beyond the ordinary, Another Broken Egg Cafe is the destination for you. Embracing creativity, this café offers an array of innovative breakfast dishes that push the boundaries of taste. Indulge in their signature Bananas Foster French Toast or savor their savory Lobster and Brie Omelet for a memorable culinary journey.

Visit Source →
Almost Heaven Kayak Adventures

Siesta Key Restaurants

Broken Egg has been an island tradition for breakfast and lunch on Siesta Key since 1984. Their scrumptious menu including fabulous egg creations and omelets, plate-filling pancakes, fresh juices, and homemade bakery selections keep our customers coming back year after year. They serve exquisite breakfasts and lunches from 7:30 to 2:30, 364 days an year.

Visit Source →
Explore Suncoast

Siesta Key Lunch Spots

With indoor and outdoor seating, you can enjoy the large covered patio while noshing on southern-inspired grub. Sip a cocktail or cool beverage while enjoying Smoked Salmon Benedict, shrimp ‘n grits, or a Sonoma Club sandwich. Their gluten-free guide will help you make good choices and kids can enjoy the menu for wee little ones needing smaller bites.

Visit Source →
Travel With A Plan

Best Restaurants to Try While on Vacation in Siesta Key

140 Avenida Messina (Located in the heart of Siesta Key Village.). Another one of the places for breakfast in Siesta Key is Another Broken Egg Cafe!. Offering both indoor and outdoor seating on its large covered patio, Another Broken Egg serves up traditional southern-inspired breakfast entrees and delicious breakfast/brunch-inspired cocktails.

Visit Source →
Beach

Seas the Day: A Dreamy 3-Day Siesta Key Itinerary

Once you roll out of bed, head over to Siesta Key Village for breakfast at Another Broken Egg. They have a variety of options like the Lobster and Brie Omelette and my personal favorite, the Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese Pancakes. You can then take a stroll around the Siesta Key Farmers Market that is also there in the village.

Visit Source →
Crescent Royale Condominiums

Best Breakfast Spots in Siesta Key

Located in Siesta Key Village, the Another Broken Egg Cafe is the place to indulge in the sweeter side of breakfast with their bourbon street pancakes and lemon custard French toast. On the more savory side of the menu, choose from dishes like a hash brown benedict and the Mardi gras omelet.

Visit Source →
VISIT FLORIDA

Siesta Key Village Restaurants: Dining & Nightlife on the Beach

There are too many Siesta Key restaurants to mention in one blog post (but I do have to note that the Broken Egg is spectacular for breakfast, especially the morning after a big night out in the village!). But you can visit the Siesta Key Chamber of Commerce for more information.

Visit Source →
The Cottages on the Key | Luxury Siesta Key Vacation Rentals

Siesta Key's Best Breakfast Restaurants

Another Broken Egg is a popular breakfast spot in Siesta Key, and it’s easy to see why. They are part of a restaurant chain specializing in breakfast and brunch foods. The chain has locations across the United States, and its latest location is in Siesta Key, Florida.

Visit Source →
Erin's Travel Tips

Siesta Key Village: Guide to Best Restaurants, Shops, & Fun!

Another Broken Egg is a chain restaurant that tends to be one of my go-to’s when craving a traditional breakfast. They have excellent pancakes and omelets. I visit them usually in Clearwater Beach, but they also have a location just off Ocean Boulevard downtown.

Visit Source →
Your Next Destination Paradise

Grab a Bite at These Delicious Siesta Key Restaurants

Another Broken Egg Cafe is one of the top breakfast and brunch restaurants in Siesta Key. This quaint cafe provides a great eating experience with its warm and welcoming ambiance. Their menu offers a selection of delectable breakfast dishes with unique twists.

Visit Source →
Inn on Siesta Key

Where to Have a Great Breakfast on Siesta Key

Another Broken Egg Café is known for their plate-sized pancakes along with their strawberry pound cake French toast, Belgian waffles, and Mardi Gras omelets. Open daily from 7 am to 2 pm. The old adage is true; the most important meal of the day is breakfast.

