Brozinni Pizzeria
Brozinni Pizzeria brings the taste of authentic New York-style pizza to Indianapolis with massive, foldable slices and flavorful appetizers.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Brozinni Pizzeria
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Brozinni Pizzeria brings the taste of authentic New York-style pizza to Indianapolis with massive, foldable slices and flavorful appetizers.
"This is the best pizza in Indy by a long shot, with primo ingredients and perfect crust."
Try the Garlic Knuckles
Drenched in garlic butter and parmesan, these doughy appetizers are a highly recommended starter.
Fold Your Slice
For an authentic New York experience, remember to fold your large, thin-crust slice lengthwise.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza
Price
$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic New York-Style Pizza
Enjoy massive, foldable slices with generous toppings, capturing the true essence of NYC pizza.
Addictive Garlic Knuckles
These doughy bites, drenched in garlic butter and parmesan, are a must-try appetizer that's dangerously delicious.
Generous Portion Sizes
From oversized slices to massive calzones and salads, expect more than enough food for a hearty meal.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Garlic Knuckles
Drenched in garlic butter and parmesan, these doughy appetizers are a highly recommended starter.
Fold Your Slice
For an authentic New York experience, remember to fold your large, thin-crust slice lengthwise.
Lunchtime Slices
Available weekdays from 11 am to 4 pm, enjoy a huge, oversized slice like a true New Yorker.
Grandma's Pie
Consider trying the Sicilian-style Grandma's Pie for a delicious alternative pizza experience.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Garlic Knuckles
Drenched in garlic butter and parmesan, these doughy appetizers are a highly recommended starter.
Fold Your Slice
For an authentic New York experience, remember to fold your large, thin-crust slice lengthwise.
Lunchtime Slices
Available weekdays from 11 am to 4 pm, enjoy a huge, oversized slice like a true New Yorker.
Grandma's Pie
Consider trying the Sicilian-style Grandma's Pie for a delicious alternative pizza experience.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Brozinni Pizzeria is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, with massive, foldable slices and generous toppings that impress. Diners rave about the unique Garlic Knuckles appetizer and appreciate the large portion sizes for both pizzas and salads. While the pizza quality is highly praised, some find the crust-to-topping ratio slightly off or miss the exact New York authenticity, and occasionally service can feel rushed.
"Love their pizza. Hadn't been there in a few years, lots of changes to the place, still great pizza,cheesy, nice pull fresh out the oven, could of used a bit more sauce but the grease and the flavors made up for it. We ordered the small, that was 8 slices,more than enough( leftovers for lunch the next day). We also had the cannolis as a treat,very good (wish they had been bigger ). Don't take my word for it. Check them out .Awesome family place or by yourself. Definitely be back ."
A Vlz
"My first time here. I ordered the Bronx Calzone. It was pretty good, filled with toppings. It was served cut open as seen in the picture.. Only thing I didn't like was I felt rushed to hurry and eat by the server even though the Restaurant was not even half full. I might stop again if I was in the area."
The Traveling Man
"Ok, I am usually very on the fence about giving the good reviews and leaving the not so good aside.
Felt it worth my opinion here and stated with my experience, nothing more.
Being from NY I wanted to visit Brozinni for a while and finally made it. Very nice location and seated immediately even on a Friday night. The menu cute with all the NY references so off we went. Our service was amazing.
The garlic knuckles were wonderful and for those used to just baked in, these drip with a flavorful base that garlic lovers will love.Highly recommend.
The antipasto salad was entree sized and tasteful when added with homemade ranch and Italian dressing.
The three meatball appetizer I was hoping would pull through but very disappointed as they were tender yet without much flavor.
Our pizza was well presented and fresh. We made one change to the Park Avenue, swapping out spicy sausage for the sausage listed. The crust was not bad as close to a NY style but not exactly there. From there it was interesting. Perhaps I missed if sauce was to be on this pie but if so, non existent. I appreciate a bit of oil on a pie but this was a bit overpowering. It tasted more oil from toppings than anything below including cheese.
With that said, please do not let me discourage you from visiting. We will I imagine try again and just order a create your own pie on a smaller scale or pop in when commitment is a slice.
Was hoping to find a bit of home in the advertised NY pie. To me, missed the mark on many levels."
Mark Rumney
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Brozinni's offers large, thin-crust pizzas that are meant to be folded lengthwise, just like in New York City. They use generous toppings and bake their pies to perfection.
The Garlic Knuckles are a standout appetizer, featuring doughy bites drenched in garlic butter and parmesan cheese. They are frequently highlighted as a delicious must-try.
Yes, you can order oversized slices weekdays from 11 am to 4 pm, which is a great way to try different flavors.
While not explicitly stated in the provided data, it's best to contact the restaurant directly to inquire about gluten-free accommodations.
Portion sizes are very generous. Pizzas are large, slices are huge, and even salads are substantial, often providing leftovers.
Yes, Brozinni Pizzeria is described as a family-friendly place, suitable for families and friends to gather.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The 25 Essential Eats Of Indy
Whether they be sticks, knots, or bread, all carb-based appetizers pale in comparison to the garlic knuckles featured at this always-packed pizzeria on Indy’s south side with a recently opened Speedway location. The fermented housemade dough proofed for the knuckles is the same Brozinni’s uses for its New York–style pies (with slices you can actually fold like a real New Yorker) and makes for garlic butter–drenched bites that are crisp, chewy, and dangerously addictive. You’ll definitely need to make yourself hold back for pizza—and when was the last time you had to be told that?
18 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis
Established in 2008, the Brozinni Pizzeria offers delicious Italian dine-in and takeout options. The menu features some of the most delicious appetizers such as garlic knuckles made with fresh homemade dough and drizzled in garlic butter and parmesan cheese, pepperoni breadsticks, fried ravioli, and fried mushrooms served with homemade ranch or marinara. The restaurant is a great, friendly place for families and friends to get together and enjoy calzones, sandwiches, pizza, and pasta.
Food in Indianapolis – Experience the Crossroads of America
Be sure to stop by Brozinni Pizzeria, a family-friendly pizza place in the Southside area of Indianapolis. Try the Park Avenue, featuring peperoni, sausage, bacon and ham; or the Broadway, loaded with all the veggies. From 11 to 4 through the week, you can buy an oversize slice a la carte like at most New York pizzerias (but why would you want to stop at just one slice?).
National Pizza Day: The Search for New York Pizza in Indianapolis
Brozinni Pizzeria– I credit my teenage daughter for finding this gem of a pizzeria hidden in the back streets of Nashville, Indiana. She visited there on a camp trip and came home promising they had true New York pizza. I am always a bit apprehensive when a menu claims “a taste of New York,” but this pizza lived up to its promise.
Best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis [2024]
Address: 8810 S Emerson Ave # 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237Phone:+1 (317) 865-0911Website:brozinni.comDetails: $$, Pizza restaurant. Discover the taste of authentic New York-style pizza at Brozinni Pizzeria in Indianapolis. This restaurant has garnered praise for its incredible pizza, flavorful appetizers, and friendly staff.
Authentic New York Style Pizza in Indianapolis
Brozinni Pizzeria, located in Indianapolis, is a haven for pizza lovers seeking authentic Italian flavors. From their delectable Garlic Knuckles to their mouth-watering calzones, every dish is crafted with care and passion. The extensive menu also features a variety of salads and appetizers, catering to all tastes.
The Best Pizza in Indianapolis
Many people recommended that I try Brozinni’s Pizzeria, claiming it’s the best you’ll find in the Hoosier state. While I’m not sure that’s the case, it was a very solid pizza and the portion sizes are HUGE. I ate on it for days and there was something slightly different about their pepperoni that I really enjoyed.
The 20 Pizza Places In Indiana You Have To Try At Least Once
This New York style pizzeria offers huge, thin crust pies in a variety of styles, including build your own options. At lunchtime, you can also order pizza by the slice, which is a great way to try a bunch of different flavors. Find the on the south side at 8810 S Emerson Ave, Ste 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237.
6 Places to Find the Biggest Pizzas in Indiana
Brozinni offers two locations, one in Indy and one in Nashville. Here you can feast on New-York style 20-inch pizzas cut into those giant traditional New York thin-crust slices we have all come to love. Don’t forget: the proper way to enjoy pizza like a New Yorker is to fold it in half lengthwise.
Best Indianapolis restaurants according to TripAdvisor
– Rating: 4.5 / 5 (176 reviews)– Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.0/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.0/5)– Type of cuisine: Italian, Pizza– Price: $$ – $$$– Address: 8810 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237-8581– Read more on Tripadvisor. 5 / 30// Tripadvisor
Highest-rated Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4.5 / 5 (176 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.0/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.0/5)- Type of cuisine: Italian, Pizza- Price: $$ - $$$- Address: 8810 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237-8581- Read more on Tripadvisor
50 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, IN for 2025 (Top Eats!)
8810 S Emerson Ave # 240Indianapolis, IN 46237(317) 865-0911 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Brozinni Pizzeria, which opened in 2008, is a family-friendly pizza joint with the Big Apple’s trademark crust and a short menu of Italian fare.
15 places to get your pizza fix in Indianapolis
Brozinni takes its identity as a New York-style joint seriously, with every pizza named after a location in the Big Apple. If you’re looking to dial up your NYC experience even further, add one of its amazing calzones or cannoli to your order.
19 Best Pizza Places in Indianapolis, IN
8810 S Emerson Ave # 240, Indianapolis, IN 46237Phone: (317) 865-0911 Visit Website. A post shared by Brozinni Pizzeria (@brozinnipizzeria). Brozinni Pizzeria prides itself on bringing a rich taste of New York to central Indiana.
Best New York Style Pizza In Indianapolis
Brozinni Pizzeria is an Indianapolis family-friendly pizza place. Get a taste of New York right here in Indianapolis, featuring the Big Apple’s signature crust, our famous buttery garlic knuckles and a great menu of Italian eats.
Where to find the highest-rated pizza places in Indianapolis - Indianapolis News | Indiana Weather | Indiana Traffic
– Rating: 4.3/5 (451 reviews)– Price level: $$– Address: 8810 South Emerson Ave. Ste 240 Indianapolis, Indiana – Categories: pizza, salad, italian– Read more on Yelp
Eight restaurants left in IndyStar bracket
The other two matches will be top-seed slugfests, with Brozinni Pizzeria taking on King Dough and Jockamo Upper Crust versus Bazbeaux.
Who Has The Best Pizza on the South Side of Indianapolis?
After 9 years of living in Franklin Township, I have finally found my “go to.” That pizza place is Brozinni Pizzeria
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit