Well stocked bar
1 / 10

Sorella

4.6
·491k reviews·,

Sorella offers a taste of Southern Italy with an East Coast edge in a relaxed, stylish setting. Known for wood-fired pizzas, exceptional pasta, and cr...

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Well stocked bar

Sorella

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Sorella offers a taste of Southern Italy with an East Coast edge in a relaxed, stylish setting. Known for wood-fired pizzas, exceptional pasta, and creative cocktails.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"Outstanding food and restaurant! The vibe is off the scale and the food lives up to the hype."

TIP

Book Reservations Ahead

Secure your spot by making reservations in advance, especially for weekend dining.

Try the Pasta Specials

Don't miss out on unique pasta creations like the Veal Agnolotti or the Drunken Mafaldine.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Open·Closes 8:30PM

Cuisine

Italian

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(414) 301-6255

Address

2535 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Authentic Italian with East Coast Inflection

Authentic Italian with East Coast Inflection

Experience Southern Italian dishes with a unique East Coast twist, from wood-fired pizzas to delectable pasta specials.

Must Try Milwaukee: ItalianThe Best Restaurants in Milwaukee22 Best Restaurants In Milwaukee
Cozy Ambiance and Charming Patio

Cozy Ambiance and Charming Patio

Enjoy a relaxed and inviting atmosphere, perfect for date nights or gatherings, with a charming outdoor patio complete with a fire pit.

Milwaukee Beer and Travel GuideGoogle Review+1
Exceptional Cocktails and Wine Selection

Exceptional Cocktails and Wine Selection

Sip on expertly crafted cocktails and explore a well-curated wine list, featuring Italian options by the glass or bottle.

Milwaukee Beer and Travel GuideGoogle Review+1
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

#sorella #bayviewmilwaukee #milwaukee #milwaukeefoodies #milwaukeefood #foodie #milwaukeewisconsin #wisconsin #wi #food #midwest #midwestfood #pasta #fyp #foryoupage #foryou #italianfood #pizza
@pcltravels
70 likes • 3.6K views

Book Reservations Ahead

Secure your spot by making reservations in advance, especially for weekend dining.

Try the Pasta Specials

Don't miss out on unique pasta creations like the Veal Agnolotti or the Drunken Mafaldine.

Follow along as our dough goes from blob to ball to base. #grwm #milwaukeefoodies #mke #pizza #mkefoodie
@sorellamke
17 likes • 529 views
36 oz Porterhouse for two, or just you. You want it? We got it. #milwaukeefoodies #mke #italianfood #milwaukee #mkefoodie
@sorellamke
80 likes • 1.6K views

Enjoy the Outdoor Patio

Visit during warmer months to experience the charming outdoor patio, perfect for al fresco dining.

Don't Skip the Desserts

The tiramisu and chocolate cake are highlights, often stealing the show.

Tips

from all over the internet

Book Reservations Ahead

Secure your spot by making reservations in advance, especially for weekend dining.

Try the Pasta Specials

Don't miss out on unique pasta creations like the Veal Agnolotti or the Drunken Mafaldine.

Enjoy the Outdoor Patio

Visit during warmer months to experience the charming outdoor patio, perfect for al fresco dining.

Don't Skip the Desserts

The tiramisu and chocolate cake are highlights, often stealing the show.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Sorella is lauded for its authentic Italian cuisine with a unique East Coast flair, cozy ambiance, and excellent service. Diners rave about standout dishes, creative cocktails, and the charming patio. While most experiences are highly positive, some find portion sizes could be more generous, and corkage fees can be on the higher side.

"I have a lot to say 😅

First: atmosphere. We arrived at 8:10pm for an 8:30 reservation. It was the tail end of dinner rush, and we arrived expecting to wait for our table to be ready. We sat at the bar and had a drink while we waited. It was very cozy, hip, inviting. The wine list had lots of Italian options by the glass or bottle. (Sadly, a lot of “Italian” American restaurants do not.) I ordered a Prosecco and my husband ordered a spicy tequila cocktail that was perfectly balanced. Delicious.

Our table was ready on time. We ordered several plates, all to share.

Beet salad: 10/10 for my taste. Very well balanced, not too much dressing, just delicious. I could eat it every day. (I order the beet salad at any restaurant who serves one, this is now my fav.)

Arancini: crispy outside, creamy and well seasoned inside. So good, would order again.

Burrata with crispy chili & house bread: 100/10. Whoever thought of this deserves a raise. I’ve never had this flavor combo and now I crave it!

Clam pizza (special): I really enjoyed this. The sauce had a slight kick of heat to it. The dough was very good, it was cooked well. Would probably order the Margherita next time since it’s our go-to at pizza/Italian places, but I’m glad I tried this.

Ziti w/ragu: my least favorite dish. Anytime I see a “ragu” pasta on a menu, I order it. The ziti shape didn’t go well with the type of sauce (for my personal preference). Also, the sauce wasn’t as rich and comforting as lots of ragu’s I’ve had. It was still tasty and I’m enjoying the leftovers. Just didn’t knock my socks off like the burrata.

I also ordered a glass of Barolo for dinner. Delicious.

Overall- I loved this place and can’t wait to go back!"

Jessica Haar

"Ate here tonight for our anniversary. Our server was very attentive, and he really took care of us. I had the pork chop, and my wife had the pasta with Cavitali Monday sauce. Cocktails were great, atmosphere was great, pork chop was great. Overall, we had a really good time, and the food/atmosphere was perfect for a nice date night. The desserts were actually the highlight of the meal. Spectacular tirimisu and chocolate cake. Definitely one of the better Italian spots in Milwaukee."

Ryan Mackman, MBA, MHA

"I had reservations I highly advise you to do the same. My first review is on the Chicken Piccata meatballs. It was very tender and flavorful and the lemony taste gave it an extra kick in the after taste highly recommend it. Now there were three entrees ordered at my table and yes I had a taste of all of them. The first one was the Rigatoni alla Vodka. It was just ok. But I’m not a big fan of alla Vodka. But my mother enjoyed it. The second meal I had was the veal strip loin Saltimbocca. It was very tender delicate and light. Very tasteful. The third meal I had was The Duroc Pork Chop. The chop was very thick and juicy. It was covered in onions and peppers with some sweet sauce It was delicious! It had a sweet and spicy flavor to it that combined to an explosion in my mouth. I highly recommend this dish. Sorella also had a wide variety of wines so if you’re into wine it’ll be great for you. The service was great waitress was very knowledgeable and attentive to our table. I recommend Sorella as a great place to get Italian food in the bay view area"

Junior Rubalcava

What People Like

Authentic Italian dishes
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Exceptional cocktails and attentive service

What People Dislike

Portion sizes sometimes small
High corkage fees

Frequently Asked Questions

Reservations are highly recommended to ensure you get a table, especially during peak hours and weekends.

The Best Restaurants in MilwaukeeGoogle Review

Standout dishes include the Arancini, Gnocchi, Rigatoni alla Vodka, and various wood-fired pizzas. The pasta specials are also frequently praised.

Must Try Milwaukee: ItalianGoogle Review

Yes, Sorella features a charming outdoor patio that is particularly enjoyable during the summer months.

Milwaukee Beer and Travel Guide

The restaurant offers a relaxed, cozy, and inviting ambiance, making it suitable for date nights, family dinners, or nights out with friends.

Google Review+1

Sorella has a well-stocked bar with a selection of delicious cocktails and a variety of Italian wines available by the glass or bottle.

Milwaukee Beer and Travel GuideGoogle Review

While not explicitly detailed, the menu includes vegetable-forward plates and pizzas that may accommodate dietary needs. It's best to inquire directly.

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

malvaux.com

bay view milwaukee restaurants

Sorella, meaning "sister" in Italian, was named after one of owner Kyle Toner's two daughters, but the food…It's all Jersey boys at their finest. This is a review for restaurants near Bay View, Milwaukee, WI 53207: "Greeted at the door by the hostess and the co-owner. View information about Hue Vietnamese Restaurant - Bay View to help decide on what to eat. Egg & Flour Pasta Bar. Cantonese House Chinese. Dashboard. Specials. Reviews. SmallPieOnline Ordering Menu. Guanajuato Mexican Restaurant. Our easy-to-use app shows you all the restaurants and nightlife options in your city, along with menus, photos, and reviews. 2201 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Bayview, Milwaukee. Read reviews from Alterra Bay View Cafe at 2301 S Kinnickinnic Ave in Bay View Milwaukee 53207 from trusted Milwaukee restaurant reviewers. 8:00 AM - 7:00 PM. HOURS: dinner Wed-Sun. Our restaurant boasts unparalleled views of the city and an expansive dining room for gatherings of all sizes. 3pm-2am . Lounges in Milwaukee ( Bay View ) Wisconsin Milwaukee Lounges Bay View Lounges Burnhearts Specials. (17) Website. PORK BELLY SANDO -$13-. The White House may be one of the most famous buildings in Bay View & likely to be one of the most popular new restaurants in Milwaukee in 2020. 99% of 785 customers recommended. Bay View food delivery and takeout. (262) 878-3900. Where: 3120 S. Lake Dr. "Enjoy terrific panoramic views of Milwaukee and Lake Michigan from South Lake Drive at Bay View Park." ~Paul Matzner While the gray skies, snow-mottled sand and leafless trees might not look as picturesque in December, outdoor enthusiasts will continue to enjoy Bay View Park's trails throughout the winter, whether walking, running, biking . THE NAME: It means sister, after Toner's young daughters. When we opened our doors we believed we could set ourselves apart from the rest of the burgers in Wisconsin by offering more chef driven, unforgettable burgers and chicken sandwiches. When we opened our doors we believed we could set ourselves apart from the rest of the burgers in Wisconsin by offering more chef driven, unforgettable burgers and chicken sandwiches. A handful of Milwaukee restaurants, including Walker's Point's La Merenda, and Honeypie in Bay View, participate in his RSA. Located right on Kinnickinic Avenue and only a 5-minute drive to downtown, the Bay View guesthouse is nestled in one of Milwaukee's hippest neighborhoods. Best Lunch Restaurants in Bay View (Milwaukee): See 1,542 Tripadvisor traveler reviews of Lunch Restaurants in Bay View Milwaukee. July 2, 2021. View → Bay View Park. 0 Follow (414) 294-0490. Suddenly left with extra room in its Bay View location (2920 S. Kinnickinnic Ave., 414-489-0765), owners decided to install a wood fire oven where the roaster used to be. Smart Cow Yogurt Bar. Featuring a rotating menu of European style cuisi You can also expand beyond the Bay View area by checking out the Best Restaurants in Milwaukee. 8.6/ 10. Includes the menu, 1 review, photos, and 3 dishes from Alterra Bay View Cafe. KINN GUESTHOUSE, 2535 S. KINNICKINNIC AVE, 414-301-6255. Thrillist Eat Seeker highlights the best restaurants in Milwaukee to take the guesswork out of your next meal. This Romantic White House serves phenomenal dishes and darling cocktails. What are people saying about restaurants near Bay View, Milwaukee, WI 53207? SmallPie. Mazatlan Mexican Restaurant 601 Milwaukee St., Delafield, (262) 646-9687 The Bay View neighborhood is a huge contributor to Milwaukee's food scene. . Menu. Welcome to Hue Vietnamese Restaurant. The owners of the newest Italian restaurant to hit the Bay View, located in the Kinn boutique hotel, are both from New Jersey and made their mark in Milwaukee at some of Milwaukee's top listers over the years. 414-837-6121. Whether you are looking for an option that is classic or something new and exciting, Bay View has it. Their telephone number is +1 414-231-3304. East Side: 2238 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee / Bay View: 2273 S. Howell Ave. Bay View 1205 E Brady St. Milwaukee, WI 53202. From Business: Our family-owned self-serve frozen yogurt shop serves 16 rotating flavors of frozen yogurt, sorbet, Italian Ice and gelato. RESERVATIONS: Recommended. 2394 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee. Low noise level so easy to have conversation. The Vanguard is a locally owned bar and restaurant located in the heart of Downtown Bayview in Milwaukee, WI. Crafty Cow. TACO TRUCK DINNER TG. MONDAY-THURSDAY. ADDRESS. In Bay View, two veterans of the restaurant industry have plans to open an Italian restaurant at 2535 S. Kinnickinnic Ave. It's called Sorella and will serve classic southern Italian dishes. Check out the list of New Restaurants in Bay View. Ordered the roasted Brussels, out of this world! HAMBURGERS • FRENCH FRIES. Santino's thrives to be the best that Milwaukee has to offer. The business is located in 2121 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207, USA. Choice of meat OR vegetarian option, black OR pinto beans, rice, cheese, avocado, and lime cilantro crema. New Bay View Restaurant is a Familiar Milwaukee Haunt. Then through our high school years and into our adult lives we have served the fine people of Bay View, West Allis and surrounding areas. Cafe India Bayview. Lazy Susan MKE serves a rotating eclectic mix of plates. Ranked #2 for tacos in Milwaukee. Tua Pasta is a fast, casual, counter-service restaurant that will cater to the area's working crowd. Palomino Bar is an old school spot in the great neighborhood of Bay View - Milwaukee, WI. 100 E Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53202. Milwaukee / Bay View / Burgers; Must-try burger restaurants in Bay View. Milwaukee's Eat Local Challenge, sponsored by several organizations including the Urban Ecology Center, Outpost Natural Foods, and the Fondy Farmers Market, began in 2007. In 2013, they moved into a brand new location at 2317 S. Howell Avenue. 39 ratings. This is a review for restaurants near Bay View, Milwaukee, WI 53207: "Can't say enough good things about this Fine Dinning Taste in a Historic Atmosphere.

Visit Source →
Journal Sentinel

25 all-star chefs will cook at 2024 Dim Sum + Give Some charity event

Beyond Jacobs and Van Rite, Milwaukee chefs participating are Gregory Leon of Amilinda, Paul Bartolotta of Bartolotta Restaurant Group, Karen Bell of Bavette La Boucherie, Kyle Knall of Birch, Joe Muench of Black Shoe Hospitality, Kurt Fogle of Dairyland, Dane Baldwin of The Diplomat, Paul Zerkel and Lisa Kirkpatrick of Goodkind, Adam Siegel of Lupi and Iris, Sam Ek and Ross Bachhuber of Odd Duck, Justin Aprahamian of Sanford, Kyle Toner of Sorella, Mitch Ciohon of Taco Moto and Dooby Dogs, and Kristen Schwab of The Wolf on Broadway.

Visit Source →
OnMilwaukee

Must Try Milwaukee: Italian

Kinnickinnic Ave., (414) 301-6255sorellamke.com [ Read more]. Despite its more casual, neighborhood restaurant feel, Sorella doesn’t scrimp on the details (or the service), offering a varied menu of shareable seasonal dishes inspired by Southern Italy and shaped with a bit of East Coast inflection. You’ll find a mix of antipasti, vegetable-forward plates, pastas and wood-fired pizza along with compelling, moderately priced entrees that are unlike any other restaurant in the city.

Visit Source →
Milwaukee Magazine

The Best Restaurants in Milwaukee

This casual, cacophonous dining spot inside Kinnickinnic’s Kinn Guesthouse opened during one of the worst years in recent history (2020) and yet here it is, one of Bay View’s finest. Owners Kyle Toner and Paul Damora are a noodle and sauce combination – chef Toner’s the back of the house, Damora is the front, with lots of restaurant experience between them. They’re also both Italian, and originally from New Jersey; nevertheless, their food speaks to Milwaukee.

Visit Source →
BestDishMKE

Best Italian

In all honesty, when we first visited Sorella, we weren’t in love with our order. But, we’ve been back a couple of times since and were very impressed with both their pizzas and side offerings. Sorella (which means “Sister” in Italian) is located in the beautiful Kinn Guesthouse in Bay View, and usually boasts a full dining room on weekends.

Visit Source →
Getting Stamped

22 Best Restaurants In Milwaukee

Sorella is one of our newer favorite restaurants and a recent addition to the best restaurant in Milwaukee list. They serve some of the best Italian food in Milwaukee. Their menu and dishes are simple, tasty, easy to share, and really affordable for what you’re getting.

Visit Source →
MilwaukeeINSIDER

11 Best Italian Restaurant in Milwaukee

Sorella is one of the best newcomers to the best Italian restaurant in Milwaukee. Sorella opened in 2020 and is located in Bayview on KK, a quick ride away from Downtown Milwaukee in under 10 minutes. The restaurant serves dinner only.

Visit Source →
Adventures & Ales

Milwaukee Beer and Travel Guide

Sorella: An Italian restaurant on the ground level of the hotel. They have a nice outdoor patio, a pretty bar, a solid beer selection along with wines and cocktails, and a full Italian food menu with pizza, pasta and appetizers.

Visit Source →
Stacker

Highest-rated Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, According to Tripadvisor

- Rating: 5.0 / 5 (12 reviews)- Detailed ratings: not available- Type of cuisine: Italian, Pizza- Price: $$ - $$$- Address: 2535 S Kinnickinnic Ave Kinn Guesthouse, Milwaukee, WI 53207-1629- Read more on Tripadvisor

Visit Source →