Visit Source →
beachyep.com

15 Best Siesta Key Restaurants On The Water

It is a great place to start your morning with an eye catching view. More than the view, it serves a great breakfast menu. They are mostly known for their plate size pancake, strawberry pound cake, French toast, Belgian waffles, and Mardi Gras omelets.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Experts

15 Best Eggs Benedict in Sarasota [2022]

Another Broken Egg Cafe is one of the most popular breakfast restaurants on Siesta Key. They make the best crab eggs Benedict and lobster eggs Benedict in Sarasota!. Make sure to try their spicy Bloody Mary and New Orleans style beignets.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Magazine

Sarasota's Best: Pancakes

We loved the outrageous artistry of options like banana-split pancakes (bananas wrapped in pancakes and covered with pecans, strawberries, pineapple and chocolate syrup) and Boar in a Quilt (blueberry pancakes wrapped around sausages).

Visit Source →
Siesta Beach

Exploring Coffee Siesta Key: Island's Best Brews

While Another Broken Egg Cafe might be a chain, it has a distinctive, local charm that makes it a favorite among residents. Their hot coffee is bold and full-bodied, perfectly complementing their extensive breakfast and brunch menus.

Visit Source →
Visit Sarasota County

Dine, Relax, and Have Fun - Siesta Key

From beignets to adventurous omelets, Another Broken Egg puts a unique culinary twist on regionally inspired dishes for any breakfast appetite, sweet or savory. We recommend their signature irresistible Cinnamon Roll French Toast.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Villa ~ Casa Blanca C-16

Top 10 Siesta Key Breakfast Restaurants

Dishes come from homemade family recipes so you’ll enjoy fabulous egg creations made from the best locally farmed eggs in Sarasota, gigantic pancakes and fresh delicious meats. Start you day with the best breakfast ever!

Visit Source →
Adventure Kayak Outfitters

Siesta Key - Where To Eat

Another Broken Egg Cafe offers exceptionally unique creations, ranging from new twists on Eggs Benedict and Gourmet Omelettes to unbelievable Biscuit Beignets, Cinnamon Roll French Toast and so much more.

Visit Source →
ideal-LIVING

Sarasota - Florida's Swanky Cultural Coast

The Chart House is similarly popular, but in a league of its own. Adjacent to AAA Four-Diamond Resort at Longboat Key Club, it is known for exquisitely-prepared seafood, and an award-winning wine list.

Visit Source →
thejc.com

Florida coast gave me Keys

The Broken Egg offers the best breakfast in town with just about every variety of egg dish ever invented. It's been part of the village life since the 80's and there's even a small art gallery inside.

Visit Source →
Family Destinations Guide

Best Brunch in Siesta Key, FL (2025) — 15 Top Places!

This eatery with 21 other locations in Florida is a gastronomic gem in Siesta Key serving delicious benedicts, sandwiches and more for all-day brunch paired with hot or cold drinks.

Visit Source →
The Anchorage

Restaurants On Siesta Key, Florida: A Culinary Paradise

Another Broken Egg Cafe is a popular spot for brunch enthusiasts. Open daily, they offer a wide range of breakfast and lunch options, including their famous Crab Cake Benedict.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Chamber of Commerce

Restaurants - Siesta Key Chamber of Commerce

Another Broken Egg Cafe isn't your typical breakfast, brunch and lunch place. Our menu is second-to-none, loaded with fresh ingredients …

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Island Rentals

Wake Up to Flavor! Best Spots for Breakfast on Siesta Key

A Southern-inspired cafe offering a variety of brunch options:. Breakfast and brunch are served daily from 7:00 AM to 2:00 PM.

Visit Source →
Jamaica Royale Siesta Key

Dining - Jamaica Royale Siesta Key

To keep it super local you can always count on Another Broken Egg in the heart of Siesta Key Village!

Visit Source →
ticket.heraldtribune.com

Siesta Key Restaurant and Bar Guide

Visit Source →
Inspire • Travel • Eat

8 Best Restaurants in Siesta Key

Visit Source →
The Wandering Hartz

A Travel Guide to Our Favorite Florida Beach, Siesta Key

Visit Source →