"We gave Upper Crust Pizza a try while visiting Marathon tonight. This place was absolutely awesome! The staff treated us like family as we discussed everything from how the business started to what things were like in Marathon during COVID. We ordered a medium deluxe pizza and it was the perfect cheese to sauce to toppings ratio. The pizza was very delicious and it was obvious it was cooked in a brick oven. We were getting ready to leave and our server told us about the dessert of the day. It was an amazing Peach Cobbler with vanilla ice cream on top. Again, the cobbler was heated in the same brick oven. It was fantastic! We will definitely be returning on our next trip to Marathon!
Special thanks to the staff from tonight. You made us feel like family ❤️"

notme210

"Great food. You can tell that the sauce and ingredients are homemade. I ordered the spaghetti bolognese which was great. Highly recommend for any pasta lover."

F R

"If you’re in Marathon, FL and craving pizza, do yourself a favor and check out this hidden gem of a pizzeria! We stopped in during our trip to the Keys, and it honestly exceeded all our expectations.

From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm smile and welcoming energy from the staff. Everyone was super friendly, accommodating, and genuinely seemed happy to be there—which really set the tone for the experience. We placed our order right when we arrived and were pleasantly surprised that everything was ready in just about 20 minutes. Quick, efficient, and piping hot!

Now let’s talk about the pizza. It was exactly the kind of thin-crust pizza you hope to find—crispy on the bottom with just the right amount of chew, perfectly baked, and loaded with flavor. You can tell they take pride in their ingredients and preparation. Every bite was delicious, and we found ourselves reaching for another slice even after we were full.

We also ordered the cheesy garlic bread, and wow—it was a standout. Gooey, buttery, and packed with garlicky goodness. It was the perfect appetizer and great for sharing with the family.

The atmosphere was casual, clean, and very family-friendly. Whether you’re dining in with kids or meeting up with friends, it’s a great spot to relax and enjoy a good meal without any fuss. The layout and vibe made it easy to feel right at home.

The only downside—and it’s a small one—is that dogs aren’t allowed inside. As a dog-loving family, we always appreciate when spots are a little more pet-friendly, especially in the Keys. That said, it wouldn’t stop us from coming back. We just know next time to plan accordingly.

All in all, this is a must-visit stop for anyone passing through Marathon. Great food, even better service, and an atmosphere that makes you feel like a local. We’ll definitely be back on our next trip!"

Ailyn Quesada