Wy'east Pizza

Wy'east Pizza

4.6
·491k reviews·,

Wy'east Pizza offers unique, long-fermented crust pizzas with creative toppings in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere.

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Wy'east Pizza

Wy'east Pizza

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Wy'east Pizza offers unique, long-fermented crust pizzas with creative toppings in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"This is easily on our Top 5 Pizza Places of Milwaukee List."

TIP

Make a Reservation

Due to the small shop size, reservations are highly recommended to secure your spot, especially on weekends.

Seasonal Pizza Selections

Try specialty pizzas that rotate seasonally for a top-notch culinary experience.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens Thursday 4PM

Cuisine

Pizza

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(414) 943-3278

Address

5601 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208, USA

Insta-Factor

Medium

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

The Perfect Crust

The Perfect Crust

Experience pizzas with a unique, long-fermented dough offering a light, bread-like texture with delightfully chewy, puffy, and crackly edges.

Best Pizza Places in MilwaukeeThe 7 Best Pizzas In MilwaukeeGoogle Review
Seasonal & Pacific Northwest Inspired Pies

Seasonal & Pacific Northwest Inspired Pies

Indulge in creative pizza topping combinations, often inspired by the Pacific Northwest and featuring seasonal ingredients.

Best Pizza in Milwaukee: Pizza Shops With the Best Slices in TownGoogle Review
Cozy, Unpretentious Atmosphere

Cozy, Unpretentious Atmosphere

Enjoy a relaxed vibe in a converted gas station, often complemented by a groovy soundtrack and friendly owners.

Google Review
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Make a Reservation

Due to the small shop size, reservations are highly recommended to secure your spot, especially on weekends.

Seasonal Pizza Selections

Try specialty pizzas that rotate seasonally for a top-notch culinary experience.

Elevate Takeaway Pizzas

Enhance takeaway by adding fresh mozzarella or burrata and extra olive oil to savor the crust.

Don't Miss the Focaccia

The focaccia is highly recommended, especially with the ranch dipping sauce.

Tips

from all over the internet

Make a Reservation

Due to the small shop size, reservations are highly recommended to secure your spot, especially on weekends.

Seasonal Pizza Selections

Try specialty pizzas that rotate seasonally for a top-notch culinary experience.

Elevate Takeaway Pizzas

Enhance takeaway by adding fresh mozzarella or burrata and extra olive oil to savor the crust.

Don't Miss the Focaccia

The focaccia is highly recommended, especially with the ranch dipping sauce.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Wy'east Pizza is widely praised for its exceptional, uniquely textured crust and creative, high-quality toppings, often drawing comparisons to the best pizzas nationwide. While many rave about the cozy atmosphere and friendly service, a few diners have noted issues with unclear check-settling procedures, high prices, and inconsistent service experiences.

"We called ahead for a scheduled pickup, and they were absolutely wonderful over the phone helping us with our order. We ordered a large Hogsback - Sausage and Red Onion.

The pizza was ready when we arrived, and the service was excellent. Parking was easy, and they take credit cards.

The crust was perfect, and the pizza was so good we just kept eating one slice after another. We finished the whole pie under 15 minutes and then felt totally guilty about how fast we inhaled the pizza.

This is easily on our Top 5 Pizza Places of Milwaukee List."

Joshua B

"Delicious pizza, fun variations. FYI, No Pepsi/coke products but they have alternatives. Great prices. Service was good, small indoor seating area but comfortable. My only critique was that it was a little ambiguous where/to whom we needed to settle the check with."

Bryan Cerro

"This might be the best pizza in Milwaukee. I loved the fermented (sourdough?) crust. It was super thin and crispy. The zig zag pizza with sopressata and olives was the right amount of salty toppings for the bright tomato sauce. Will definitely order again."

Cayla Dobbertin

What People Like

Exceptional crust with perfect char and chew
Creative, seasonal toppings
Cozy atmosphere and friendly owners

What People Dislike

Inconsistent service experiences
Unclear check procedures
High prices

Frequently Asked Questions

The crust is made from long-fermented dough, resulting in a light, bread-like texture with delightfully chewy, puffy, and crackly edges that are perfectly charred.

Best Pizza Places in MilwaukeeThe 7 Best Pizzas In MilwaukeeGoogle Review

Yes, due to the small seating capacity, making a reservation is highly recommended, especially on weekends, to guarantee a table.

Google Review

Wy'east Pizza rotates its specialty pizza choices throughout the year, often featuring seasonal ingredients and Pacific Northwest-inspired combinations.

Best Pizza in Milwaukee: Pizza Shops With the Best Slices in TownGoogle Review

The restaurant does not serve Pepsi or Coke products but offers alternative beverages. They also have a great beer list.

Google Review

Parking is generally easy, though the limited shop size might impact the surrounding area during peak times.

Google Review

Yes, takeaway options are available. For an enhanced experience, consider adding fresh mozzarella or burrata and extra olive oil.

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

Thrillist

Best Pizza in Milwaukee: Pizza Shops With the Best Slices in Town

The owners of Wy'east moved to Milwaukee from Portland where they operated a popular pizza truck. Those same pizzas have found a permanent home here in a renovated spot with a small dining room on Vliet Street, where pizzas are cooked quickly in a super-hot, wood-fired oven, with dough that's had an extra-long fermentation time, which leads to better flavor, texture, and a beautiful burnished color full of bubbles. Toppings and pizza names are influenced by the Pacific Northwest, like the Hot Marmot topped with pepperoni and hot peppers pickled in a maple syrup brine.

Visit Source →
Eater

The 38 Best Restaurants in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Visit Source →
Milwaukee Magazine

Best Pizza Places in Milwaukee

Owners Ann Brock and James Durawa started making pizza in Portland, Oregon, after Durawa caught the bug for baking. Together they operated a popular trailer specializing in chewy, medium-thick-crust pies topped with fresh, some seasonal ingredients until they moved back home to Wisconsin and found a spot for their Wy’east – the original name for Mt. Hood in Oregon; the owners are also hikers – in Washington Heights. Durawa is the yeast master and creates crusts from long-fermented dough that is light and bread-like, chewy with snazzy puffy-crackly edges that get a little charred.

Visit Source →
Journal Sentinel

The Milwaukee 50, with the Top 30 restaurants, ranked

A pitch-perfect meal to match the season was a salad and pizza at Wy’east. It was late spring-early summer, when local produce was just getting rolling in Wisconsin: To start, slices of radish, sugar snap peas and feta in a light vinaigrette, flecked with fresh mint and sumac, and then the Deschiutto pizza (served Wednesdays and Sundays into October), lavish prosciutto and pea shoots over goat cheese and mozzarella, chutney, herbs and olive oil on Wy’ east’s excellent New York-meets-Naples crust, crisp and chewy and deeply flavorful. I couldn’t have been happier.

Visit Source →
Sweetphi

The Best Milwaukee Restaurants Guide

Wy’east – Woodfired pizza amazingness located in Milwaukee – right on the Tosa border. Lately I’ve been sending Nick to get pick up from here because their pizzas are so good, if they ever have a special with honey on their pizzas, get it!. Van Guard – specializing in house-made sausages.

Visit Source →
OnMilwaukee

52 restaurants for your bucket list in 2019

Looking for a pizza spot that does things a bit differently?. That’s Wy’East where you’ll find pies made with a chewy slow-fermented crust and just enough liberally doppled charring. The toppings are of great quality, with flavor combinations that show a true attention to detail.

Visit Source →
bigseventravel.com

The 7 Best Pizzas In Milwaukee

The main secret to their great tasting pies is the long fermented dough that is cooked in a super hot oven. They char their pizzas perfectly to get that perfect crust, while ensuring the centre and toppings are still lush and perfectly fresh.

Visit Source →
Family Destinations Guide

50 Best Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI for 2025 (Top Eats!)

5601 W Vilet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208(414) 943-3278 Visit Website Open in Google Maps. This eatery, housed in a standout polygon structure, features amazing pizzas with a modern take, plus salads and sides, in rustic-chic environs.

Visit Source →
Shepherd Express

Best of Milwaukee 2020 Winners: Dining Out

The star of the show here is pizza; it’s Milwaukee style, meaning a cracker-thin crust cut into squares. Toppings are generously applied. Edge pieces are crunchy, while middles are easily foldable to prevent flopping.

Visit Source →
Urban Milwaukee

Guide: Milwaukee’s 30 Best Pizzas

Why it made the list: When you walk into WY’EAST you’ll notice a blue-and-red tiled Forno Bravo gas-fired domed Italian Pizza oven. WY’ East’s style of pizza is a unique hybrid between a Neapolitan and New York-style.

Visit Source →
Midwest Explored

15 Best Restaurants in Milwaukee WI You Must Try

This Milwaukee pizza restaurant is a little more than you would expect. Here the pizzas are innovative and creative but use old techniques. The results are amazing.

Visit Source →
Stacker

Highest-rated Pizza Restaurants in the Milwaukee Area by Diners

- Rating: 4.2/5 (132 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 5601 West Vliet St. Milwaukee, Wisconsin - Categories: Pizza- Read more on Yelp

Visit Source →