Thompson and Bleecker
A beloved Italian spot in Ithaca, famous for gourmet wood-fired pizzas and vibrant pasta dishes in a cozy, energetic atmosphere.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Thompson and Bleecker
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved Italian spot in Ithaca, famous for gourmet wood-fired pizzas and vibrant pasta dishes in a cozy, energetic atmosphere.
"This is the hottest restaurant in Ithaca right now, so it will be crowded and a little loud because people are really enjoying themselves."
Arrive Early or Late
They don't accept reservations, so arrive before opening or after 7 PM to avoid long waits.
Explore the Cocktail Menu
Don't miss their unique cocktails, with options like Hamptons Water and extra dirty martinis.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(607) 319-0851
Address
211 E Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Wood-Fired Pizzas
Savor gourmet wood-fired pizzas like the spicy Diavola or the popular Party Dude, known for their perfectly cooked thin crust.
Flavorful Pastas
Indulge in rich and creamy pasta dishes such as truffle alfredo and spicy vodka sauce, made with fresh ingredients.
Cozy & Vibrant Atmosphere
Experience a lively and charming atmosphere with decorative touches, perfect for dates or lively gatherings.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Arrive Early or Late
They don't accept reservations, so arrive before opening or after 7 PM to avoid long waits.
Explore the Cocktail Menu
Don't miss their unique cocktails, with options like Hamptons Water and extra dirty martinis.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
For a more intimate experience and to avoid high noise levels, consider visiting during non-busy times.
Try the Meatballs!
Meatballs are a highly recommended appetizer, described as heavenly and a must-order.
Tips
from all over the internet
Arrive Early or Late
They don't accept reservations, so arrive before opening or after 7 PM to avoid long waits.
Explore the Cocktail Menu
Don't miss their unique cocktails, with options like Hamptons Water and extra dirty martinis.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
For a more intimate experience and to avoid high noise levels, consider visiting during non-busy times.
Try the Meatballs!
Meatballs are a highly recommended appetizer, described as heavenly and a must-order.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Thompson and Bleecker is celebrated for its delicious wood-fired pizzas and flavorful pasta dishes, with the Diavola pizza and vodka pasta receiving high praise. The lively atmosphere and attentive service contribute to a positive dining experience. However, some reviews mention inconsistency in food quality, particularly with pasta being overcooked or certain dishes not meeting past standards after relocation.
"My favorite restaurant in Ithaca by far!! I had a first date here and now that’s my bf of one year, so it really does not disappoint;). So far have tried truffle pasta, alla vodka, and the meatballs are so heavenly (RUN don’t walk to order the meatballs if you haven’t tried them yet). Staff were so lovely and attentive, 10/10 service every time. The hot honey pizza is so delicious and one time my boyfriend and I ordered it with pepperoni by accident but they were so understanding of our mistake that they brought us a new vegetarian pizza<3. I need to come back to try everything on the menu and I would love to have my graduation dinner here if I could because it is just that awesome (and a fun and fancy yet laidback vibe inside). Thank you Thompson and Bleecker!!!!"
Serena Moscarella
"the straciatella is genuinely not what it used to be, and i’ve been twice to the new location feeling rather disappointed by this. while the cheese was once incredibly creamy and flavorful, the prosciutto a bright welcoming color, the two times i’ve gotten the ‘new’ straciatella the cheese and prosciutto both have been rather dry—not quite as fresh and milky like before! it feels worse knowing this used to be my favorite dish in all of ithaca, only for it to have disappointed me twice in a row now. the pasta sauce is very creamy and flavorful, but sometimes the pasta itself is overcooked with the noodles falling apart. the best pizza i've had here is definitely the diavola, though one time the bottom was a little too soggy for my liking. i'd say the food is generally tasty, and when it’s done right it is absolutely delicious, but quality control needs a little work as food isn't always consistent."
Fig Bar
"Had ordered a tiramisu. Awful taste, the ladyfingers were not soaked in espresso at all. The ladyfingers were totally dry. They used to be so good till last year. The pizza was not good as well. I think the taste has changed after moving to the new location."
Abhishek Kulkarni
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
No, Thompson and Bleecker does not accept reservations. It's recommended to arrive early or visit during off-peak hours.
The wood-fired pizzas (especially Diavola and Party Dude) and pasta dishes like Truffle Alfredo and Spicy Vodka are highly recommended.
The atmosphere is described as electric and lively, which can mean it's a bit loud when busy. For a quieter experience, try visiting during off-peak hours.
They offer well-crafted cocktails and a good selection of local and international beers.
Some reviews suggest that food quality can be inconsistent, with occasional issues like overcooked pasta or changes after relocating.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Ithaca Restaurants To Keep An Eye On | Ithaca
Thompson and Bleecker found a new home in the old Barr Building on East Seneca Street this summer. George Papachryssanthou, the owner and founder of Thompson and Bleecker, said that when the building went on sale, he and his wife Milly thought its unique character would be perfect for a restaurant. They jumped at the chance to become their own landlords and expand Thompson and Bleecker on their terms.
Welcome to Ithaca and its uniquely varied restaurant scene!
Ithaca has a plethora of pizza possibilities, with late-night staples like Casablanca, franchise offerings from Papa John’s with their $1 slices for Terrific Tuesday, gourmet toppings at Luna Inspired Street Food, fancy wood-fired pizzas from Agava, Ciao, or Thompson & Bleecker, and a few great classic pizzerias like Sal’s and Franco’s, where you’ll pay a bit more but it just might be worth it.
Best restaurants in Ithaca, according to Yelp
Top Review: “I recently visited Thompson & Bleeker in Ithaca, NY and had an excellent experience. I tried a few different pizzas and all of them were delicious, but the standout dish for me was the Penne alla vodka. The pasta was cooked perfectly and the sauce had just the right amount of cream and spice.
A College Kid’s Guide to Ithaca
Farther into the Commons, you’ll find Thompson and Bleecker, whose gourmet wood-fired pizza can’t be beat. I’m still drooling thinking about the hot honey and spicy tomato sauce. Coltivare is another great American/Italian option, but on the pricier side.
Top 17 birthday dinner in Downtown Ithaca
Cozy atmosphere with a large selection of local and international beers. Nestled in Ithaca, Thompson and Bleecker exudes charm and character. While the pasta leaned towards being overly soft, the pizza and salad delighted the taste buds.
Highest-rated Restaurants With Outdoor Seating in Ithaca, According to Yelp
- Rating: 4.5/5 (146 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 220 East State St Ithaca, NY 14850- Categories: Pizza, Wine Bars, Italian- Read more on Yelp. You may also like:Highest-rated ice cream shops in Ithaca, according to Yelp
The #1 Italian restaurant in Ithaca right now—and see the rest of the top 12, according to Yelp reviewers
- Rating: 4.5/5 (164 reviews) - Price level: $$ - Address: 220 East State St. Ithaca, New York - Categories: Pizza, Wine Bars, Italian - Read more on Yelp
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit