
Alimentari
An Italian market and deli offering epic sandwiches, homemade pasta, and a curated selection of specialty imported and local goods.

Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Alimentari

Highlights
Must-see attractions
An Italian market and deli offering epic sandwiches, homemade pasta, and a curated selection of specialty imported and local goods.
"Epic sandwiches and a beautifully curated selection of Italian products make this a must-visit spot."
Signature Sandwich Picks
Try the Spicy Sopressata or Italian Beef for flavorful, must-have sandwich experiences.
Picnic Perfection
Grab a sandwich, pasta salad, or gelato to go and enjoy a picnic in a nearby park.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian Deli
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Epic Sandwiches
Indulge in generously portioned, unique sandwiches crafted with high-quality ingredients on delicious sourdough bread.

Authentic Italian Market
Discover a curated selection of imported Italian products, local produce, artisanal cheeses, wines, and more.

Homemade Pasta
Enjoy freshly made pasta and sauces, perfect for creating a delicious Italian meal at home.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Signature Sandwich Picks
Try the Spicy Sopressata or Italian Beef for flavorful, must-have sandwich experiences.
Picnic Perfection
Grab a sandwich, pasta salad, or gelato to go and enjoy a picnic in a nearby park.
Avoid the Crowds
Visit during off-peak hours as there is no indoor seating available.
Explore Beverage Options
Discover unique N/A cocktails, wines, and other offerings to enjoy at home.
Tips
from all over the internet
Signature Sandwich Picks
Try the Spicy Sopressata or Italian Beef for flavorful, must-have sandwich experiences.
Picnic Perfection
Grab a sandwich, pasta salad, or gelato to go and enjoy a picnic in a nearby park.
Avoid the Crowds
Visit during off-peak hours as there is no indoor seating available.
Explore Beverage Options
Discover unique N/A cocktails, wines, and other offerings to enjoy at home.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Alimentari is praised for its delicious, generously portioned sandwiches and its extensive selection of high-quality Italian specialty items. While the food is a clear highlight, the lack of dine-in seating means most visitors opt for takeout, making it ideal for picnics or enjoying at home. Some reviewers mention that certain sandwiches could be elevated with additional ingredients, but the overall consensus is positive regarding freshness and flavor.
"I’ve heard so many good things about this place, we decided to try! It was amazing! Sandwiches were delicious and I love that they use Madison sourdough bread! Walking into the store felt fresh and clean! I didn’t have a lot of time to look around but the displays were beautiful! Food and ingredients are high quality and the staff was very friendly! So excited to have a sandwich shop like this on the near west side!!"
Sara D
"Definitely the best sandwich I’ve ever had. I just got the plain turkey, but the meat was so flavorful, and you can just tell everything is fresh and homemade. One sandwich is very filling and it was the perfect ratio of meat to toppings and sauce. Would definitely recommend!!"
Faith F
"I was able to find very good guanciale, pecorino, and even authentic spaghetti pasta to make a delicious homemade carbonara that was to die for! The staff are incredibly friendly and helpful! I was even able to find mozzarella di bufala which was amazing! Definitely will be returning many times"
Rebekah Suneson
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
No, Alimentari does not have indoor seating. It is primarily a deli and market for takeout orders.
The Spicy Sopressata and Italian Beef sandwiches are frequently recommended for their unique flavors and generous portions.
Yes, Alimentari offers homemade pasta and sauces that you can purchase to prepare at home.
You can find a variety of imported Italian products, including wines, cheeses, cured meats, pasta, and more.
Absolutely! Many customers grab their orders to enjoy in nearby parks, making it a great spot for a picnic.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best Restaurants in Madison: Coolest, Hottest, Newest Places to Eat
MarquetteAn offshoot of nearby A Pig in a Fur Coat, Alimentari is equal parts Italian market and deli—think Eataly, but scaled for Madison’s ~260,000-person population. But the Williamson Street-adjacent shop offers all of the appeal of its lauded urban relative. Browse wines, fresh pastas, or niche sundries, and don’t leave before ordering a sandwich.
Romantic Restaurants in Madison, WI
If you want to see a totally different side of chef Daniel Bonanno's culinary prowess, head down the street to his Italian deli Alimentari where you can get epic sandwiches and all the fixings for a romantic picnic.Head chef and Best Chef of the Midwest semifinalist Dan Fox at Heritage Tavern goes beyond farm-to-table cuisine by raising his own pigs for use at his and other Madison-area restaurants. Heritage is cozy and its menu is elevated with some of the finest produce and meat Wisconsin has to offer.
Madison area dining: 11 just-opened restaurants, and 19 to come | Food & Drink
Chef Dan Bonanno, his brother Enrico Bonanno and Dan’s Pig in a Fur Coat co-founder Bonnie Arent opened Alimentari in 2018 in a little strip mall just off Willy Street. Now they’re expanding, having signed a 10-year lease for the former Roman Candle location on Monroe Street. Dan Bonanno said to expect fresh pastas, cured meats and Italian cheese, as well as sandwiches made with these things, plus olives and pasta salads, prepared freezer meals (lasagna), fresh mozzarella and prepared sauces.
Shop These 10 Madison-Area Specialty Food Markets
Mortadella or prosciutto sliced paper- thin as it is in Italy; freshly-made pasta and sauces; even take-and-bake lasagna. This epicurean deli owned by the folks at A Pig in a Fur Coat carries select imported Italian products along with the best local ones to offer the perfect stop for your next dinner or charcuterie board. Don’t forget to order a fresh sandwich to-go, made with Madison Sourdough bread.
Cozy up at 11 businesses specializing in homemade pasta | Dining & Drink
It’s relatively easy to understand the Alimentari motto: “good food, good people.” Customers can order homemade ravioli, tagliatelle or the bestselling bucatini at this Italian product and sandwich shop. Co-owner Bonnie Arent suggests making any one of their pastas at home with fresh tomato sauce and Parmesan cheese.
20 Dog Friendly Things to Do in Madison, Wisconsin
When you’re ready for lunch, visit Alimentari, a high-end market that makes deli sandwiches, fresh pasta, sauce, cheese, and more. There’s no seating inside, so grab your items to go and find a nice park and set up a picnic with your dog.
Madison’s Best New Bars and Restaurants
The European-style deli and food shop, formerly on Brearly Street, opened in its new home on Monroe Street in Knickerbocker Place to offer an expanded selection of meats, cheeses and wines.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit