Marathon Bagel Co.
The Florida Keys' first authentic bagel shop, offering over 12 unique bagel varieties daily with creative cream cheeses.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Marathon Bagel Co.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
The Florida Keys' first authentic bagel shop, offering over 12 unique bagel varieties daily with creative cream cheeses.
"Fantastic food – bagels or a skillet, you won't be disappointed!"
Arrive Early to Beat Lines
Visit around 9 am to avoid long lines, especially during boat trip preparation times.
Don't Miss Unique Flavors
Explore exciting bagel flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Jalapeno-Cheddar.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Bagel Shop, American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Unique Bagel Flavors
Discover over 12 creative bagel varieties daily, from Cinnamon Toast Crunch to Jalapeno Cheddar. House-made cream cheeses add to the delight.
Authentic New York-Style Bagels
Praised as the first authentic bagel shop in the Keys, offering classic New York-style bagels with a satisfying chew.
Hearty Breakfast Sandwiches
Build your perfect breakfast sandwich with a wide selection of bagels, eggs, cheeses, and fixings for a satisfying meal.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Arrive Early to Beat Lines
Visit around 9 am to avoid long lines, especially during boat trip preparation times.
Don't Miss Unique Flavors
Explore exciting bagel flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Jalapeno-Cheddar.
Try the Lox Combo
For a classic taste, opt for their lox and cream cheese combo.
Grab Muffins Early
Chocolate muffins sell out quickly, so grab one as soon as you can.
Tips
from all over the internet
Arrive Early to Beat Lines
Visit around 9 am to avoid long lines, especially during boat trip preparation times.
Don't Miss Unique Flavors
Explore exciting bagel flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Jalapeno-Cheddar.
Try the Lox Combo
For a classic taste, opt for their lox and cream cheese combo.
Grab Muffins Early
Chocolate muffins sell out quickly, so grab one as soon as you can.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Marathon Bagel Co. is celebrated for its wide variety of delicious and freshly baked bagels, with unique flavors and house-made cream cheeses earning high praise. Many diners enjoy the hearty breakfast sandwiches and the friendly atmosphere, though some find the bagels sweeter and softer than traditional New York style. A few reviewers mentioned inconsistent customer service during busy periods.
"Absolutely delicious!! We stopped here on our way out of the keys and I’m so happy we did! They had a plethora of homemade bagel and cream cheese options to choose from! We got bacon, egg, and cheese on their everything and jalapeño cheddar bagels which were so delicious! We also got two iced vanilla lattes and split a cranberry/orange muffin! Despite being so busy, the service was fast and the staff was friendly. We loved that they had outdoor seating as well as a few tables inside. We will definitely be stopping back!"
Isabella Roberts
"The food was okay, I ordered a western bagel sandwich, bagel with cream cheese for my kid. I won't be coming back. Customer service was not good. As the staff was trying to find the people who ordered each item, they were cussing and making snide remarks to customers who didn't hear them. The sticker on the register instructs customer to "tip correctly". I'm not sure what the correct tip amount is in this situation."
Josh Limanen
"Their bagels look good. Super crispy outside but fell flat inside. More like toast. Lots of options to choose from. From plain to everything. They did mix up our order though and gave us the wrong bagel and filling mix but I understand they were busy.
🥯 Lots of cream cheese flavors: Strawberry, Blueberry, Scallion, Bacon Scallion, Vegetable, Lox Spread, Honey Wallnut, Jalapeño Cheddar and some I have never seen before like…: Banana Cream, Oreo & Cinnamon Bun.
Great egg options as well and sandwiches and bowls.
The wait can be a little long - but they are clearly in demand and have good food. Some tables inside and outside.
Wish they had a public restroom while waiting in line but overall, great place!!"
Hilary Marshall RI Real Estate (Hil)
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
They offer over 12 daily varieties including Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Jalapeno Cheddar, Blueberry, and Oreo, plus house-made cream cheese flavors.
While some consider them authentic, a few reviewers note they are softer and sweeter than traditional New York bagels.
Popular choices include bacon, egg, and cheese on various bagels, as well as the BLT with egg.
Yes, they offer a vegan cream cheese spread made with cashews.
Visiting earlier in the morning, around 9 am, is recommended to avoid longer lines.
Yes, they also serve breakfast bowls, deli sandwiches, subs, and pastries like muffins.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Where Locals Eat & Drink in the Middle Keys
Open every day but Monday for breakfast and lunch with over 12 bagel varieties--Everything, Plain, Salt, Asiago, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Garlic, Onion, Cinnamon Raisin, Sesame, Poppy Seed and daily specials: Tuesday-Cranberry; Wednesday-Jalapeno Cheddar; Thursday-Blueberry; Friday-Chocolate Chip; Saturday- Oreo, Sundried Tomato; Sunday-Egg, Egg Everything, Pumpernickel, and don’t forget their amazing selection of cream cheese—Savory flavors: Bacon Scallion, Jalapeno Cheddar, Chive, Sundried Tomato, Lox, Green Olive, and Vegetable; Sweet flavors: Strawberry, Honey Walnut, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Oreo and a vegan spread made with cashews. Cream Cheese is house made with no added sugar.
Noshing Your Way Through The Florida Keys - Big Daddy Kreativ
If you’re looking for a quick and easy breakfast, Marathon Bagel Co. in The Florida Keys is a must-visit destination. Located on the gulf side of the Overseas Highway, this family-owned, locally sourced shop offers up some of the freshest and most mouthwatering bagels you’ll find anywhere in South Florida. Featuring unique flavors like jalapeño cheddar and honey oat with cinnamon raisin swirls, their plain bagels are also legendary among those who appreciate freshness and simplicity.
Things to do in Marathon Florida with Kids
Marathon Bagel Co. is a popular eatery located in Marathon, Florida, that specializes in delicious bagels and breakfast items. This cozy establishment offers a wide variety of freshly baked bagels, made in-house daily, with a range of flavors and toppings to suit every palate. From classic plain and everything bagels to unique options like asiago cheese or blueberry, there’s something for everyone’s taste preferences
7 Best Breakfast Spots in Marathon, FL
An authentic New York-style bagel shop in the Florida Keys, Marathon Bagel Company has all the classic bagel and cream cheese combos, plus some fun flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Jalapeno-Cheddar, and Oreo. You can also get your bagel made into a breakfast sandwich piled high with eggs, cheese, and other fixings. Not in the mood for a bagel?
Best Breakfast In Marathon Florida
Marathon Bagel Co. & Deli is the perfect place to grab a quick breakfast on the go. They have a wide selection of bagels, sandwiches, and pastries to choose from. They are considered the first authentic bagel shop in the Keys and are a huge hit!
Where to Go in Marathon
Even better are the many different kinds of breakfast sandwiches you can get on the…. Get Details & Directions Marathon Bagel Co.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit