Lincoln Street Diner
A cozy, old-school diner serving up classic American comfort food favorites with friendly service and a charming small-town atmosphere. ^[^M5]
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Lincoln Street Diner
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A cozy, old-school diner serving up classic American comfort food favorites with friendly service and a charming small-town atmosphere. ^[^M5]
"This place is just very nice. The food is very good, prepared just behind the counter. ^"
Visit on Weekdays for Less Wait
To avoid crowds, try visiting on weekdays before 11 AM or all day Saturday for pancakes and French toast. ^[^M4]
Sit at the Counter
Opt for counter seating to watch the cooks in action and enjoy a more interactive dining experience. ^[^D1]
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American Diner
Price
$
Phone
(607) 216-1616
Address
309 E Lincoln St, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Charming Small-Town Diner Atmosphere
Experience a cozy, old-school diner with friendly staff and a welcoming vibe, offering a taste of simpler times. ^
Delicious American Comfort Food
Savor hearty breakfast and lunch classics like omelets and burgers, all made with fresh ingredients and served affordably. ^[^M2]
Unique Breakfast Specials
Don't miss out on Saturday's special Cajun Sausage Gravy over corn muffins or their renowned, fluffy pancakes. ^[^M1]
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Home fries
Pancakes
French Toast
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit on Weekdays for Less Wait
To avoid crowds, try visiting on weekdays before 11 AM or all day Saturday for pancakes and French toast. ^[^M4]
Sit at the Counter
Opt for counter seating to watch the cooks in action and enjoy a more interactive dining experience. ^[^D1]
Saturday is Breakfast Only
Enjoy breakfast items all day on Saturdays, but be aware that weekday lunch hours have limited griddle items. ^[^M1]
Cash Preferred
While electronic payments are accepted, the diner prefers cash if you have it readily available. ^
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit on Weekdays for Less Wait
To avoid crowds, try visiting on weekdays before 11 AM or all day Saturday for pancakes and French toast. ^[^M4]
Sit at the Counter
Opt for counter seating to watch the cooks in action and enjoy a more interactive dining experience. ^[^D1]
Saturday is Breakfast Only
Enjoy breakfast items all day on Saturdays, but be aware that weekday lunch hours have limited griddle items. ^[^M1]
Cash Preferred
While electronic payments are accepted, the diner prefers cash if you have it readily available. ^
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Lincoln Street Diner is a beloved, old-school spot praised for its delicious, comforting American fare and friendly, small-town vibe. Diners rave about the fluffy pancakes, hearty omelets, and unique sausage gravy specials, though some note that it can get crowded and the lunch menu is more limited. Overall, it's a highly recommended, reasonably priced destination for a satisfying breakfast or lunch. ^
"Perfect if you are looking for an old-school diner. Counter and table seating with food hot off the plancha grill. Fried eggs are delicious as is the egg sandwich and the pancakes. Gets very crowded on weekends so go before 10. Fair prices and good conversation. Takes electronic payments but prefers cash if you have it."
Jillian Caci
"Homey, no-nonsense place half a block away from Ithaca Falls. My partner wanted to fuel before a long bike ride so we got the pancakes and eggs with hash. The pancakes were wonderful! Thanks so much for the satisfying meal."
LL C
"A quirky neighborhood spot where the regulars all know each other, the breakfasts and burgers are great, and daily homestyle specials range from very good to amazing. Fish fry on Fridays, chili dogs most Thursdays, fresh roast turkey dinners frequently, creative chicken salad, etc.
Breakfast is limited for weekday lunch hours; no griddle items. Saturday is breakfast items only. You may have to wait for a table. It’s worth it."
Mark H. Anbinder
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Diners highly recommend the fluffy pancakes, the Ziffy Omelette, and the Cajun sausage gravy over home fries or corn muffins. French toast is also a standout. ^[^M3]
Weekdays before 11 AM are less crowded. Saturdays offer breakfast all day. Weekends can be very busy, so arriving early is advised. ^[^M4]
On weekdays, griddle items like pancakes and French toast are not served during lunch hours. Breakfast is served all day on Saturdays. ^[^M1]
It's a cozy, humble, old-school diner with a charming, small-town atmosphere and friendly staff. ^
The diner offers omelets that can be made with vegetables, but specific vegan options are not detailed in the provided information.
Yes, it's a small place, and you may have to wait for a table during busy times. Sitting at the counter is also an option. ^
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Welcome to Ithaca! A dining guide for new and longtime residents of Tompkins County
The Lincoln Street Diner in Fall Creek is a classic diner, nothing fancy but good hearty breakfasts including omelets anytime they’re open, and pancakes and french toast before 11 weekdays or all day Saturday. Cajun sausage gravy is available Saturday, and it’s great on the “daily breakfast special,” home fries and corn bread topped with sausage gravy. There’s an ever-changing variety of muffins and coffee cake to get your morning started, along with the ever-present diner coffee.
Best of 13 diners in Ithaca
A classic American diner with a focus on local and organic ingredients. Located in the heart of a charming small town, Lincoln Street Diner is a hidden gem that serves up delicious and affordable breakfast and lunch options. The Philadelphia omelet paired with homemade potatoes and toast is a standout dish, while the mini apple crumble tart offers the perfect sweet ending to your meal.
Breakfast & Brunch in Ithaca, NY
Call your friends to meet up at an old-school diner offering American comfort food favorites. This hometown restaurant takes pride in customer service and its food. Local Pick: Give the Ziffy Omelet (ham, bacon, onions, peppers, cheese, and home fries) a try when you stop in for a morning snack and coffee.
Best breakfast spots?! : ithaca
I'm going to highly recommend Lincoln Street Diner again - yes, it is a fall creek, cheap diner, but it's solid food every time and exactly what I want from a diner breakfast. Other diners in the area are at least 2x as expensive and doesn't have the hole in the wall energy that I love
where to eat in Ithaca, NY
However, if what you’re after is a regular good old fashioned greasy-spoon diner experience, visit the Lincoln Street Diner or the Ithaca classic State Street Diner.
Highest-rated Restaurants in Ithaca by Diners
- Rating: 4.1/5 (151 reviews)- Price level: $- Address: 309 East Lincoln St. Ithaca, New York - Categories: Diners, Breakfast & Brunch- Read more on Yelp
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit