Good 'N Plenty Restaurant
A beloved farmhouse eatery serving authentic Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine with a memorable family-style dining experience since 1969.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Good 'N Plenty Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved farmhouse eatery serving authentic Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine with a memorable family-style dining experience since 1969.
"Experience the hearty flavors and communal joy of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking at this charming farmhouse restaurant."
Try the Dutch Sampler
For an authentic experience, opt for the Dutch Sampler with fried chicken, meatloaf, and pork.
Family Style Feast
Embrace the all-you-can-eat family style for a wide selection of traditional dishes.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pennsylvania Dutch
Price
Mid-range
Address
150 Eastbrook Rd, Smoketown, PA 17576, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Pennsylvania Dutch Family Style
Experience generous portions of traditional favorites served communally in a cozy farmhouse setting.
The Delicious Dutch Sampler
A hearty plate featuring fried chicken, meatloaf, and pork with sauerkraut, served with classic sides.
Decadent Desserts
Indulge in classic Pennsylvania Dutch sweets like apple crumb pie or shoefly pie, often served with ice cream.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Dutch Sampler
For an authentic experience, opt for the Dutch Sampler with fried chicken, meatloaf, and pork.
Family Style Feast
Embrace the all-you-can-eat family style for a wide selection of traditional dishes.
A La Carte Option Available
If family-style isn't for you, choose ala carte options in a separate dining room.
Visit in the Off-Season
Avoid crowds by visiting during the quieter winter months.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Dutch Sampler
For an authentic experience, opt for the Dutch Sampler with fried chicken, meatloaf, and pork.
Family Style Feast
Embrace the all-you-can-eat family style for a wide selection of traditional dishes.
A La Carte Option Available
If family-style isn't for you, choose ala carte options in a separate dining room.
Visit in the Off-Season
Avoid crowds by visiting during the quieter winter months.
Save Room for Dessert
Don't forget to explore the downstairs bakery for freshly baked goods.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners frequently praise the excellent food, generous portions, and friendly service, making it a worthwhile stop for authentic Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine. While the family-style dining is a highlight for many, some find the desserts a bit too sweet. The atmosphere is generally described as pleasant and communal, with the added bonus of a gift shop and bakery.
"Oh my gosh! The Dutch Sampler has fried chicken, meatloaf and pork with saurkraut, I had whipped potatoes and chow chow as my sides and It. Was. Delicious! Becky was our server and she was pleasant, helpful and so quick. I highly recommend this restaurant, they have a nice shop also."
Patti B Johnson
"Came here tonight for dinner and everything was really good. We chose the family style dining which was all you can eat fried chicken, baked ham, meatloaf, mashed potatoes, corn, green beans, buttered noodles, apple sauce, gravy, bread, butter or apple butter. For dessert we chose apple crumb pie with ice cream and shoefly pie with ice cream. The atmosphere was really friendly with a gift shop and bakery downstairs. Well worth the short wait and the money."
John Moss
"We opted to go to the other dining room as we wanted to order from their ala carte menu rather than their family style all you can eat option. It was a good choice as the portion size was generous as you can see from the attached pictures. We were also served their super soft bread with whipped butter and jam so we certainly had our fill!"
Rock U
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The restaurant is famous for its all-you-can-eat family-style dining, where dishes are brought to your communal table. An a la carte menu is also available in a separate dining room.
While the emphasis is on traditional meat dishes, inquire about vegetarian sides and the availability of vegetarian options on the a la carte menu.
Yes, the family-style dining is often a hit with kids, and there are specific kids' menus available.
First-time visitors often enjoy the 'Dutch Sampler' or the all-you-can-eat family-style dining to experience a variety of traditional dishes.
Absolutely! There is a bakery downstairs offering a variety of freshly baked Pennsylvania Dutch treats.
The restaurant can get busy, especially during peak tourist seasons. Visiting during the winter months or on weekdays can offer a quieter experience.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Lancaster, PA Restaurants - Fodor's Travel Talk Forums
If you want Pennsylvania Dutch style food, you can get this in family-style presentation at Good and Plenty (been here and enjoyed it) or Plain and Fancy Farm or Stoltzfus Farm Restaurant, or in smorgasbord type presentation at Shady Maple or Miller's.
The 14 Best Amish Restaurants Near Lancaster PA
Established in 1969 by Christ and Dolly Lapp, Good ‘N Plenty began its journey in a farmhouse built in 1871, offering a cozy, family-style dining experience. Initially seating about 114 guests, the restaurant has expanded over the years to accommodate over 500 diners, making this a great choice for larger groups. Good N Plenty isn’t just for tourists, either, but is a beloved spot for locals as well, especially during the quieter winter months.
Things To Do in Lancaster With Kids
Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant in Lancaster County, PA has been serving authentic PA Dutch meals family style dining since 1969. If you’re a social family with the kind of kids that love to tell family secrets, the family style seating could be lots of fun. The host will always introduce you to your tablemates with where they’re from and then let the fun begin.
13 Things to Do in Lancaster Pa: Endless Family Fun
We did stop here for dinner on our way to our house rental on the recommendation of friends. So many people told me we had to eat here to experience one of Amish country’s classic homestyle family restaurants!. They have family style, a la carte and kids menus depending on the size of your group or personal preference.
Exploring with Kids: 36 Hours in Lancaster, PA
If you like family-style dining, then head to Good ‘N Plenty. The food is delicious though dare I say you may get too much food (mind you, this was my first experience with dining family-style). Look for fried chicken, mashed potatoes, ham loaf, shoo-fly pie and so much more.
Amish group spends $2.9M for former Good N Plenty restaurant, plans health care clinic for church members | Local Business
Well Spring Care Inc. paid $2.9 million last week for the 8.5-acre property along Route 896 just north of Route 30 where Good N Plenty closed in December after serving traditional Pennsylvania Dutch food to visitors for more than a half-century.
Smorgasboard | Food | Lancaster County
Good N' Plenty Restaurant has been serving up a unique Pennsylvania Dutch dining experience. Good N' Plenty offers guests family-style dining, menu dining, convenient takeout, an award-winning bakery, and an extensive gift shop
Pa.’s best small-town restaurant is in Lancaster County, according to Thrillist
For Pennsylvania, Thrillist sided with a popular Lancaster County family-style spot, Good N’ Plenty Restaurant in Smoketown, population 357. (Despite what you think, it’s not named after the pink and white licorice candy.)
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit