Harry & Izzy's
An upscale steakhouse sister to the legendary St. Elmo, Harry & Izzy's offers a modern spin on classic chops, seafood, and pizza in a vibrant atmosphe...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Harry & Izzy's
Highlights
Must-see attractions
An upscale steakhouse sister to the legendary St. Elmo, Harry & Izzy's offers a modern spin on classic chops, seafood, and pizza in a vibrant atmosphere.
"Experience a fantastic steakhouse with delicious food, incredible service, and a vibe you'll brag about!"
Request Lower Level Seating
For a more intimate dining experience, ask for a table downstairs.
Try Unique Whiskeys
Explore unique offerings like the St Elmo cherry vanilla whiskey and a selection of bourbons.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American Steakhouse
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
World Famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail
Experience the legendary shrimp cocktail with a powerful horseradish kick – a must-try appetizer.
Perfectly Cooked Steaks
Savor tender filet steak and other expertly cooked cuts, prepared to perfection.
Bourbon Bread Pudding
Indulge in a decadent bread pudding, generously topped and infused with Woodford Reserve.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Request Lower Level Seating
For a more intimate dining experience, ask for a table downstairs.
Try Unique Whiskeys
Explore unique offerings like the St Elmo cherry vanilla whiskey and a selection of bourbons.
Make Reservations
To ensure a table, especially during busy periods, book your reservation in advance.
Be Ready for Horseradish
The shrimp cocktail's sauce packs a serious punch with real horseradish – a true flavor explosion.
Tips
from all over the internet
Request Lower Level Seating
For a more intimate dining experience, ask for a table downstairs.
Try Unique Whiskeys
Explore unique offerings like the St Elmo cherry vanilla whiskey and a selection of bourbons.
Make Reservations
To ensure a table, especially during busy periods, book your reservation in advance.
Be Ready for Horseradish
The shrimp cocktail's sauce packs a serious punch with real horseradish – a true flavor explosion.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Harry & Izzy's offers a fantastic steakhouse experience with attentive service and generous portions. Diners rave about signature dishes like the shrimp cocktail and bread pudding, praising the perfectly cooked steaks and the overall deliciousness of the food. While some note that the shrimp cocktail is pricey and the onion rings were more like straws, the overwhelming sentiment is positive, highlighting a fun and relaxing atmosphere suitable for casual or business dining.
"One of my favorite spots in Indy, partly owned by Peyton Manning with the same quality food as its next door neighbor St. Elmo’s Steakhouse with the same owners, this high end restaurant is a better value and less snooty atmosphere. I’ve seen people in suits and even people in shorts. They are known for their shrimp cocktail sauce with “Grade A horseradish” (apparently there is a grading, which our waiter explained, so ask them!). Also their bred pudding dessert is a must order, combining three of my favorite things: ice cream, whipped cream and Woodford Reserve 🥃! The waiter said it could serve 4 but the four of us struggled to finish it. Highly recommend both of those things.
One of my colleagues has a variety of allergies and the manager thoughtfully came out to explain how they handle food allergies. We thought that was a nice touch.
Great spot for business dinners!"
Good Capitalist
"While at the convention center for a large conference that we were working at, a few of us came to St Elmo’s right at 4, when it opened to grab a spot at the bar and try their “famous” shrimp, but the line was ridiculously long outside, so we came here, to Harry & Izzy’s instead, since it’s the same chain. Walking in, we quickly found a couple of seats at the bar and upon being greeted by the bartender, I asked her what she likes to make and he response was “draft beer.” To which I said no bartender should say that, especially in a nicer place like this with all the spirits they have. She then said wine too. This just told me she wasn’t a very good bartender, rather an order taker who just pumps out orders with no focus on customer service nor providing a good experience.
Service was very mixed the entire time we were there. While there, we also tried their famous shrimp, ordering 6 pieces. At the same time we ordered that, we asked for the fried ravioli and also the bacon. The ravioli and two orders of the bacon came out soon after and when we said we only ordered one order of bacon, she said “oh yeah” and asked if we wanted this second order and when we said not if we had to pay for it, she took it – Another poor service and training example from her… What’s she going to do with it once it was sat in front of us? Hopefully not serve it to someone else!
The bacon tasted great! The shrimp was over done being covered in that cocktail sauce. The flavor of the sauce was decent, but not stronger/spicier than Eddie V’s atomic horseradish in their cocktail sauce. Drinks during our visit were ok, but nothing special.
Overall, based on this experience and what we heard from others about this place and St Elmo’s, this chain seems to have rested on their laurels and long history and does little to continue providing great service and experience."
F'burg Foodie
"The buffalo solider cocktail was an easy drinker that wasn't overpowering on the bourbon. We got the shrimp cocktail to start which was great but expensive for 4 shrimp. It packed quite the punch with the amount of horseradish. The fried chicken slider was basic but what I expected. The French onion soup was well balanced and one of the best I've had. The star of the show was the lobster sacchetti which was split between 2 people. The sauce was nice and creamy with just the right amount of lobster flavor. It was all very filling so we skipped dessert.
It was a pretty casual atmosphere with most people in sports gear of shorts and t shirts at 5:00 on a Saturday."
Megan G
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Harry & Izzy's is most famous for its World Famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail with a strong horseradish kick, perfectly cooked steaks, and decadent bread pudding.
Yes, Harry & Izzy's is the sister restaurant to St. Elmo Steak House, sharing similar quality and menu items but offering a slightly more casual and modern atmosphere.
It is recommended to make reservations, especially during peak times, to ensure you can secure a table.
Some diners suggest requesting seating downstairs for a more intimate experience.
The Bourbon Bread Pudding, often infused with Woodford Reserve and topped with ice cream, is a highly recommended dessert.
Yes, the restaurant offers unique drink options such as the St Elmo cherry vanilla whiskey and a selection of bourbons.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Must-Try Restaurants In Indianapolis Indiana
Harry & Izzy’s‘ menus might vary, but the astronomical portions and the intense flavors of the house specials stay the same thorough its three local venues. The World Famous St Elmo Shrimp Cocktail and Izzy Style New York Strip are still absolute favourites. Sliders are also offered, but in a way befitting the stylish polished interior of the three locations, and the brasserie-style settings.
Indianapolis Steakhouses
Here, we have the classic cuts courtesy of its buttoned-down 115-year-old next-door sibling refashioned as a craps game with Nathan Detroit from Guys and Dolls—a nod to the yin and yang of former St. Elmo partners Harry Roth, the bespectacled, and Izzy Rosen, the bookmaker. But in the same way breakfast-for-dinner rebranded waffles, slicing into what is basically a St. Elmo steak inside Harry & Izzy’s just feels different. That’s a big part of the showy magic here, a restaurant with a vibe all its own that just happens to have a St. Elmo franchise inside.
27 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis in
Harry Roth and Izzy Rosen met as children and remained friends as Issy worked at City Market selling grocery items while Harry attended Monroe College of Optometry. The two ultimately became partners in another restaurant and became known in the community as “the Odd Couple.” Harry & Izzy’s is a more casual eatery celebrating the legendary partnership of the two men. If visiting for lunch, try the Izzy New York Strip, rolled in cracked pepper, pan-seared, then topped with an orange brandy butter sauce.
Wine in Indianapolis?
Back out onto Illinois, continuing south, you'll find Oceanaire - excellent seafood, The Restaurant at the Canterbury - just got a make-over and a new chef, St Elmo's - Indy's oldest restaurant with the infamous shrimp cocktail, good steak and a very nice wine list, and then Harry and Izzy - St Elmos' sister restaurant - a bit more casual, gorgeous bar and the same food basically. Directly across the street is Mikado - sushi. There's also a couple of brewery type places you'll pass on the walk.
20 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana
If you are looking for an upscale American grill with three distinct locations in the Indianapolis area, then you should try Harry & Izzy’s. Whether you are looking to plan a small gathering or even host a private meal for friends, family, or coworkers, you can trust that the staff at Harry & Izzy’s will accommodate your party for up to 100 guests. The private dining experience also comes with various menu options to choose from to ensure that all of your guests are satisfied with their meals.
Best Restaurants in Indianapolis
Harry & Izzy’s is a sleek, upscale spot that brings the same high standards as its sister restaurant, St. Elmo Steak House, but in a slightly more modern setting. Located downtown just steps from Monument Circle, it’s one of my go-to picks when I want that classic steakhouse experience without quite as much formality. The menu features beautifully prepared steaks, fresh seafood, and of course, the iconic St. Elmo shrimp cocktail that brings the heat.
Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana
This is another terrific American restaurant to eat at while you're in Indianapolis. Based in 153 Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, Harry & Izzy's is a upscale steakhouse with a notable wine selection & a contemporary spin on chops, seafood & pizza and lets you enjoy flavors and meals you'll only be able to get in Indianapolis. Give us a call at 317-635-9594 and book a reservation at Harry & Izzy's!
Indianapolis Steakhouses: 10Best Steakhouse Reviews
Although it shares some traits with its sister restaurant, St. Elmo Steak House, Harry & Izzy's is an experience all its own. This swanky establishment serves up a selection of chops that's sure to please even the most discerning steak enthusiasts. The 14-ounce Izzy Style NY Strip, which is rolled in cracked peppercorn, pan-seared and served with an orange brandy butter sauce, is a particular favorite.
Best American restaurants in Indianapolis [2024]
Address: 153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225Phone:+1 (317) 635-9594Website:harryandizzys.comDetails: $$$, American restaurant. Harry and Izzy’s is a remarkable restaurant in Indianapolis, offering a welcoming atmosphere, exceptional staff, and a mouthwatering menu. The restaurant’s chic decor and bustling ambiance create the perfect setting for an enjoyable dining experience.
Where to eat and menu suggestions
Can’t wait for dinner for a St. Elmo steak or shrimp cocktail?. Hit up sister restaurant Harry & Izzy’s, which is also open for lunch, for steaks and seafood. The restaurant’s Devour Indy special is offered every day — a $35 three-course lunch guests create from options like a three-piece shrimp cocktail; filet, fried chicken, or fried shrimp sliders and crème brûlée.
Best Steakhouses in Indianapolis (IN), Prime Steakhouse Indianapolis, Steak Restaurants Indianapolis
Lifelong friends Harry Roth and Izzy Rosen -- who established the famed St. Elmo Steak House -- are honored at this modern American steakhouse that bears their name and resemblance. The atmosphere here is more casual than St. Elmo Steak House, and in addition to this downtown location, there are outposts on the north side and in the airport.
Harry & Izzy's is an independent, upscale American Grill located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis. Its ambience exudes class and sophistication in a comfortable setting. While the lively bar is Harry & Izzy's focal point, unique dining rooms incorporate dark woods, lush fabrics and a deep color palette.
Best gluten-free restaurants in Indianapolis in 2025
The best option for gluten free food in Downtown, Indianapolis is Harry & Izzy without a doubt. This restaurant offers multiple options and has an exclusive gluten-free menu in Indianapolis , at each of its locations. There you will find one of the most delicious appetizers: the San Telmo shrimp cocktail.
15 Best Restaurants In Indianapolis IN You Must Try
This is the more casual sister version to its more exclusive counterpart. There are three locations to choose from but many agree the downtown version has the best atmosphere. This place celebrates Harry and Izzy the founders of the famous steak house with a much more accessible and casual atmosphere.
The 50 Best Gluten-Free American Restaurants in Indianapolis
As someone with celiac disease (gluten intolerance), it is always a challenge for me to find a restaurant where I can eat without worries. I was completely thrilled at Harry & Izzy’s. As soon as I entered I was warmly welcomed and immediately offered a separate gluten-free menu - a big plus!
11 Great Dairy-Free and Gluten-Free Restaurants in Indianapolis
Harry and Izzy’s (or their parent company next door, St. Elmo’s) is a must for any out-of-town visitors. Athletes and celebrities often stop in to either restaurant when visiting Indianapolis. Located downtown in Circle Center Mall, Harry and Izzy’s offers high-end American cuisine.
Best Indianapolis restaurants according to TripAdvisor
– Rating: 4.5 / 5 (1,887 reviews)– Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.5/5)– Type of cuisine: American, Steakhouse– Price: $$$$– Address: 153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225-1079– Read more on Tripadvisor. 18 / 30// Tripadvisor
Best Places In Indianapolis To Host Your Rehearsal Dinner
If you’re looking for a place with variety, Harry & Izzy’s is the spot to go!. It is a gorgeous steakhouse with tons of choices in spaces for events. Their menu also ranges from many different things, so if you’re not a steak person, you still have lots of choices!
Highest-rated Restaurants in Indianapolis, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4.5 / 5 (1,908 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.5/5)- Type of cuisine: American, Steakhouse- Price: $$$$- Address: 153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225-1079- Read more on Tripadvisor
50 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, IN for 2025 (Top Eats!)
153 S Illinois StIndianapolis, IN 46225(317) 635-9594 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Inside Circle Centre Mall, Harry & Izzy’s is an elegant steakhouse with an extensive wine list and a modern take on chops, seafood, and pizza.
Directory | Circle Centre Mall
Located in Downtown Indianapolis, Harry & Izzy’s is an upscale American Grill, sibling to the renowned St. Elmo Steak House, offering classic dishes such as the world-famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail®, steaks, chops, and fresh seafood.
Indy Bites: What Food Is Indianapolis Known For?
Those other restaurants include Harry & Izzy’s (an upscale American Grill) and 1933 Lounge. Just down the street from St. Elmo’s is the first Harry & Izzy’s. There is also a Harry & Izzy’s location in Northeast Indianapolis.
The Best Places to Eat in Indianapolis for Any Occasion
From perfectly-seasoned French fries to the best steak you’ll ever have, their menu has a wide variety of food options. Top it off with a fancy glass of wine, with over 100 stunning selections to choose from.
Top 25 restaurants in Indianapolis to visit while there for the NCAA Tournament
Harry and Izzy’s: Located at 153 South Illinois Street, this steakhouse also serves a variety of pizzas and seafood entrees. You can also try one of hundreds of bottles of wines from all over the world.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit