The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar
1 / 10

The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar

4.6
·491k reviews·,

A vibrant waterfront tiki bar and eatery in the Florida Keys, offering fresh seafood and tropical drinks with stunning bay views.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar

The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A vibrant waterfront tiki bar and eatery in the Florida Keys, offering fresh seafood and tropical drinks with stunning bay views.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"Amazing waterfront views, great food, and lively atmosphere make this a Florida Keys gem."

TIP

Secure Outdoor Seating

Opt for outdoor seating to best enjoy the beautiful views and sea breeze while dining.

Try Signature Dishes

Don't miss the chance to taste their flavorful Caribbean Special or the renowned lobster roll.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens Sunday 8AM

Cuisine

Seafood, American, Caribbean

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(305) 743-4191

Address

12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Stunning Waterfront Views

Stunning Waterfront Views

Dine with breathtaking views of fish swimming below from the outdoor seating area, perfect for sunset watching.

Signature Lobster Rolls

Signature Lobster Rolls

Indulge in warm, buttery lobster rolls that are a highlight for many seafood enthusiasts.

Lively Tiki Bar Atmosphere

Lively Tiki Bar Atmosphere

Experience a vibrant, family-friendly vibe at Mile Marker 54's longest open-air bar, known for its tropical drinks.

Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Check out my review of Island Fish Company in beautiful Marathon, Florida. . . . #travel #lawyer
@imanimartinaesq
17 likes • 721 views

Secure Outdoor Seating

Opt for outdoor seating to best enjoy the beautiful views and sea breeze while dining.

Try Signature Dishes

Don't miss the chance to taste their flavorful Caribbean Special or the renowned lobster roll.

Their conch fritters with the ‘Bahama’ sauce?? UNREAL. If you’re ever in the Keys, this is your sign to stop at Island Fish Co. 🍹🐠 #fyp #floridakeyslife #islandfishcompany #foodie #seafood #conchfritters #restaurantreview #floridakeys #viral #explore #trending #vlog #contentcreator #contentcreation #comewithme #foodtiktok #flkeys #flkeyslife #marathonfloridakeys #islamoradaflorida #keylargo #foodi...
@selenalissettefernandez
90 likes • 3.9K views
Fort Myers to Marathon Key #islandfishcompany
@drkarindc
12 likes • 257 views

Visit During Off-Peak Hours

To avoid longer wait times, consider visiting on weekdays or outside of peak meal hours.

Pet-Friendly Dining

Bring your furry friends along, as the restaurant is noted to be pet-friendly.

Island Fish Co in Marathon, Florida #keywest #fl #florida #restaurant #fy #fyp #fypシ #foryoupage #foryourpage
@crinaskitchenandbeyond
30 likes • 972 views

Tips

from all over the internet

Secure Outdoor Seating

Opt for outdoor seating to best enjoy the beautiful views and sea breeze while dining.

Try Signature Dishes

Don't miss the chance to taste their flavorful Caribbean Special or the renowned lobster roll.

Visit During Off-Peak Hours

To avoid longer wait times, consider visiting on weekdays or outside of peak meal hours.

Pet-Friendly Dining

Bring your furry friends along, as the restaurant is noted to be pet-friendly.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

The Island Fish Company offers a beautiful waterfront dining experience with generally good seafood, though some dishes like the Key Lime Pie have received negative feedback. While many praise the atmosphere, views, and friendly service, others note occasional slow service or inconsistencies in food preparation.

"Such a beautiful view! I highly recommend sitting outside. The food was amazing. I had the Caribbean Special and it was so full of flavor and the pan-seared grouper on it was delicious. Everything my family got looked delicious! The key lime custard is amazing and would be ranked no. 1 of all the key lime pies we’ve tried, but the crust is not the best. Would absolutely come here again."

Kiley Sherrer

"Good experience here. I had a grouper sandwich which was very good and my wife had some shrimp egg rolls. Loved being able to sit by the water on a beautiful day! The only thing that held me back from giving a better rating was that the service was a little slow getting to our table. Otherwise, I will probably go back next time we are in Marathon."

Ryan McKenzie

"After speaking with some of the locals in the area, we choose to celebrate my husband’s birthday here. It was amazing! The atmosphere, view by the marina, fresh menu, and the liveliness & friendliness of the place was worth the recommendation. They are pet-friendly, as well. A place to return with family, pets, and friends soon! A true Florida Keys gem. Cheers!"

Jasmine Cabañez

What People Like

Stunning water views and sunsets
Fresh seafood and flavorful dishes
Lively tiki bar atmosphere

What People Dislike

Inconsistent Key Lime Pie
Occasional slow service
Overcooked or greasy dishes

Frequently Asked Questions

Popular choices include the warm lobster roll, coconut shrimp, and Caribbean Special. Many also rave about the fresh fish options.

Yes, the restaurant is renowned for its spectacular sunset views over the water, especially from its outdoor seating areas.

Yes, Island Fish Company is noted to be pet-friendly, making it a great spot for those traveling with their animal companions.

It features a lively, family-friendly, tiki bar atmosphere with open-air dining and beautiful marina views.

While not always necessary, it's advisable to consider visiting during off-peak hours or on weekdays to avoid potential wait times, especially on weekends.

The restaurant is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, typically from 11 am to 11 pm, Wednesday through Sunday.

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

Lonely Planet

Drinking and nightlife Florida Keys, South Florida & the Keys

The Island has a friendly staff pouring strong cocktails on a sea-breeze-kissed tiki island overlooking Florida Bay. Chat with your friendly bartender –…

Visit Source →
TheLuxuryVacationGuide

Top Ten Must See and Do Marathon, Florida

Bought in 1989 by the Florida Keys Land and Sea Trust, Inc., Crane Point consists of 63 acres of varied flora and endangered fauna. With trails leading throughout, there’s always somewhere new to go in Crane Point. Whether you’re there to visit the Marathon Wild Bird Center which rehabilitates hundreds of rescued birds each year, the historic Adderley — one of the oldest Bahamian-style buildings in the Keys outside of Key West, or simply there to take in the wildlife throughout the uniquely preserved Crane Point, nothing else captures the natural beauty of the Keys quite like this.

Visit Source →
keysrentalsonline.com

The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida

Sunsets, Florida Bay views, and great food can be found all in one place in the heart of the Florida Keys at Mile Marker 54 Bayside, Marathon. The Island Fish Co. invites you to sit back and enjoy a relaxed dining experience while feasting on locally inspired dishes, fresh seafood, and cool Hawaiian-style tiki hut favorites that will quench your thirst. Their spectacular sunset views and tropical waters will make your brunch, lunch, dinner, drinks, and desserts that much more pleasurable.

Visit Source →
Coco Plum Vacation Rentals

The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida

Visit Source →
Indigo Reef Vacation Rentals

The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida

Visit Source →
Havana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant & Bar

Oceanside Restaurant for Lunch & Dinner, Marathon FL

The view from our Tiki Bar, restaurant and patio deck overlooking the Atlantic Ocean speaks for itself. Wonder out on our pier and experience what the locals call the million dollar view.The plush outdoor oceanfront patio is reminiscent of a tropical retreat offering picturesque locations for guests to mingle, dance, sip cocktails and smoke fine tableside cut cigars. Our restaurant, bar and lounge are open 11am-11:00pm Wednesday through Sunday.

Visit Source →
keyshomeaway.com

The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida

Sunsets, Florida Bay views, and great food can be found all in one place in the heart of the Florida Keys at Mile Marker 54 Bayside, Marathon. The Island Fish Co. invites you to sit back and relax while enjoying locally inspired dishes, fresh seafood and cool tiki favorites that will quench your thirst. Their spectacular sunset views and tropical waters will make your lunch, dinner, drinks, and desserts that much more pleasurable.

Visit Source →
tropicalpropertyrentals.com

Local Area Guide | Tropical Property Rentals

Our spectacular sunset views and tropical waters will make your lunch, dinner, drinks and desserts that much more pleasurable. After eating, mosey through our gift shop where you will find Island apparel with original artwork and our exclusive logo on quality tank tops, t-shirts and sweaters. The mercantile shop is packed with great gift ideas to remember your trip to the Keys or make your friends who didn`t come along jealous.

Visit Source →
Florida Rambler

Iconic Florida Keys diners and dive bars

The Island Fish Co. is no longer home to the longest tiki bar in the Keys after hurricane remodeling, but that hasn’t changed its appeal to both visitors and locals. Now open for breakfast, lunch and dinner, the open-air dining rooms overlooking a marina and Florida Bay has great atmosphere and decent food prices. We loved the Indian River Steamers, a baker’s dozen (we got 15) littleneck clams served in its own broth.

Visit Source →
SeafoodSlurps

The Top-Rated Seafood Market in Marathon FL for 2025

When I first arrived at Island Fish Company, I was immediately taken in by its beautiful waterfront location. The view alone is worth a visit, but I was even more impressed by the amazing service I received throughout my time there. As an expert in seafood, I was delighted to find that Island Fish Company not only offers a fantastic seafood market but also serves delicious Caribbean food.

Visit Source →
Florida Keys Camping

14 Marathon Restaurants on the Water

The Island Fish Company, Tiki Bar and Grill, Marathon, Florida Keys by Having Fun Wherever We Go. Sunsets, Florida Bay views, and delicious dining can all be experienced at Mile Marker 54 Bayside, Marathon, in the center of the Florida Keys. Island Fish Company, a nautical-themed seafood restaurant, offers a magnificent view of the sunset and local delicacies influenced by the sea.

Visit Source →
bloggerbill.com

Key Colony Beach Florida | Restaurants & Places To Eat

Island Fish Company is a popular waterfront restaurant in Marathon, celebrated for its open-air tiki bar and fresh-caught seafood. Menu highlights include conch fritters, tuna poke bowls, and a wide selection of grilled fish and shellfish, all served with a view of the marina. The laid-back Keys atmosphere and sunset views make it a top destination for casual waterside dining.

Visit Source →
Beach Travel Destinations | Your beach travel destination expert!

The 10 Best Marathon Resorts

Their spectacular sunset views and tropical waters will make your lunch, dinner, drinks and desserts that much more pleasurable. If you are looking to just relax and enjoy the scenery, pull up a bar stool to the longest tiki bar in the Florida Keys. The bartenders are sure to put a smile on your face when you sip on one of their frozen favorites or cold draft beer.

Visit Source →
Roaming With Kids

Things to do in Marathon Florida with Kids

Island Fish Company is situated on the water’s edge, providing a picturesque dining experience. The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating options, allowing guests to soak up the scenic beauty of the Florida Keys while enjoying their meal. The menu features a variety of seafood options, including locally caught fish, shrimp, crab, lobster, and more.

Visit Source →
Florida Keys Swim with Dolphins Tour and Ticket

Best Family Restaurants in Marathon, FL & Swim with Dolphins!

Address: 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050Phone: (305) 289-2065. Island Fish Company provides the ultimate Florida Keys dining experience with its waterfront location and open-air seating. Specializing in fresh seafood, the restaurant serves popular dishes like conch fritters, fish tacos, and a variety of locally caught fish prepared to perfection.

Visit Source →
ActiveRain

The Top Restaurants in Marathon, FL

Located right on the water, The Island Fish Co. is perfect for those seeking a true Keys dining experience. They serve a variety of seafood dishes, including stone crab claws, conch fritters, and grilled mahi-mahi. The restaurant also offers a vibrant bar scene with live music, making it a great evening spot.

Visit Source →
Florida Trippers

14 Best Restaurants In Marathon FL You Must Try

Another of the best restaurants in Marathon for seafood is Island Fish Company. This fun tiki bar combines frozen drinks, local seafood specialties, and beautiful sunset views. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, Island Fish Company is a laidback spot to hang out and just enjoy being in the Keys!

Visit Source →
Travel in USA

Things to do in Marathon Florida: best beaches and tourist attractions

For lunch and dinner, we recommend Island Fish Company (12648 Overseas Hwy) where you can enjoy a spectacular sunset while you eat. The menu features tortilla wraps, filet mignon, chicken wings, cajun chicken salad, crispy crab sandwich, stuffed shrimp, fried calamari, and linguine with shellfish.

Visit Source →
Kristen Brenner

Where Locals Eat & Drink in the Middle Keys

There’s an obvious reason why this popular restaurant is opened 365 days a year for lunch and dinner. Breakfast is offered mid-December through Labor Day. Locals and tourists gather by the bay as much for the stunning view as for the warm service and a culinary experience that enhances it all.

Visit Source →
mymiddlekeys.com

Best Marathon Florida Keys restaurants - Kelly Willey

The Island Fish Company is a large tiki bar and restaurant offering panoramic ocean views. Known for its seafood and tropical drinks, this waterfront restaurant is perfect for a relaxed evening by the water. Try their coconut shrimp or mahi-mahi sandwiches while enjoying the sunset.

Visit Source →
Orlando Sentinel

7 great tiki bars in the Florida Keys

Longest tiki bar in the Florida Keys, this party haven rests on a spit of sand that pokes out into the bay. Often packed to the palm fronds yet spacious and airy, this sassy saloon keeps buzzing all day long on weekends. The heliport next door provides continuous entertainment.

Visit Source →
Chicago Tribune

7 great tiki bars in the Florida Keys

Visit Source →
Coconut Cay Resort

Grab a Delicious Meal at These Marathon, FL, Restaurants

Sit back and relax while you dine on locally inspired seafood dishes with sunset views and tropical water breezes!. Island Fish Company serves breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert seven days a week. This restaurant is home to the longest tiki bar in all of the Florida Keys.

Visit Source →
Sun Sentinel

Road food landmarks on the Overseas Highway

Having undergone post-hurricane remodeling, the Island Fish Co. is no longer home to the longest tiki bar in the Keys. Taking it up a notch, this fabulous open-air eatery is now open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. We found the prices reasonable, not to mention quite tasty.

Visit Source →
continentalkcb.com

Restaurants

Beautiful sunset views and great food can be found just a short distance from the Continental. Here you'll enjoy chef's specials and cool tiki favorites in a large restaurant with plenty of seating. They are open for breakfast, lunch and dinner with fresh fish daily.

Visit Source →
coconutcay.com

Grab a Meal at These Romantic Restaurants Near Marathon, FL

Whenever you’re ready to venture out of your Marathon Florida resort for a delicious meal, Island Fish Company is the place to go!. Imagine enjoying a delicious meal while taking in the breathtaking sunset views of Marathon. Island Fish Company offers exactly that.

Visit Source →
Worldwide Boat

Best Beach Bars in the Florida Keys

You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu, from the fresh-caught crab to the conch fritters. Not to mention, the atmosphere epitomizes the Florida Keys: incredible ocean views, lively entertainment, and plenty of frozen cocktails. Spend an afternoon on the dock.

Visit Source →
Gulfview Getaways - The Very Best Luxury Vacation Rental Homes & VRBO Properties in Marathon, Florida 33050

Dining with a View: Best Waterfront Restaurants in Marathon Florida - Gulfview Getaways

The Island Fish Company boasts panoramic views of the Gulf that will take your breath away. Indulge in fresh seafood dishes while soaking in the serene ambiance of the surrounding waters. Don’t miss the opportunity to try their famous fish tacos!

Visit Source →
RAK Marathon

Where Do Locals Eat in Marathon: Discover Authentic Dining Spots

Island Fish Company: This waterfront restaurant offers a variety of seafood dishes at reasonable prices. Locals enjoy the relaxed atmosphere and live music in the evenings. The menu includes items like coconut shrimp, fish tacos, and crab cakes.

Visit Source →
TripHobo

Restaurants in Marathon

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar, Sparky's Landing, and Marathon Grill and Ale House are a few restaurants in Marathon where you can get the best of Maritinis. To know their happy hours, you will have to check them out online individually.

Visit Source →
undertheboom.com

Guide to Tiki Bars of Marathon

Turning toward the north / east end of Marathon, Island Fish Co. is a true tiki bar on the bay side that is the only restaurant that can be reached by land, sea, and air. There is a helipad on the north end of the parking lot.

Visit Source →
Restaurant Observer

15 Best Restaurants in Marathon, FL [2023 Updated]

Whether land, water, or air, you can reach The Island Fish Company without any problem. The restaurant offers a dock and scenic view of the Marina. If you want a beachside Marathon experience, this is the place to dine.

Visit Source →
Kingsail

Florida Keys

Large, open air Tiki right on the Gulf of Mexico serves breakfast, lunch and dinner daily 8am till 11pm. Fresh local fish served in locally inspired style. Spectacular views all the time, including sunsets, of course.

Visit Source →
Island Breeze Vacations

Guide to Best Seafood Restaurants in Marathon, FL

The Island Fish Company is a popular spot for both locals and tourists, offering a casual dining experience right on the water. With a tiki bar and live music, it’s a great place to relax and enjoy fresh seafood.

Visit Source →
keyvaca.com

Where to Go in Marathon

Everybody comes here for a reason, a Marathon staple that serves up all the seafood classics while also letting you enjoy a great view by water with a lot…. Get Details & Directions Island Fish Company

Visit Source →
Florida Rentals Blog

Top Restaurants in Marathon, Florida

This fun spot is located right on the bay and has amazing waterfront views!. They are open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The menu features lots of local seafood and it is all prepared to perfection.

Visit Source →
Jolly Roger

Dining - Jolly Roger

MM 54 Gulfside12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050(305) 743-4191Waterside tiki bar/eatery pairing seafood classics such as coconut shrimp with frozen drinks.Open daily, 8am-10pm.www.islandfishco.com

Visit Source →
Medium

A Weekend in Marathon, FL: Best Things To Do and Attractions | by Robert Miller

● For casual eating under the sky and to get that open feeling, you can visit Island Fish Company. Here, you can taste savored items like shrimp, tacos, and stone crab accompanied by tropical drinks.

Visit Source →
vacationhomerents.com

Best Dinner Places to Eat in Islamorada

While in Marathon, The Island Fish is a great spot to grab dinner on a peasant evening. Even with a wait, it's worth it, and you'll enjoy your pleasant meal by…”more

Visit Source →
antrimlodge.com

thanksgiving dinner marathon, fl

The Island Fish Co. invites you to sit back and relax while enjoying locally inspired dishes, fresh seafood and cool tiki favorites that will quench your thirst.

Visit Source →
evendo.com

Best bars in Marathon Key

Discover the flavors of the sea at Island Fish Company, a premier seafood restaurant in the beautiful Florida Keys, offering fresh dishes and stunning views.

Visit Source →
Villa Paraiso Vacation Rentals

Lazy Days

Island Fish Company in Marathon, Florida, offers waterfront dining with a focus on fresh seafood and Caribbean-inspired dishes, providing a scenic an…

Visit Source →
manta.com

Seafood Restaurants | Marathon, FL

There are 226 cities in Florida with businesses in the Seafood Restaurants category. We've listed the top ten (based on number of businesses) above.

Visit Source →
Whats At Florida Keys

Restaurants In Marathon Florida #1 Guide For The Best Eating In Marathon

I am racking my brains to think of restaurants in Marathon, or in fact the rest of the Florida Keys that have a better location than this place.

Visit Source →
middlefloridakeysrealestate.com

10 Best Things to Do in Marathon, Florida

Invite your dad, kids, spouse, or friend to a fishing spot where you can relax and talk while waiting for a fish to take your bait.

Visit Source →
Florida-Keys-Vacation.com

Marathon FL Attractions, Fishing & Scuba Diving Tips

Especially here at The Island Fish Company Tiki Bar & Restaurant where you can kick back, and enjoy the fantastic water view.

Visit Source →
Florida Back Roads Travel

Florida Keys Travel Guide: Tips, Food, Lodging, Maps

Visit Source →
seaglassbeachhouseflkeys.com

Restaurants – Sea Glass Beach House Fl Keys

Visit Source →
tigerdroppings.com

Lower Florida Keys Best Restaurants.

Visit Source →
New Orleans Mom

Ultimate Guide to a Florida Keys Family Vacation

Visit Source →
https://travelphotodiscovery.com

Florida Keys Things To Do On Marathon, Florida

Visit Source →