Cracked Conch Cafe
1 / 10

Cracked Conch Cafe

4.6
·491k reviews·,

A long-running, chill spot in Marathon serving locally sourced seafood and iconic conch dishes with a tropical patio vibe.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Cracked Conch Cafe

Cracked Conch Cafe

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A long-running, chill spot in Marathon serving locally sourced seafood and iconic conch dishes with a tropical patio vibe.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"This place has my heart. Quaint & beachy, but it's all about the food!"

TIP

Try the breakfast specials

Savor delicious breakfast options like Egg & Cheddar on Biscuit or homemade chipped beef.

Conch sourcing concerns?

Opt for other well-prepared seafood like fried snapper or grouper baskets if concerned about conch sourcing.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Open·Closes 9PM

Cuisine

Seafood / American

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(305) 743-2233

Address

4999 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, USA

Insta-Factor

Medium

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Iconic Conch Dishes

Iconic Conch Dishes

Savor the Keys' most iconic food with various conch preparations, from fritters to melts. Sourced from the Caribbean.

Heart of the Keys is a fun base12 Restaurants in Marathon, Florida Keys, Accessible By Dinghy Or By Foot From City Marina/Boot Key Harbor
Perfection Key Lime Pie

Perfection Key Lime Pie

Experience the legendary Key Lime Pie, available both regular and deep-fried, a must-try sweet ending.

Google Review+1
Tropical Ambiance

Tropical Ambiance

Enjoy a relaxed, beachy vibe with a covered outdoor patio perfect for a laid-back dining experience.

The Best Marathon, FL Seafood Restaurants & MarketsGoogle Review
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

@luisvalenz6
8 likes • 971 views

Try the breakfast specials

Savor delicious breakfast options like Egg & Cheddar on Biscuit or homemade chipped beef.

Conch sourcing concerns?

Opt for other well-prepared seafood like fried snapper or grouper baskets if concerned about conch sourcing.

Don't skip the pie!

The Key Lime Pie is perfection, and even better deep-fried. Heavenly!

Ask about extra sides

Consider asking for additional sides with sandwiches for an enhanced dining experience.

Tips

from all over the internet

Try the breakfast specials

Savor delicious breakfast options like Egg & Cheddar on Biscuit or homemade chipped beef.

Conch sourcing concerns?

Opt for other well-prepared seafood like fried snapper or grouper baskets if concerned about conch sourcing.

Don't skip the pie!

The Key Lime Pie is perfection, and even better deep-fried. Heavenly!

Ask about extra sides

Consider asking for additional sides with sandwiches for an enhanced dining experience.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Cracked Conch Cafe is celebrated for its consistently good food, friendly service, and relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Many rave about the iconic conch dishes and the legendary Key Lime Pie, highlighting the value of generous portions for reasonable prices. While some find it a bit pricey, the overall experience is described as awesome and worth revisiting.

"OMH (oh my heavens)! Yes! This place has my heart. Quaint & beachy, but it's all about the food! I adored my Snapper Melt on Rye so much, I would choose it for my last meal!! And the Key Lime Pie was a tasty finish to lunch in paradise! My husband had a meaty omelette & fruit & loved every bite."

Cher Couvillion Wilson

"The blue crab and bacon Benedict was very good! My eggs were a little runnier than I like them (had some runniness in the whites) but they happily remade it for me. If you don't like runny whites, just let them know when you order it."

Marie Griffin

"Cracked Conch has an old-timey diner feel, no frills but the food, service, and vibe of the place is awesome. It feels like you’re coming home to have a meal. The Key Lime Pie is perfection, both regular and deep fried! The staff is friendly and attentive.

The ahi tuna was delicious as was the snapper, the twice baked potato was golden brown and wonderful as well."

Jenn C.

What People Like

Iconic conch dishes
Legendary Key Lime Pie
Friendly and attentive service

What People Dislike

Can be pricey
Occasional runny egg whites

Frequently Asked Questions

The cracked conch, conch fritters, and Key Lime Pie (regular and deep-fried) are highly recommended.

12 Restaurants in Marathon, Florida Keys, Accessible By Dinghy Or By Foot From City Marina/Boot Key HarborGoogle Review+1

Conch meat is now sourced from the Caribbean, as local harvesting has been prohibited since the mid-1980s.

Heart of the Keys is a fun base

It's a chill, long-running spot with a relaxed, beachy vibe and a covered outdoor patio.

Google Review

Yes, they offer an excellent breakfast with options like Egg & Cheddar on Biscuit and homemade chipped beef.

Google Review

Yes, they offer a kids' menu and a welcoming atmosphere, making it suitable for families.

Top 11 Florida Keys Kid-Friendly Restaurants - Tripping.com Rentals

The servers are accommodating for puppies, suggesting a dog-friendly environment.

Google Review

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

TRIP.COM

Shopping itineraries in Island Gift Shop in November (updated in 2024)

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina | Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House | Butterfly Café | Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar | King Seafood- Market & Restaurant | Brutus Seafood Market & Eatery | Subway | Triton Seafood Restaurant Italian Cuisine & Pizza | Mahina | Papa Johns Pizza | Marathon Grill and Ale House | Burger King | Harbor View Cafe | Driftwood Pizza, Pasta, & Subs | Barracuda Grill | Marathon Seafood Mkt & Grill | Panda House Chinese Restaurant And Buffet | The Stuffed Pig | Cracked Conch Cafe | Plaza Grill Restaurant, | KFC | S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill | The Bistro - Eat.

Visit Source →
Florida Rambler

Heart of the Keys is a fun base

Although it has not been legal to harvest conch in the Keys since the mid-1980s due to overfishing, conch matches key lime pie as the Keys’ most iconic food. Conch meat now comes from the Caribbean, but even the traditional fisheries in the Bahamas and Turks and Caicos are stressed, according to Seafood Watch at the Monterey Bay Aquarium. While it is impossible to get a straight answer from any restaurant server about where their conch comes from, there are lots of places to try conch fritters in the Keys.

Visit Source →
coconutcay.com

The Best Places to Grab Brunch Near Marathon, Florida

Situated at 4999 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, the Cracked Conch Cafe offers a wholesome brunch experience with its famous seafood dishes, including conch chowder and fritters. The waterfront setting allows for the freshest catches from nearby waters, making it a go-to spot for seafood enthusiasts. Open Monday through Sunday from 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM, the Cracked Conch Cafe’s menu promises a delightful return.

Visit Source →
Coco Plum Vacation Rentals

The Best Marathon, FL Seafood Restaurants & Markets

Definitely put the legendary Cracked Conch Cafe on your list for a tasty breakfast, lunch, or dinner on a tropical patio. It’s open every day for fan favorites like smoked fish dip and key lime pie, with Cuban coffee and refreshing cocktails also on offer. This relaxed eatery prides itself on homestyle cooking and conch specialties like conch capri and stuffed fish.

Visit Source →
Jenia's Travel Diaries - The world is a book, and those who do not travel read only a page.  - Saint Augustine

12 Restaurants in Marathon, Florida Keys, Accessible By Dinghy Or By Foot From City Marina/Boot Key Harbor

Owner Joe DeConda has spent forty years in the Keys and never left for a storm!. “People need to eat”, he says,” and I want to be here to help start the cleanup process.” The Cracked Conch Café is a place you must try especially if you’re interested to see many ways to prepare conch. First off, you must try the conch chowders.

Visit Source →
Gamintraveler

Best Bahamian Food: 40 Best Bahamian Dishes

Visit Source →
Will Fly for Food

Bahamian Food: 15 Tasty Dishes in the Bahamas

Similar to fried clams or fried calamari, cracked conch is made with tenderized conch meat that’s been coated in a seasoned batter and then deep-fried. Because of its naturally tough and sturdy texture, conch meat greatly benefits from being pounded or chopped up into small pieces before cooking.

Visit Source →
findeatdrink.com

Florida Keys - Travel Guide

Chef Erik Desjarlais loves their cafe con leche and Cuban Mix. Chef Norman Van Aken goes for their “Black Eye Pea Fritter, called Bollos.” His warning: “that word in Spanish is a euphemism for a woman's most personal area. I have been taken to task on that one!

Visit Source →
Jolly Roger

Dining - Jolly Roger

MM 49.84999 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050(305) 743-2233Chill, long-running spot offering a menu of locally sourced seafood, plus outdoor seating.Open daily. Sat, Sun, Mon, Tues, Fri 7am- 10:30pm. Wed and Thurs 9:30am-10:30pm.m.mainstreethub.com/conchcafe

Visit Source →
Vacation Rentals - Beach Houses, Condos, Cabins, Apartments & Vacation Homes | TRIPPING

Top 11 Florida Keys Kid-Friendly Restaurants - Tripping.com Rentals

Start your day off right with a plate of buttermilk pancakes for the kids at the Cracked Conch Café. For the adults, made-to-order omelets come with a variety of add-in options. Select a booth with a view of the grill so kids can watch the chef at work.

Visit Source →
Getting Stamped

Best Breakfast In Marathon Florida

A must-try restaurant in Marathon, the Cracked Conch Cafe is a local favorite. They’re open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and serve up some of the most delicious food in town. Its a great place to grab something to eat no matter what time of day.

Visit Source →
Currently Traveling

The Best Places to Eat in Marathon, Florida

4999 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050 facebook.com/TheCrackedConchCafe. We’ve heard this is a great spot to try for breakfast and is known for the Key lime pie. It also seems to be a good option if you’re craving some diner-style meals!

Visit Source →
keyvaca.com

Where to Go in Marathon

Visit Source →