Island Cream Co.
A Maui paradise for frozen treats, boasting over 150 handmade gelato flavors and a unique self-serve shaved ice station. Pure indulgence!
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Island Cream Co.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A Maui paradise for frozen treats, boasting over 150 handmade gelato flavors and a unique self-serve shaved ice station. Pure indulgence!
"Spectacular ice cream with the coolest flavors that deliver on their titles!"
Ask for Free Toppings
Don't forget to ask for free toppings like condensed milk to elevate your shaved ice experience.
DIY Shaved Ice Fun
Customize your shaved ice with dozens of syrup flavors for a fun, self-serve experience. Be mindful of drips!
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Dessert Shop / Ice Cream
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Over 150 Handmade Gelato & Ice Cream Flavors
Indulge in a dizzying array of over 150 unique, handcrafted gelato and ice cream flavors, with 36 made fresh daily. Pure bliss!
Customizable Glacier Ice Station
Create your own refreshing shaved ice masterpiece from 36 vibrant syrup flavors, making each visit a fun, personalized experience.
Inventive & Unique Creations
Beyond the classics, discover unique treats like Turtle Ice Cream, Peanut Butter Pie, and the Sposhy for an unforgettable dessert adventure.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Ask for Free Toppings
Don't forget to ask for free toppings like condensed milk to elevate your shaved ice experience.
DIY Shaved Ice Fun
Customize your shaved ice with dozens of syrup flavors for a fun, self-serve experience. Be mindful of drips!
Consider Sharing Large Treats
Indulge in decadent sundaes like the Mac nut brownie, which are generously portioned and perfect for sharing.
Allergy Awareness
Be cautious with nut allergies as workers may use the same scoop for different flavors.
Tips
from all over the internet
Ask for Free Toppings
Don't forget to ask for free toppings like condensed milk to elevate your shaved ice experience.
DIY Shaved Ice Fun
Customize your shaved ice with dozens of syrup flavors for a fun, self-serve experience. Be mindful of drips!
Consider Sharing Large Treats
Indulge in decadent sundaes like the Mac nut brownie, which are generously portioned and perfect for sharing.
Allergy Awareness
Be cautious with nut allergies as workers may use the same scoop for different flavors.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Island Cream Co. is celebrated for its incredible variety of handmade ice cream flavors and the fun, customizable shaved ice experience. While many praise the unique creations and friendly service, some find the prices to be on the higher side, and a note of caution regarding potential cross-contamination for severe allergies is worth mentioning. Despite minor concerns, it's a highly recommended spot for a sweet treat in Maui.
"Great gourmet ice cream shop with lots of flavours!
It’s hard to remember the name of what I got, because it was a funky name. Uniquely, it was the one that has pecan in it.
They had so many ice cream flavours to choose from, so it was very exciting to be in there.
Furthermore, the extra chocolate rolled wafer was a wonderful little surprise. I’ve been to many ice cream shops, and this shop truly has a presentation that goes above and beyond."
Amir Lopez
"A popular spot for obvious reasons, Island Cream Co has made a mark for itself by serving up delicious ice cream and shave ice in the area. Parking in the area is abundant and the place is clean despite syrup stations being out in the open. The shave ice is self serve on syrups so you can go crazy on yours or just add light flavoring. If you want ice cream or anything else they will prepare it in full for you behind the counter but beware of any allergies as we saw a worker scoop different flavors with the same scoop after the first scoop had touched one with nuts.
We ordered multiple different flavors of the ice cream and most were pretty good. They do also include a rolled chocolate wafer which was a nice touch for those who enjoy it. For those in our party who ordered the shave ice, they said it was good as well. The seating is a bit limited in the store so beware you may need to wait or take your stuff to go. This place has very good bones and I think one or two changes would make it even better,they have a unique product and we would recommend giving it a go if you’re in the area."
Amber Lee
"We had such a fun and delicious time at Island Cream Co.! We ordered the shaved ice from the Glacier Ice Station and it was an absolute treat. It was not only tasty but also a fun experience. Playing with the machine and choosing from all the colorful syrups felt like being a kid again. Pro tip: don’t forget to ask for free toppings like condensed milk, they’re happy to add it if you just ask!
But the real showstopper was the Sposhy. So refreshing, bright, and full of flavor. I absolutely loved it and will definitely be coming back for more. Perfect spot to cool off and enjoy some sweet fun!"
Bong Arquiza
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Their ice cream is a unique 'island cream' hybrid, handmade daily with natural ingredients and no preservatives. They offer over 150 flavors!
Yes, the Glacier Ice Station allows you to create your own shaved ice from 36 available syrup flavors.
The restaurant mentions having non-dairy options available.
Customers rave about flavors like Turtle, Peanut Butter Pie, Kaua'i Karmel, and island-inspired options such as Coconut Poi and Lilikoi Cheesecake.
Yes, they offer a 6 Mini Scoop Sampler, and the wide variety of flavors makes it easy to try several.
Some reviews suggest the prices can be high, especially for simple orders.
Yes, there is plenty of parking in the large lot of the strip mall where the restaurant is located.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best restaurants Maui, Hawaii
This aptly named old-timer has been slinging burgers, hot dogs and ice cream to midway road trippers for 30 years. The only ATM on the highway is here, as…
13 Spots for the Best Ice Cream in Maui (& Shave Ice!)
Topping the charts on a lot of “best ice cream” lists, Island Cream Co. is a popular spot for the largest selection of these frozen treats – over 150 flavors to be exact and 36 of them are made fresh daily!. The Kona-Karamel with roasted pecans or Bali-Buffalo Peanut will have your mouth watering as soon as it hits your taste buds. All products are handmade right in the shop using only natural ingredients – no preservatives added, so all the flavor comes directly from nature’s kitchen.
7 Best Ice Cream Shops In Maui
Known for its fresh, delicious, and inventive frozen treats, Island Cream Co. has earned a devoted following among both locals and tourists. Using high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients, they offer a delightful array of flavors, including island-inspired options like Pineapple Coconut, Lilikoi (passion fruit), and P.O.G. (pineapple, orange, guava). The shop also boasts a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and a friendly staff that contributes to a delightful customer experience.
10 Amazing Cheap Eats in Maui
Rated 11th Best in America by Yahoo Food, Island Cream Co. is a shop in Maui known for serving handmade gelato and ice cream. In fact, some of it’s best-selling ice cream includes Kaua‘i Karmel, S’mores, Lahaina Cream, Oatmeal Cookie, Turtle, many chocolate choices and two versions of Macadamia Nut. In addition, the shop also has fruit versions that include but are not limited to Pineapple Cream, Strawberry, Mango, Hawaiian Tropical and Blueberry.
5 Best Rated Ice Cream Shops in Lahaina Maui
Ranked 1 st as the best ice cream in Hawaii by Buzzfeed, 11th in the whole America byYahoo Food, 7th in the World’s Awesome Ice Cream Shops by Mozo, and many more!. Island Cream Co. is one of the most popular and favorite choice by many icecream lovers. The ice cream shop is located at Lahaina Gateway Center and opensevery day from 11:00 AM till 09:00 PM.
Best Desserts in Maui: Our Top 5 Picks
Island Cream Co. has received numerous accolades for its unique frozen treat that isn’t quite ice cream or gelato, but rather ‘Island Cream.’ Island Cream Co. makes their own waffle cones and infuses flavors like shortcake, popcorn, and chocolate cake right into each recipe. They have dozens of different flavors to pick from, as well as non-dairy options.
15 Best Maui Restaurants with great views with map
I'm not sure Island Cream Company just tastes better because it's in Hawaii (everything is better in Hawaii) or if it's their original recipe with the perfect mix of gelato and ice cream. All ice creams are hand made as well as their cones, fudge and other fun toppings. Most ice creams are natural and products are bought locally.
The Best Ice Cream in Maui: by a Mama and her Kids
They have the biggest selection of unique flavors, they serve huge portions, and have fresh delicious waffle cones. There is often a line up, but they move quickly and are always very friendly. The staff are happy to combine different flavors, accommodate requests, and were very helpful when my son dropped half his ice cream.
Maui with a Sweet Tooth: Best Maui Desserts
The tasty offerings at Island Cream Co are in a league of their own. Each day, Island Cream Co whips up 36 batches of their trademarked “island cream”— a unique ice cream gelato hybrid. Expect to find traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla alongside specialty creams like coconut poi and lilikoi cheesecake.
33 BEST Local Places to Eat in Maui (2025)
Island Cream Co. is one of our favorite Maui ice cream shops located in Lahaina. They dont’ just serve traditional ice cream, but a signature “Island Cream,” a combination of gelato, sorbet, and ice cream. With over 36 flavors to choose from, like Lilikoi Cheesecake and Pineapple Dole Whip, we keep coming back!!
11 Best Places to Eat in Maui Hawaii
If you’re looking for a sweet treat, head to Island Cream Co. From the outside, it looks like any other strip mall ice cream shop, but step inside and you’ll find the largest selection of handmade ice cream in Maui!. They offer 150 different flavors with a rotation of 36 made fresh daily in the store.
Yum for EVERYONE: Maui's Best Family-Friendly Restaurants!
After a day in the sun, treat the keiki to some delicious ice cream at Island Cream Co. This local favorite offers a range of flavors, including some unique ones like lilikoi (passionfruit) and haupia (coconut). They also have vegan options and homemade waffle cones.
Top Spots for Best Desserts Guide -
Island Cream Co. offers a mix of ice cream and gelato, creating a velvety smooth texture. Flavors include macadamia nut, pineapple, and root beer. They use local ingredients, adding to the authentic Maui taste.
Lahaina Best Shaved Ice
The Island Cream Co. is the only place where you can get Glacier Ice, a do-it-yourself shave ice company that puts you in charge.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit