Benny Vito's Original Margaritaville - Sandusky, OH
A seasonal waterfront haunt offering Tex-Mex and smokehouse fare with a vibrant Key West vibe and live music. Enjoy views of a waterfall.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Benny Vito's Original Margaritaville - Sandusky, OH
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A seasonal waterfront haunt offering Tex-Mex and smokehouse fare with a vibrant Key West vibe and live music. Enjoy views of a waterfall.
"Great atmosphere, great food, and best service this year!"
Weekday visits recommended
Visit during weekdays to avoid potential weekend crowds and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.
Best seating options
Opt for window seats overlooking the waterfall or the bar for potentially quicker service.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Tex-Mex, American, Smokehouse
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(567) 877-2001
Address
212 Fremont Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Waterfront Dining with a Waterfall View
Enjoy Tex-Mex and smokehouse fare with scenic ocean views from a festive seasonal deck, complete with a waterfall backdrop.
Key West Vibes and Live Music
Experience a lively Key West atmosphere with smokehouse favorites and live bands playing on weekends.
Unique Appetizers
Don't miss out on creative starters like the unforgettable bacon-wrapped dates and flavorful chorizo corn cakes.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Weekday visits recommended
Visit during weekdays to avoid potential weekend crowds and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.
Best seating options
Opt for window seats overlooking the waterfall or the bar for potentially quicker service.
Half portions for kids
Consider half-order options for kids to save money while still enjoying generous portions.
Check live music schedule
Enjoy added entertainment by checking out live music events typically held on weekends.
Tips
from all over the internet
Weekday visits recommended
Visit during weekdays to avoid potential weekend crowds and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.
Best seating options
Opt for window seats overlooking the waterfall or the bar for potentially quicker service.
Half portions for kids
Consider half-order options for kids to save money while still enjoying generous portions.
Check live music schedule
Enjoy added entertainment by checking out live music events typically held on weekends.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
The Original Margaritaville receives praise for its unique waterfront setting, often highlighted by its waterfall feature and lively atmosphere, especially with live music on weekends. While many enjoy the Tex-Mex and smokehouse fare, particularly appetizers like bacon-wrapped dates, some reviewers have noted inconsistencies in service and food quality. Moderate pricing and the option for half-orders are also appreciated aspects.
"Go check it out for yourself!! We are foodies and it was great!!! Bacon wrapped dates are to die for (watch for toothpicks). Chorizo corn cakes are calling me back. The queso, chicken nachos and burger in paradise had everyone else pleased. Pleasant staff, didn’t take long and I LOVE places that give you half order options especially if we take our kids! Under $55 to fully feed 3 adults is good in this area!!! Could have fed a 4th or a few kids, half orders are still large."
Jennifer B
"This place was so good we went back two days in a row. Mexican/American bar food menu, quick food service, and friendly staff. Extremely reasonable prices. Free chips and salsa were tasty, the queso dip was thick and flavorful, and I can personally vouch for the burrito, the tacos, the burger on a tortilla, and the chicken sandwich. Veggies were fresh and food came out hot (and very quickly both times). They also have tons of outdoor seating if that’s what you like, but we sat inside to enjoy the cold air. Bonus, we sat at a table next to a huge window in front of a small waterfall. Added bonus, the fries were fantastic. Very different from what I’m used to, a flatter wide cut fry with a hint of seasoning. An absolutely PERFECT break for food and air-conditioning from Cedar Point. This will probably be my go-to for an amusement park launch from now on."
Miriam Sokoloff
"Nice date night spot to have some dinner by the waterfall, or just for a drink at their bar. Good service, and great food."
Kevin Richardson
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The restaurant boasts a unique waterfront setting with a waterfall view, Key West vibes, and live music on weekends, offering Tex-Mex and smokehouse dishes.
Yes, there is an expansive seasonal waterfront deck offering great views, perfect for enjoying the atmosphere.
The menu features Tex-Mex favorites like fajitas, nachos, and tacos, alongside smokehouse fare such as ribs and burgers.
Yes, the restaurant offers half-order options, which are still generous in portion size, making it a good choice for families.
Visiting during weekdays is recommended to avoid potential weekend crowds.
Yes, live music is a regular feature on weekends, adding to the lively atmosphere.
Popular items include bacon-wrapped dates, chorizo corn cakes, fajitas, nachos, enchiladas, and tacos.
Prices are considered reasonable, especially given the portion sizes and the overall experience.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Restaurants Near Cedar Point Amusement Park
Located on Route 6, just outside of Sandusky and Cedar Point, Margaritaville has been a summer favorite for decades. This restaurant serves smokehouse fare, has a Key West feel, and huge patio with live music on the weekends. There's even a waterfall.The menu features fajitas, a variety of nacho combinations, enchiladas and tacos, and American burgers.
Outdoor Dining in Ohio’s Lake Erie Shores & Islands
Bay Harbor Waterfront Dining & Famous Dave’s Legendary Pit Bar-B-Que, Sandusky – Both located at Cedar Point’s marina, these diverse eateries offer plenty of outdoor space overlooking the water. Famous Dave’s is a barbecue chain known for its meals served family style and Bay Harbor specializes in steaks and seafood.
List of best patio outdoor dining in northwest Ohio
Highlights: Although this is not affiliated with the Jimmy Buffet brand, The Original Margaritaville offers a variety of food items from salads and tacos to burgers and, of course, margaritas. The building is located next to a small waterfall that is visible from both the outdoor patio and indoor dining room.
Crush Wine Bar - Sandusky, Ohio
The Orginal Margaritaville has been a favorite of those looking for a fun, relaxed atmosphere. Take to the deck with drinks and live music, or dine indoors. Either way, enjoy wonderful views of the creek.
Most Clevelanders Have Never Heard Of This Fascinating Maritime Museum
And after your visit, enjoy an excellent meal at The Original Margaritaville in Sandusky, Ohio. And here are some more fun attractions in Cleveland.
Where to eat in Sandusky?
I suggest Margaritaville; not the one thats now in the old Chi Chi's on 250, but the one that is on Rt. 4 or 6. Great view great food.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit