
Casablanca Pizzeria
A lively pizzeria offering both classic pizza and diverse Mediterranean flavors, known for its late-night hours and friendly owner.

Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Casablanca Pizzeria

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A lively pizzeria offering both classic pizza and diverse Mediterranean flavors, known for its late-night hours and friendly owner.
"This halal pizzeria is a must-try for its amazing calzones and Mediterranean specialties!"
Explore Beyond Pizza
Try Mediterranean dishes like Shawarma and calzones for a more authentic experience.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long wait times by visiting when it's less crowded.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza, Mediterranean
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(607) 272-7777
Address
111 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Perfectly Balanced Pepperoni Calzone
A harmonious blend of meat, cheese, and bread that's utterly craveable and satisfying.

Unique Mediterranean Flavors
Explore beyond pizza with flavorful Lamb Shawarma and delicious, sweet baklava.

Late-Night Dining Destination
Catering to nocturnal schedules, this spot offers delicious food when you need it most.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Explore Beyond Pizza
Try Mediterranean dishes like Shawarma and calzones for a more authentic experience.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long wait times by visiting when it's less crowded.
Halal Options Clearly Marked
Appreciate the clear labeling of halal options on the menu.
Tips
from all over the internet
Explore Beyond Pizza
Try Mediterranean dishes like Shawarma and calzones for a more authentic experience.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long wait times by visiting when it's less crowded.
Halal Options Clearly Marked
Appreciate the clear labeling of halal options on the menu.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Casablanca Pizzeria offers a mix of satisfying pizza and Mediterranean dishes, with friendly service often highlighted by a kind owner. While some reviews praise the delicious calzones and shawarma, others note an average pizza experience and occasional issues with service or food handling. The late-night hours are a definite plus for those on nocturnal schedules.
"The gentleman with grey hair is beyond helpful and kind. He always greets everyone with a smile and seems to remember everyone's order. It is a great place to get good food. And he is especially amazing."
Shana King
"Disappointing Experience
I recently visited with high hopes of enjoying an authentic Jamaican patty, but unfortunately, my experience was a letdown. The moment I walked in, I noticed a swarm of flies buzzing around the food, which was a major red flag.
I ordered the patty, but it failed to impress. The dough was excessively thick and overpowered the filling, making it difficult to enjoy. To make matters worse, the flavor and texture were far from the authentic Jamaican patty I'm familiar with.
The price was also steep, considering the subpar quality. Overall, I was disappointed and wouldn't recommend to anyone seeking a genuine Jamaican patty experience.
Rating: 1/5 stars
Recommendation: Improve food handling and preparation to ensure a clean and authentic dining experience. Revise the recipe to achieve a more traditional Jamaican patty taste and texture."
jayce green
"Verdict:
Amazing halal pizzeria in Ithaca! Highly recommend!! Loved that halal is very clearly stated in the menu too
Food:
I got a pepperoni calzone and it was absolutely amazing. Perfectly balanced between the meat, cheese, and bread. It hit the spot. I’m actually craving it right now just writing this review 🤤
Service:
The owner is a very friendly Moroccan guy. The place was packed on a Thursday night and he told everyone up front it was going to be a little longer getting the food. Thankfully it was worth the wait. The inside of the restaurant is a dated diner vibe.
Price:
Price was very fair. It’s near Cornell so it’s definitely in a college students budget."
Mohammed Waqar
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The pepperoni calzone is highly recommended for its perfect balance, and the Lamb Shawarma and baklava offer unique Mediterranean flavors.
Yes, Casablanca Pizzeria clearly states halal options on their menu, making it easy for diners to choose.
Yes, they offer late-night dining hours, which is convenient for those with nocturnal schedules.
The interior has a dated diner vibe, but the atmosphere is generally described as friendly.
The restaurant offers delivery and pickup services.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Welcome to Ithaca and its uniquely varied restaurant scene!
Ithaca has a plethora of pizza possibilities, with late-night staples like Casablanca, franchise offerings from Papa John’s with their $1 slices for Terrific Tuesday, gourmet toppings at Luna Inspired Street Food, fancy wood-fired pizzas from Agava, Ciao, or Thompson & Bleecker, and a few great classic pizzerias like Sal’s and Franco’s, where you’ll pay a bit more but it just might be worth it.
Top 16 buffalo wings in Ithaca
Buffalo wings at this establishment are a must-try due to their delicious flavor and expert cooking. The tangy sauce and juicy wings were enjoyed by a group of friends, making for a satisfying and tasty experience. High-quality buffalo wings are served here, with a tangy sauce coating juicy and perfectly cooked chicken.
Highest-ranked Pizza Restaurants in Ithaca by Diners
- Rating: 3.1/5 (70 reviews)- Price level: $- Address: 111A East State St. Ithaca, New York - Categories: mediterranean, pizza- Read more on Yelp
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit