Sweet Savannah's of the Florida Keys
A charming dessert haven in Marathon, Florida, famous for its award-winning Key Lime pie, inventive cupcakes, and delightful ice cream.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Sweet Savannah's of the Florida Keys
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A charming dessert haven in Marathon, Florida, famous for its award-winning Key Lime pie, inventive cupcakes, and delightful ice cream.
"The best Key Lime pie in Marathon, with creative cupcakes and a charming gift shop to boot!"
Savor the Signature Pie
Don't miss the award-winning Key Lime pie; it's a must-try for an authentic taste of the Florida Keys tradition.
Explore Unique Gifts
Browse the charming gift shop for unique finds from local artists, perfect for souvenirs.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Dessert Shop
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Award-Winning Key Lime Pie
Indulge in the legendary Key Lime pie, widely recognized as the best in Marathon. A true taste of the Florida Keys!
Creative Cupcakes & Ice Cream
From inventive cupcakes with delightful fillings to a vast array of small-batch ice cream flavors, there's a sweet treat for everyone.
Charming Gift Shop Finds
Discover unique treasures and locally crafted items in their delightful gift shop, perfect for souvenirs or special gifts.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Savor the Signature Pie
Don't miss the award-winning Key Lime pie; it's a must-try for an authentic taste of the Florida Keys tradition.
Explore Unique Gifts
Browse the charming gift shop for unique finds from local artists, perfect for souvenirs.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
For a more relaxed experience, consider visiting during non-busy times.
Gluten-Free Options Available
They offer many delicious gluten-free cupcakes and desserts, including their amazing Key Lime pie.
Tips
from all over the internet
Savor the Signature Pie
Don't miss the award-winning Key Lime pie; it's a must-try for an authentic taste of the Florida Keys tradition.
Explore Unique Gifts
Browse the charming gift shop for unique finds from local artists, perfect for souvenirs.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
For a more relaxed experience, consider visiting during non-busy times.
Gluten-Free Options Available
They offer many delicious gluten-free cupcakes and desserts, including their amazing Key Lime pie.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Sweet Savannah's of the Florida Keys is a beloved dessert spot praised for its wide variety of delicious treats, especially its award-winning Key Lime pie and creative cupcakes. Diners also appreciate the friendly service, charming atmosphere, and the added bonus of a gift shop filled with unique local finds. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, occasional comments touch on personal taste preferences for specific flavors.
"Wow what a place! The cafe seating area is just the ticket. Coffee is so well brewed it doesn't even need cream.
Cupcake was to die for! The center had a gooey lime delight which paired nicely with the delicate butter cream topping and citrus meringue.
Gift shop is one i can spend all day in.
A definite gem for the keys!"
Kimberly Sabat
"Gluten free cupcakes and desserts! Also love the mint chocolate chip (oddly, the plain chocolate wasn't my favorite). They also have a shop stocked with local artists' items. We finally found cute jewelry for my niece! I was surprised at how many places down here don't have earrings for young girls! Love what we bought here!"
Nicole Brown
"Great variety of regular and gluten free dessert options. They also feature a coffee bar for drinks, and have a side room with ample seating if you have multiple people together. The service was friendly, the bathroom was clean (and cute, love the salt scrub option!) and the rum raisin ice cream I enjoyed was refreshing. Brought home a chocolate covered key lime and cupcake for later! Prices were fair for baked goods.
They also made a note at the cash register about their pricing transparency (some items being more now post-tariffs) and I commend them at wanting to maintain an honest relationship with their customers. They clearly communicate the change in that flyer and as a customer it makes me want to support them more knowing they were mindful about taking steps to ensure they weren’t price gouging."
Jordan Flick
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Sweet Savannah's is most famous for its award-winning Key Lime pie, often cited as the best in Marathon. They also offer various Key Lime-themed treats.
Yes, they offer a good selection of gluten-free cupcakes and desserts, including their highly praised gluten-free Key Lime pie.
Besides Key Lime pie, you can enjoy a variety of baked goods, custom cakes, and a wide array of ice cream and gelato flavors.
Sweet Savannah's also features a gift shop with unique finds from local artists, making it a great spot for souvenirs.
Yes, they offer custom cakes for special occasions like birthdays and weddings.
Yes, the restaurant has garden seating and an indoor area with ample seating, suitable for groups.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Top Things to Do in Marathon, Florida
If you’re looking for the best Key Lime pie in the Florida Keys, look no further than Sweet Savannah’s. In the last seven years, this local favorite’s version has been named the best Key Lime pie in Marathon – a remarkable feat considering the extensive competition in the city. In addition to this classic Keys favorite, Sweet Savannah’s also offers all kinds of baked goods and sweets, including cupcakes, small batch ice cream, and custom cakes for all occasions.
The 14 Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys
Sweet Savannah’s of the Florida Keys is a bake shop that sells cupcakes, baked goods, ice cream, and of course, award-winning key lime pie. Indulge your sweet tooth here with a multitude of options. For key lime pie, Sweet Savannah’s sells their classic Key Lime Pie, and they also have Key Lime Bars, Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie, Key Lime ice cream, and Key Lime cupcakes.
The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida
This is the place to go for everything from homemade ice cream and cupcakes to ordering an exquisite custom wedding or birthday cake. If it�s made with sugar chances are the talented team at Sweet Savannah�s can create it for you!. For a truly special treat stop by for a slice or entire pie of their award-winning Key Lime pie, a Florida Keys tradition.
The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida
This is the place to go for everything from homemade ice cream and cupcakes to ordering an exquisite custom wedding or birthday cake. If it's made with sugar chances are the talented team at Sweet Savannah's can create it for you!. For a truly special treat stop by for a slice or entire pie of their award-winning Key Lime pie, a Florida Keys tradition.
Where to Grab Dessert in Marathon, Florida
Sweet Savannah’s of the Florida Keys is located at 8919 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL. Here, they sell various cupcakes, ice creams, and other delectable baked goods. They even offer options for those who cannot eat gluten or prefer to be gluten-free. Sweet Savannah’s also has an assortment of signature cakes.
15 Things to do in Marathon, Florida: Marathon Key
I like to make sure I find the ice cream shop as soon as I come into town. My boys love hard packed ice cream, not custard, or soft serve but hard packed, hand scooped ice cream. We love to try the different flavors, explore the different types of cones, sundaes, ice cream sandwiches and toppings.
FLORIDA KEYS BREWBQ AND CRAFT BEER FESTIVAL SET FOR JULY 14-15
In addition to the People’s Choice tastings, food will be available for purchase from Battle Rig BBQ, Lazy Days South, Brutus Seafood, Sweet Savannah’s, Marathon Youth Sports Burgers & Dogs, and the Greater Marathon Chamber of Commerce smoker slinging barbecue pulled-pork sandwiches.
4 Best Places For Key Lime Pie In The Florida Keys
This beautiful bakery offers a beautiful aesthetic, capturing the whimsy of my favourite meal of the day (dessert) with its cute décor. Be warned, you’ll want to stay and try every item on the menu. And there is a lot of Key lime to try, not just the pie.
28 Best Things To Do In Marathon FL
If so, Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop is something you must visit!. Delicious cupcakes, cookies, cakes, and more may be found here!. Even some handcrafted ice cream, delectable tea, and new coffee are available.
Where to Go in Marathon
Sweet Savannah’s is the best ice cream and bakery in the Keys. They have award-winning Key Lime Pie and their small-batch, locally made…. Get Details & Directions Sweet Savannah’s
Dining - Jolly Roger
MM 54, Oceanside11287 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050(305) 743-3131Unique specialty cakes. Cool off with 24 flavors of ice cream. Satisfy your sweet tooth.
Lazy Days
Sweet Savannah’s in Marathon, Florida Keys, is a beloved dessert shop offering homemade ice cream, cakes, and sweet treats. It’s a must-visit for any…
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit