Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza serves authentic New York-style pizzas with a crispy brick oven crust, unique celebrity-themed pies, and a cozy boardwalk vibe.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Papa's Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Papa's Pizza serves authentic New York-style pizzas with a crispy brick oven crust, unique celebrity-themed pies, and a cozy boardwalk vibe.
"The crust is perfect! Truly some of the best pizza I’ve had!"
Visit Off-Peak Hours
To avoid long waits at this popular, cozy spot, consider visiting during non-peak hours.
Embrace the Beachside Experience
Take your pizza to enjoy on Pensacola Beach for a memorable and scenic dining experience.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza, Italian
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(850) 934-1198
Address
400 Quietwater Beach Rd #1, Pensacola Beach, FL 32561, USA
Website
papaspizza.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic New York Style Pizza
Experience traditional New York Style pizzas crafted from scratch in a brick oven, dating back to the 1940s.
Celebrity Pizzas
Savor unique pies named after famous personalities, loaded with fresh toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and green olives.
Beachside Boardwalk Dining
Enjoy delicious pizza with a view, perfect for a casual meal after a day of fun on Pensacola Beach.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit Off-Peak Hours
To avoid long waits at this popular, cozy spot, consider visiting during non-peak hours.
Embrace the Beachside Experience
Take your pizza to enjoy on Pensacola Beach for a memorable and scenic dining experience.
Try the Buffet Deal
During weekdays, the lunch buffet offers great value with fresh pizza, salad, and soda.
Explore the Menu Variety
With a wide range of pizzas and Italian favorites, try different options on separate visits.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit Off-Peak Hours
To avoid long waits at this popular, cozy spot, consider visiting during non-peak hours.
Embrace the Beachside Experience
Take your pizza to enjoy on Pensacola Beach for a memorable and scenic dining experience.
Try the Buffet Deal
During weekdays, the lunch buffet offers great value with fresh pizza, salad, and soda.
Explore the Menu Variety
With a wide range of pizzas and Italian favorites, try different options on separate visits.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners frequently praise Papa's Pizza for its authentic New York-style crust, delicious toppings, and friendly service, making it a great casual spot on the boardwalk. However, some reviewers have noted inconsistencies in quality, with one describing the pizza as dry and disappointing. Despite occasional criticisms, many visitors find it to be a satisfying and enjoyable meal, especially after a day at the beach.
"The pizza was fresh and crisp! We had the make your own, pepperoni and sausage and mushroom and green olives! Good stuff, nice place and nice people! Stop by for sure!!"
Babes N Bladez
"Excellent pizza! Brick oven... many places just can't get the bottom crust crisp without burning it. This place rocked it out. Prices aren't too bad either and it's right on the boardwalk - fun area."
Donald Ellsworth
"Cool pizza place to go to after spending time on the beach. It's a small pizza restaurant, had a mom and pop feel to it. The pizza was pretty good, not out of this world good, but pretty good. The service was great, our waitress was very attentive."
Romy M.G.
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Papa's Pizza specializes in authentic New York Style pizzas, made from scratch in a brick oven.
Yes, vegetarian options like 'The Sophia Loren' pizza with spinach and mushrooms are available, along with custom topping choices.
Yes, Papa's Pizza offers both whole pies and individual slices, making it easy to enjoy a quick bite or feed a group.
While specific parking details aren't provided, it's located on the Pensacola Beach Boardwalk, which typically has public parking areas nearby.
Papa's Pizza offers a 'two-bite money-back guarantee' on their pizzas, ensuring customer satisfaction.
Yes, it's a family-friendly spot, perfect for casual dining after a day at the beach or exploring the boardwalk.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Pensacola Beach dining guide: From fancy to flip flops
If you’re looking for a satisfying New York-style pizza slice served simply on a paper plate and packed with flavor, Papa’s Pizza hits the spot after a day on the sand. Pizza is offered by the whole pie or by the slice, giving you the option to feed one or the entire family. The house specialty combinations are named after celebrities, such as The Frank Sinatra, The Sophia Loren and The Al Pacino.
Pensacola Beach Restaurants Guide: BBQ, Seafood & More
At Papa’s Pizza, you can enjoy the original quality, methods, and recipes that have been cherished in Brooklyn, New York, since 1947. Papa’s Pizza has been serving Authentic New York Style pizza by the slice and whole pies on Pensacola Beach since 1998. We only use the finest ingredients including the finest Italian cheeses money can buy.
Top 10 Places to Eat in Pensacola Beach, FL
The delicious pizza at Papa’s Pizza is just one of the many reasons you need to visit the Pensacola Beach Boardwalk. No dining list is complete without an outstanding pizzeria!. Pizza and family vacations go together like waves and the ocean, but not any pizza place will satisfy your hunger for the perfect slice.
17 Best Pensacola Beach & Navarre Beach Restaurants To Try!
Located right on the Pensacola Beach Boardwalk, Papa’s Pizza claims to have the “Best Pie In The Panhandle”. Their specialty is New York Style Pizzas and Italian favorites, including calzones, pastas, and stromboli. Stop by Bamboo Willy’s Bar for a drink after, which is right behind Papa’s Pizza!
Pensacola Beach Boardwalk on Penacola Beach Florida
Papa's Pizza specializes in famous New York Style pizzas, made with traditional tools and methods, dating back to the 1940s. “We have a two-bite, money-back guarantee,” says owner Mike Pinzone. “If you take two bites and you don’t like it, we’ll give you your money back, no questions asked.
Pensacola Beach Boardwalk- 5 Fun Things To Do!
Papa’s Pizza at the Pensacola Beach Boardwalk is a great spot to get your fix. They make their pizzas with only the freshest and most authentic ingredients, so you can taste the difference. Their locations in Northwest Florida and Alabama are perfect for a night out or a family gathering.
Top 12 Pensacola Beach Kid-Friendly Restaurants - Tripping.com Rentals
When you’re craving a scrumptious pizza pie, you can’t beat Papa’s Pizza. The eatery specializes in New York-style pizza, and the dough is made fresh daily. Choose from fun celebrity pizzas named after Frank Sinatra, Al Pacino, Joe Pesci, or Rocky Marciano.
Pensacola Beach Boardwalk
Papa's Pizza makes every single slice, pie, stromboli, calzone and more by hand. Menu highlights - Pastas - Spaghetti with meatballs, spaghetti with marinara, or spinach lasagna. Salads - Greek salad, anti-pasta salad,
Places in Pensacola Beach, Florida, United States Florida – Usmenuguide – Restaurant Menus, pictures and specials
Located on the Pensacola Beach boardwalk, Papa’s Pizza uses only the best ingredients and is famous for having “the best pizza on the panhandle”. View menu Pizzas are Read more...
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit