Great Pie in Kissimmee
1 / 10

Broadway Pizza Bar

4.6
·491k reviews·,

A historic Kissimmee pizzeria serving authentic New York-style pizzas, casual bites, and a welcoming atmosphere. Dog-friendly patio available.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Great Pie in Kissimmee

Broadway Pizza Bar

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A historic Kissimmee pizzeria serving authentic New York-style pizzas, casual bites, and a welcoming atmosphere. Dog-friendly patio available.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"Best value in Kissimmee, with pizza that's perfectly cooked and delicious!"

TIP

Stick to the Pizza!

While other items like subs have received mixed reviews, the pizza is consistently praised as great.

Off-Peak for Best Service

Visit during less busy times to potentially avoid service delays, as noted by some patrons.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Open·Closes 9PM

Cuisine

Pizza, Italian

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(407) 847-7050

Address

403 Broadway, Kissimmee, FL 34741, USA

Insta-Factor

Medium

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

New York Style Pizza Perfection

New York Style Pizza Perfection

Authentic New York-style pizzas with fresh ingredients and a tangy sauce, celebrated by locals and visitors alike.

The Top 9 Pizza Shop Recommendations in KissimmeeGoogle Review+2
Historic Building Charm

Historic Building Charm

Dine in a unique space that was once a Coca-Cola Bottling Company and bicycle shop, offering a glimpse into local history.

A Visitor’s Guide to Downtown KissimmeeA Local’s Guide to Historic Downtown Kissimmee
Dog-Friendly Patio Dining

Dog-Friendly Patio Dining

Enjoy your meal al fresco on the covered patio where leashed dogs are welcomed, making it a great spot for pet owners.

Dog Friendly Activities in Kissimmee FLDog-Friendly Spots in Kissimmee You Need to Visit!Google Review
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

@broadwaypizzaa has launched another unique pizza which I had to definitely try. This pizza was a combination of meat, cheese and the tasty goodness. You can get this one in Rs 2500. It had both meat and chicken flavours. Visit your nearest Broadway branch and do share your feedback w me ✨ #explore #foodies #food #pizza #pizzalovers
@food_exploration_umair
5K likes • 263.8K views

Stick to the Pizza!

While other items like subs have received mixed reviews, the pizza is consistently praised as great.

Off-Peak for Best Service

Visit during less busy times to potentially avoid service delays, as noted by some patrons.

Tried this amazing deal from @broadwaypizzaa . You can have unlimited pizza & drinks for Rs.999. . . For more follow @foodum_moodum . . . . . . . . . #food #foodie #foodporn #iftar #unlimitedpizza #unlimitedoffer #iftarplatter #iftarbuffet #ramazanspecial #sehri #buffet #streetfood #foodblog #foodvlog #vlogger #foodphotography
@foodum_moodum
28.9K likes • 781.3K views
Calzone 🤤 Broadway 📍 Review: Calzone 8/10 [saucy, creamy and flavorful] @Broadway Pizza #broadway #calzone #trending #trendingsong #review #diljitdosanjh #fastfood #foodie #foodlovers #cheese #pizza #sandwish #chickencalzone #calzonepizza #calzone #fyp #viral #explore #anusha #exploremore #anushablogsofficial
@anushablogsofficial
124 likes • 14.4K views

Pet-Friendly Patio

Bring your furry friends to the covered porch seating area.

Order Popular Appetizers

Mozzarella sticks and garlic butter wings are recommended for a tasty start to your meal.

@broadwaypizzaa recently launched Shawarma Fusion Pizza on their menu. We tried their newly launched pizza in both Thin and Original Crust. Loaded with lots of cheese, Shawarma Toppings and Shawarma Sauce. Loved the unique Flavour of the newly launched Shawarma Pizza. We also tried their Appetizer Platter and Chocolate Pizza. Loved both of the products. Broadway’s newest addition is a MUST-TRY! ...
@bazla_afzal
27 likes • 2K views

Tips

from all over the internet

Stick to the Pizza!

While other items like subs have received mixed reviews, the pizza is consistently praised as great.

Off-Peak for Best Service

Visit during less busy times to potentially avoid service delays, as noted by some patrons.

Pet-Friendly Patio

Bring your furry friends to the covered porch seating area.

Order Popular Appetizers

Mozzarella sticks and garlic butter wings are recommended for a tasty start to your meal.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Broadway Pizza Bar is a popular spot known for its New York-style pizzas, with many praising the fresh ingredients and tangy sauce. However, some diners have encountered issues with food quality on non-pizza items like pasta or subs, and there have been reports of undercooked dough and poor food safety practices. Service is generally seen as friendly, though some suggest visiting during off-peak hours to avoid delays.

"We were in Kissimmee and just wanted to get some pizza. Boy, did we get SOME pizza. I just wish we had gotten the XL pizza! My wife chose the Supreme Pizza and Broadway Pizza did not disappoint! The pizza looked gorgeous. It was almost too beautiful to eat... almost. This ain't no ordinary pizza place. From the moment you grab the crust and pull the first slice away from the rest of the pizza, you can see the love and pride these folks put into that pizza. 🍕 ❤️ the ingredients were fresh! The sauce was sweet with chunks of tomato in them. It was perfect! 😍 Hana greeted us when we sat down, and until we left, she was constantly checking on us and even answered a question about another table's pizza. We are gonna have to go back and try that one, too. I didn't get a picture of the mozzarella sticks, but those golden triangles of love were so cheesey and stringy that we had to wrap the cheese around the breaded coating a few times so it wouldn't drag on the floor. We were there to order pizza, but that dipping sauce made me wish I was gonna get spaghetti! It was sweet and flavorful, and I pulled out a chunk of spaghetti like I found a gold nugget! The atmosphere was very calm and relaxed and we thoroughly enjoyed the experience. Stop here when you're in Kissimmee."

Stephen Winters

"Solid place... great wait staff. And super inexpensive.

I had only ordered the cheese pizza, so don't have much to judge it on here. I'm just not a fan of doughy pizza... but all.of the ingredients were fresh and the sauce had a nice zing to it!

Would return for sure."

Ryan Murphy

"Not impressed, a lot of order of the chicken Alfredo with grilled chicken, the flavor was good, but the noodles were overcooked and mushy and a lot of liquid, I really wanted the spoon, but the longer I waited for a server to come by colder my food got so I found myself Using the fork all the while my eye was looking for the server to ask for a spoon. Literally by the time she walked by I was pretty much done with my Alfredo. Came with a piece of bread, the bread was saturated with butter. I took one bite I knew if I ate it, there was going to be trouble to my gut, it was that greasy. I ordered a sprite, but then really wanted to order to go with it, eventually, the waiter did come over and I requested a water. Can you not, when she brought the water? I was literally finished with my mail. They weren’t busy, and there seem to be adequate people working not sure what the problem was, but there are plenty of other restaurants on this road that I would patronize in the future. Try to give restaurants to tries, but when parking is bad, I drive a big truck, food really wasn’t that tasty, and the service really sucked. I really don’t see a reason to go back."

Roads Traveled Photography

What People Like

Delicious New York-style pizza
Fresh ingredients and tangy sauce
Friendly staff

What People Dislike

Inconsistent food quality on non-pizza items
Undercooked dough and food safety concerns
Potential service delays during peak times

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, leashed dogs are welcome on their covered outdoor patio.

Dog Friendly Activities in Kissimmee FLDog-Friendly Spots in Kissimmee You Need to Visit!

The New York-style pizzas are highly recommended. Popular appetizers include mozzarella sticks and garlic butter wings.

The Top 9 Pizza Shop Recommendations in KissimmeeGoogle Review+1

While pizza is generally well-received, some reviews mention issues with pasta, subs, and undercooked dough. It's advisable to focus on the pizza offerings.

Top 8 Gluten-Free American Spots to Enjoy in KissimmeeGoogle Review+1

The restaurant is located in a historic building that was formerly a Coca-Cola Bottling Company and a bicycle shop.

A Visitor’s Guide to Downtown KissimmeeA Local’s Guide to Historic Downtown Kissimmee

To avoid potential service delays, it's recommended to visit during off-peak hours.

Google Review

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

Element Vacation Homes

A Visitor’s Guide to Downtown Kissimmee

Get ready to indulge in Broadway Pizza Bar’s mouthwatering pizza and calzones, a local favorite that you simply can’t miss!. Did you know that this building used to be an old Coca-Cola Bottling Company and a local bicycle shop before the owner bought it in 2008?. Now, the interior has undergone a complete transformation, but you can still spot remnants of the past signage and catch a glimpse of historic Kissimmee photos while you wait for your steaming hot pizza to arrive.

Visit Source →
fantasyworldresort.com

Dog Friendly Activities in Kissimmee FL

Broadway Pizza Bar is a big favorite with their brick oven pizza, extensive wine list, friendly staff, and the fact that leashed dogs are allowed at tables on the covered porch, making it ideal, no matter the weather. Tabbouleh serves up authentic Mediterranean cuisine that is delicious and affordable. Whether you choose your own plate or go with a family meal platter, you’ll be well fed with items like kebabs, shawarma, lamb shank, and more.

Visit Source →
Experience Kissimmee

A Local’s Guide to Historic Downtown Kissimmee

As you walk down Broadway, you’ll pass by Broadway Pizza Bar, a local favorite serving up cheesy pizza and tasty calzones. This building was actually an old Coca-Cola Bottling Company, and then a local bicycle shop until the owner purchased it in 2008. While the interior has completely changed, you can clearly make out where the old signage used to be and see some historic photos of Kissimmee while you wait for your crispy crust to arrive.

Visit Source →
UNATION

Dog-Friendly Spots in Kissimmee You Need to Visit!

Located right in historic downtown Kissimmee, The Broadway Pizza Bar is a great place to hang out for lunch or dinner!. Of course, the New York Style pizza they offer is the favorite, but they also have salads, pastas, wings, and calzones on their menu. Take advantage of their outdoor patio seating, and your pooch will love sitting at your feet—but no promises that they won’t beg for a bite off your plate.

Visit Source →
Orlando Date Night Guide

7 Itineraries for Date Night in Kissimmee and St. Cloud

Head to Main Street for Broadway Pizza Bar, a pizza joint with a casual, vintage ambiance and a cozy feel. I suggest sharing some garlic knots and one of their specialty New York-style pizzas. Finally, wander down to Abracadabra Ice Cream Factory where your custom made ice cream creation is frozen with liquid nitrogen right in front of you!

Visit Source →
bellaromafl.com

The Top 9 Pizza Shop Recommendations in Kissimmee

When it comes to pizza places, New York has the eat-on-the-run slice down to a fine art. If you're in Kissimmee, Broadway Pizza Bar is the real deal—short of getting a plane to the Big Apple!. Aside from New York-style gourmet pizza, they also offer wraps, salads, wings, pasta, and New York-style cheesecake.

Visit Source →
iTrip®

Top Kissimmee Pizza Restaurants for Families Visiting Orlando

Broadway Pizza bar has operated a locally owned restaurant serving New York-style pizza since 2008. With an inviting ambiance and a beautiful patio, this Kissimmee pizza restaurant caters to any family.

Visit Source →
Atly

Top 8 Gluten-Free American Spots to Enjoy in Kissimmee

Expect a cozy vibe with live music, tasty pizza, and a pleasant atmosphere, though the outdoor seating is near a busy road.

Visit Source →
CitySurfing Orlando

Out and About: Limbhelados Serves Up Luscious Frozen Desserts in Downtown Kissimmee .. #Limbhelados #Limber #Kissimmee #EatLocal

Visit Source →