Sale Pepe has reopened in Lahaina as of March 2025! We had the pleasure of returning to dine here this evening. Enjoy a few photos that captured our experience.
1 / 10

Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina

4.6
·491k reviews·,

An authentic Italian bistro on Maui, renowned for its wood-fired pizzas, fresh house-made pastas, and resilient spirit.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Sale Pepe has reopened in Lahaina as of March 2025! We had the pleasure of returning to dine here this evening. Enjoy a few photos that captured our experience.

Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

An authentic Italian bistro on Maui, renowned for its wood-fired pizzas, fresh house-made pastas, and resilient spirit.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"The best Italian restaurant on Maui, with amazing food and a lovely atmosphere!"

TIP

Book Ahead

Reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant can get very busy.

Explore Unique Flavors

Try Sicilian olives with rosemary or risotto with black truffle-infused burrata for a memorable dish.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens Monday 5PM

Cuisine

Italian

Price

$$$

Phone

(808) 667-7667

Address

157 Kupuohi St STE J1, Lahaina, HI 96761, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Authentic Neapolitan Pizza

Authentic Neapolitan Pizza

Indulge in artisanal Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a traditional wood-fired oven, using the finest ingredients.

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui20 of the Absolute Best Lahaina Restaurants You Have to Check Out
House-Made Pastas

House-Made Pastas

Experience exquisite, house-made pastas crafted with passion and premium ingredients, like the seasonal porcini on papardelle.

9 Days on MauiGoogle Review
Resilient Spirit

Resilient Spirit

This beloved Italian eatery has rebuilt and reopened, embodying the strength and spirit of the Lahaina community.

TikTokGoogle Review+1
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

The first business lost in the fire to rebuild and reopen in #Lahaina. #lahainapersempre #ciaoyoaloha
@salepepemauimaui
305 likes • 5.2K views

Book Ahead

Reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant can get very busy.

Explore Unique Flavors

Try Sicilian olives with rosemary or risotto with black truffle-infused burrata for a memorable dish.

#amatriciana #bucatini #lahainapersempre #ciaoyoaloha
@salepepemauimaui
1.3K likes • 26.7K views
Early Mothers Day Dinner ❤️ check out the new location of your favorite authentic Italian Restaurant. Sale Pepe, Lahaina YUMMMMM
@nikki_alcantaraofficial
15 likes • 396 views

Early Dinners

Dining in Hawaii tends to be early, so expect to dine before sunset, even without a reservation.

Check Lanai Seating

If you prefer outdoor seating with alcohol, confirm availability as lanai seating may have restrictions.

#ciaoyoaloha #lahainapersempre The first business lost to the Lahaina fire to be rebuilt! mangiare!
@salepepemauimaui
1.7K likes • 36.4K views

Tips

from all over the internet

Book Ahead

Reservations are highly recommended as the restaurant can get very busy.

Explore Unique Flavors

Try Sicilian olives with rosemary or risotto with black truffle-infused burrata for a memorable dish.

Early Dinners

Dining in Hawaii tends to be early, so expect to dine before sunset, even without a reservation.

Check Lanai Seating

If you prefer outdoor seating with alcohol, confirm availability as lanai seating may have restrictions.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Sale Pepe is celebrated for its authentic Italian cuisine, particularly its wood-fired pizzas and house-made pastas, which diners consistently praise for freshness and flavor. The service is often described as attentive and friendly, with many highlighting the owners' personal touch and the warm ambiance. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, some diners have noted inconsistencies in service speed and a higher price point for the island.

"First time at Sale Pepe. It's been open 110 days since the fires destroyed its original location. We got various dishes to share between 4 of us. We were seated upstairs. Cass was our waitress. Very friendly, good service. Food was great - nice to have delicious Italian in Maui."

Daniela Grasso

"Mix review on this restaurant. Monday night and we were sat around 30 minutes after walking up. Quickly ordered and some of the food came out. Salad was good, and the rice balls were delicious. But the waiter forgot about our drink, when she brought it over the ice was melted in the cup but she opened the bottle and poured it anyways, Causing it to be watered down. Then for some reason they turned on super loud music on the patio halfway through our meal which was odd. But fine. Then we waited for our pizza… and waited. And waited… it took around 40 minutes after we finished the appetizers. She said the pizza station was backed up but other tables got them just fine. I think she forgot to ring it in. Anyways the sausage on it was super lack luster but the crust was good. I think we’d come back for the food the service just sucked."

Katherine Walker

"Ambiance-We went her as a family of 4 with kids. We got there right when they opened and made reservations. They sat us down right away. The owner was letting us in. There was soft music playing and place had only been open for the last 72 days. There were two stories, with indoor and outdoor dining available and we were sitting inside. They didn’t ask us what we preferred when we made reservations. Place was clean.

Food- every single food item we got was amazing. You could tell they made fresh to order with really good quality ingredients. We got two classic margaherita pizza to share, gnocchi in sauce, the side of bread, 1 Italian soda each and lemon and vanilla gelato to end the course. They were all delicious. I would recommend all. They don’t have traditional branded beverages like coke or Pepsi. They Italian sodas and no diet options.

Customer service- our waitress was nice and felt like they knew the menu inside and out. They were also accommodating with kid friendly modifications. I can see that all staff was working hard and tending to everyone’s needs.

Price- it was on the pricey side. We spent $204 on the meal and soft drinks described above for a family of 4.

I would highly recommend going to check this place out and I would go again next time we come back to Maui to visit."

Fernando Mendoza

What People Like

Authentic Neapolitan pizzas
Delicious house-made pastas
Warm, attentive service

What People Dislike

Occasional service delays
Price point

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, making a reservation in advance is highly recommended as Sale Pepe can get very busy.

Google Review

Sale Pepe is famous for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas from a wood-fired oven and its delicious house-made pastas.

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, MauiGoogle Review

They offer indoor and outdoor dining. If you prefer outdoor seating with alcohol, it's advised to check beforehand.

They offer Italian sodas but do not have traditional branded beverages like Coke or Pepsi, and no diet options are available.

Google Review

The restaurant is on the pricier side, with a family of four spending around $204 for a full meal.

Google Review

Yes, they are accommodating with kid-friendly modifications and have a welcoming atmosphere for families.

Google Review

Sale Pepe has reopened in Lahaina, with its new location operating since March 2025, after rebuilding from the fires.

TikTokGoogle Review

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

Lonely Planet

Best restaurants Maui, Hawaii

Visit Source →
Suites & Lobbies

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui

Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina, tucked away in the lively town of Lahaina on Maui’s captivating coastline, is an extraordinary culinary destination for pizza connoisseurs and Italian food lovers alike. This authentic Italian eatery, celebrated for its warm hospitality and elegant atmosphere, specializes in crafting artisanal Neapolitan-style pizzas, expertly prepared in their traditional wood-fired oven. Using only the finest ingredients imported from Italy and locally sourced from the island, Sale Pepe offers a menu that showcases the perfect balance of classic and innovative flavors.

Visit Source →

9 Days on Maui

Hawaii Tasting Tours takes the idea of progressive dining to the next level: On this epicurean journey through Lahaina, guests meet at Fleetwood’s on Front St., where a spirited, knowledgeable guide will take you to a smattering of premier restaurants for samples of signature dishes, including prime rib from Lahaina Fish Co., hand-rolled pasta with kale and sausage from Sale Pepe, and fresh-veggie stirfry from Koa’s Seaside Grill. Accompanied by an educational foray into Hawaii and its burgeoning food scene, this is a terrific way to “feed” the 5 senses.

Visit Source →
vacationhomerents.com

Cheap Places to Eat in Maui

Visit Source →
Hawaii Ocean Project | Maui Whale Watching Tours | Dinner Cruises

Best Italian Food on Maui - HOP to it - Hawaii Ocean Project | Maui Whale Watching Tours

While best known for the pizzas that come out of their custom-made stove piping hot, Sale Pepe also offers flavorful pasta dishes. After numerous visits to Maui, the owners of Sale Pepe decided to sell their restaurant in Brooklyn (the male half of the husband/wife duo who own the restaurant is originally from Milan) and make a go of it on Maui. Even though it's one of the best Italian restaurant in Lahaina, the prices are actually quite low for the quality of the meal.

Visit Source →
Alex on the Map

20 of the Absolute Best Lahaina Restaurants You Have to Check Out

Sale Pepe Restaurant is a highly-rated Italian restaurant situated in the heart of Lahaina. Known for its authentic cuisine, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere, the establishment is a favorite among visitors and locals alike. On the menu here, you can expect to find a wide variety of house-made pasta such as seafood linguine, wood-fired pizza, and seafood options, as well as a selection of delectable appetizers.

Visit Source →
HawaiianIslands.com

15 of the Top Maui Restaurants

Formed from a bond of family, travel, and a love for food — Sale Pepe delivers true authentic Italian food in the heart of Lahaina. The plates at Sale Pepe are made with fresh and local ingredients and are presented in a creative way destined to delight. Try out some Sicilian olives with a hint of rosemary or maybe some risotto with black truffle-infused burrata.

Visit Source →
Travellers Worldwide

15 Best Restaurants in Maui, Hawaii in 2024

The motto for this restaurant is “this too shall pasta”, which is particularly fitting during these trying times. Chef Michele di Bari brings traditional Italian flavors with a twist in this unassuming eatery on the island’s east side. Everything on offer at this restaurant is spectacular and many gravitate toward the wood-fired pizzas with creative toppings.

Visit Source →
Pride of Maui Local Travel Blog

Local Businesses Reopen After Fires

Sale Pepe brings a slice of Italy to Lahaina with its warmth, charm, and authentic Italian cuisine and plans to reopen in Spring 2025. This cozy eatery is a top choice for pasta lovers and those looking for a taste of Italy in the heart of Maui. From handmade pasta to wood-fired pizzas, each dish at Sale Pepe is made with passion and the freshest ingredients.

Visit Source →
Foodie on the Road

10 Wonderful Local Places to Eat in Maui Hawaii

Sale Pepe is an authentic and highly rated Italian restaurant tucked away on a side street in a small strip mall in Lahaina, and turned out to be one of the favorite local places to eat in Maui Hawaii. A very upscale restaurant with a renowned head chef, this one is an award winner. It’s a great place to have some unexpected fresh food with a local twist!

Visit Source →
The Hawaii Vacation Guide

The 10 Best Restaurants in Lahaina: Something for Everyone

Reservations: Strongly recommendedIndoor or outdoor dining: BothPrice point: $17+ for pizza. I know you’re not coming to Maui for Italian food, but this restaurant is worthy of a top mention. If you need a break from fish and you’re craving a little something different, this spot makes food that almost makes you feel like you’re in Italy.

Visit Source →
Maui Westside

Best Pizza Spots on Maui

Sale Pepe (Lahaina) - If you are after an all round Italian dining in Lahaina then Sale Pepe is the best on the West Side of Maui. Their Pizza is artisanal Italian style with local ingredients & with a homemade charm. There pastas are also incredible with our favorite being the lasagna, you just can’t go wrong here!

Visit Source →
One Day Itinerary

One day in Lahaina, Hawaii (Guide)

Sale Pepe is an excellent choice if you’re in the mood for some Italian cuisine, and their brick-oven pizzas are just excellent. Kimo’s Maui, on the other hand, is a seafood restaurant with a long tradition that boasts a fantastic view of the harbor. Oh, and you must try their Hula Pie!.

Visit Source →
Jeffsetter Travel

Outstanding Italian Food at Sale Pepe Maui

Aside from checking out Waicoco, my other restaurant goal for our Maui trip was to finally try Sale Pepe Maui. Hailed as one of the best restaurants in the islands by many of Hawaii’s top chefs, Sale Pepe has long been on my to-try list. And I’m glad we finally got here.

Visit Source →
The Professional Mom Project

Best Kid Friendly Restaurants in Maui

Sale Pepe is a bit off the beaten path in Lahaina but it’s so worth looking for. The food was great, the service was very friendly and they were happy to make any type of pasta our kiddo wanted. They also have fantastic pizza and pasta for the adults in your group.

Visit Source →
Maui Trip Guide | Best Things to Do and See

Where to Eat on Maui: The Ultimate Food Lover's Guide | Best Maui Restaurants - Maui Trip Guide

You wouldn’t think that a tropical island in the middle of the Pacific Ocean would have an exceptional Italian restaurant, but they do. Sale Pepe’s owners hail from New York and Italy, and the couple have ferried their love of Italian food to the shores of Maui.

Visit Source →
mauimarket.com.ar

fodor's maui restaurants

If you're in the mood for some amazing Italian food while on Maui, you have to check out Sale Pepe!!!. Thats Cool Cat Cafe. Lunch is served daily from 11:00am to 3:30pm and includes pupus, salads, seafood specialities, burgers, sandwiches and dessert.

Visit Source →
DineRank.com

6 Best Italian Restaurants In Lahaina, HI

Sale Pepe is a restaurant located in Lahaina, Hawaii at 878 Front St. They are open every day except Sunday. Pastas and artisanal Italian pizzas, crafted by a certified pizzaiola with fresh, local ingredients in classic and creative presentations.

Visit Source →
Restaurant Clicks

25 Best Restaurants in Maui, HI

878 Front St #7,8, Lahaina, HI 96761Phone: 808-667-7667 Visit Website. A post shared by Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina (@salepepemaui). Right next to Wo Hing Temple Museum, you’ll discover Sale Pepe, a unique little slice of Italy right in Maui.

Visit Source →
Honolulu Magazine

A Reimagined Pacific’o at a Taste of Maui

While the restaurant is still owned by Louis Coulombe, Michele and Qiana Di Bari of nearby Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina have signed on as managing partners. The broad revitalization also includes new furnishings, and the new vibe is palpable.

Visit Source →
What The Fab

12 Restaurants That You Have To Try In 2023

Sale Pepe serves classic Italian style cooking made with fresh local ingredients. Their motto is one part Milan, one part Brooklyn, all Maui, and I just love that. They’re open Monday through Saturday from 5 pm to 9 pm serving dinner only.

Visit Source →
The Sweetest Escapes

15 Best Maui Restaurants with great views with map

An Italian and New Yorker opened an Italian joint in Hawaii and it is PERFECTION!. We had a few of their pizzas and pasta and can’t wait to come back for more. We ordered 2 pizzas and a pasta dish and got 3 meals out of it for the 2 of us.

Visit Source →
Sakamoto Properties

Best Food in Maui for Curbside Takeout

Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina: Craving an Italian dinner but don’t want to drive far from your piece of paradise in West Maui?. This spot on Lahaina’s Front Street is for you!. Be sure to call ahead to order off their online menu.

Visit Source →
travelmagazine.com

7 Restaurants You Need to Visit in Maui

When you think of Hawaii, Italian cuisine is probably not the first thing to come to mind. Still, Sale Pepe is bringing authentic and delicious Italian food to Maui finally. A talented husband-and-wife team runs the restaurant.

Visit Source →
Hawaiian Local

Restaurants in Lahaina , HI

s Best Italian Restaurant award winner, Sale Pepe is a family-owned authentic Italian restaurant where Chef Michele Di Bari masterfully mixes traditional Italian cuisine with modern technique, combining fresh local and se…

Visit Source →
Family Destinations Guide

15 Best Restaurants in Lahaina, HI for 2025 (Top Eats!)

878 Front StLahaina, HI 96761(808) 667-7667 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. This award-winning restaurant in the heart of Lahaina is famous for its authentic Italian dishes served in a casual setting.

Visit Source →
CHUBBY DIARIES - LIVE LIFE NOW

Must-Visit Restaurants in Maui - CHUBBY DIARIES

Sale Pepe is owned by a husband and wife team who met in New York. Here you’ll find authentic Italian food like house-made pasta and pizza. This is absolutely a must visit restaurant in Maui.

Visit Source →
reddit

I’m staying just North of Lahaina and am having a hard time finding really tasty eateries. The tourist restaurants are really meh. Where are the delicious places to eat? : maui

My favorites in the area: Monkeypod, Merrimans, Sale Pepe, Fridas, Honu, Sansei. If you don’t like those than our taste buds are very different lol

Visit Source →
Atly

Top 50 Gluten-Free Dinner Spots Across Lahaina

Visit Source →
Maui No Ka Oi Magazine

La Dolce Vita | Sale Pepe | A Fianco

Visit Source →