Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Green Bay
This casual pizza chain offers unique, creative pies alongside classic pastas, wings, and seafood, with a focus on accommodating service and generous ...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Green Bay
Highlights
Must-see attractions
This casual pizza chain offers unique, creative pies alongside classic pastas, wings, and seafood, with a focus on accommodating service and generous portions.
"The best pizza I’ve ever had, even beating out New York and Italy!"
Try the Churro Cheesecake
Don't miss out on the amazing cinnamon churro cheesecake for a delightful dessert experience.
Patio Dining Option
Consider sitting on the patio for a pleasant and enjoyable dining experience.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(920) 490-1000
Address
416 Dousman St, Green Bay, WI 54303, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Unique & Delicious Pizzas
Creative pizza interpretations with perfect cheese, sauce, and crust that even skeptical New Yorkers rave about.
Exceptional Service
Staff like Madison are praised for being accommodating and friendly, making diners feel welcomed.
Generous Portions & Great Value
Enjoy substantial 'pick 4' salads and well-priced daily specials that offer excellent value.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Churro Cheesecake
Don't miss out on the amazing cinnamon churro cheesecake for a delightful dessert experience.
Patio Dining Option
Consider sitting on the patio for a pleasant and enjoyable dining experience.
Explore Creative Pizzas
Embrace unique flavor interpretations of popular pizza styles for a truly delicious meal.
Check Daily Specials
Take advantage of daily specials for well-priced and satisfying meal deals.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Churro Cheesecake
Don't miss out on the amazing cinnamon churro cheesecake for a delightful dessert experience.
Patio Dining Option
Consider sitting on the patio for a pleasant and enjoyable dining experience.
Explore Creative Pizzas
Embrace unique flavor interpretations of popular pizza styles for a truly delicious meal.
Check Daily Specials
Take advantage of daily specials for well-priced and satisfying meal deals.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners consistently praise Glass Nickel Pizza Co. for its creative and delicious pizzas, highlighting the perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and crust. The exceptional service, with staff going above and beyond, is another frequent positive mention. However, some customers have experienced significant wait times for food and, in rare instances, issues with food quality or delivery.
"Some of their pizzas are interpretations of popular flavors so it might not be what you expect but it’s still delicious nonetheless!
I love getting pizza from here - their sauce, crust, quality, and overall flavor is usually quite consistent and satisfying.
Great service and restaurant was clean."
Amaya
"The details:
I walked 6 miles with my Boxer service dog before arriving here. I was greeted in an appropriate manner in a reasonable amount of time. I inquired as I have in the past if we could sit on the patio and get service outside. The bartender/server/order taker/hostess (Madison) was very pleasant and gladly accommodated us on the patio.
I ordered beer for me and water for the dog. The beer was served cold immediately and a pitcher of water along with disposable bowl for the dog was brought to my table.
I was thrilled by our acceptance and decided to stay for lunch and make a time of it.
I ordered a pick 4 salad which was served on Leaf or Romaine lettuce and of substantial size. My dog got meatballs which she definitely approved of (they were pretty decent). We took an Italian sub to go when we left an hour or so later.
NOTE
I understand an upcharge for a side with sandwich, however I feel that any single serve sandwich should at the very least be served with a pickle spear as this is not a "Sub shop" and a pleasant sit down dining experience is provided.
My review is based off of 13 yrs bartending, 17 yrs cooking, and an avid dog lover and service dog trainer. My dog experience is better with each visit."
Benjamin Walter
"While staying in Green Bay, we decided to try Glass Nickel Pizza Co. for dinner — and I’m so glad we did! Our server was fantastic: friendly, patient while we debated which pizza to order, quick with our drink orders, and thorough in explaining the day’s specials.
The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, with the bonus of bar seating if you’re dining solo — a nice touch that makes it feel welcoming for everyone.
When the pizza first arrived, I was a little hesitant because the crust looked like it might be from a frozen pizza. But that doubt disappeared with the first bite — it was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. We went with the supreme, which was generously loaded with toppings.
I also love that they offer a different daily special, which makes it easy to enjoy a great meal while saving a little money. Overall, this was a wonderful experience, and I’d definitely recommend stopping here if you’re in the area!"
Amy Schoen
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Diners rave about the perfect combination of cheese, sauce, and crust, with many considering it the best pizza they've ever had. They also offer unique interpretations of popular pizza styles.
Yes, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. offers vegan pizzas, such as the Daiya® Delight, and has been praised for its gluten-free pizza.
The service is frequently highlighted as exceptional, with staff like Madison being very accommodating and friendly, creating a welcoming dining experience.
Yes, the patio is an option for dining and is recommended for a pleasant experience, with staff being happy to accommodate.
The restaurant offers daily specials, which are well-priced and a great way to enjoy a delicious meal while saving money.
The 'Pick 4 Salad' is a generous portion salad that can be served on your choice of lettuce, offering a substantial and customizable option.
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. features creatively named pies like the Boaris Karloff (with three different meats) and the Pollo Diablo, which has garnered a cult following.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best pizza in Green Bay? – Grief Bacon
Having had Glass Nickel a time or two, the best things about this place are the actual Not Pizza items, but the pizza is certainly not bad either. Unfortunately, the one time we ate in the actual location was so terrible that I didn’t even bother writing a Yelp review because I was certain that the bad service was a weird fluke with new staff or something. Like, it was THAT bad and no one even apologized, and in fact, seemed to insinuate that they screwed up the order but I should be happy with what I got anyway.
A Foodie's Guide to the Best Restaurants in Green Bay, Wisconsin
Located in Green Bay, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. is making waves with its creative pizzas and classic pastas, alongside an array of wings and seafood dishes. Patrons rave about the stellar service, with one couple even choosing this spot to celebrate their anniversary, impressed by the attentive waitress and top-notch calzones and vegetarian lasagna. The Pollo Diablo pizza has garnered a cult following, described as a life-changing experience with its perfectly spiced jalapenos on a thin crust.
The Ultimate Green Bay Pizza Trail
This local pizza chain got its start in the state capital of Madison and is now in nine different locations throughout Wisconsin. Each season, they put out a limited menu of favorites, or you can order off the permanent menu of specialty pizzas like the Boaris Karloff (featuring three different Boar’s Head® meats) or the Portabella Lugosi. They also have a Daiya® Delight pizza for those who are vegan or lactose-intolerant!
Eat Your Way Through Greater Green Bay, WI’s Restaurant Scene
Finally, the Green Bay outpost of regional chain Glass Nickel Pizza Co. offers cleverly named pies, such as the Cheeseasaurus (a sauceless pizza with extra cheese) and the Couch Potato (topped with tater tots and a side of sour cream).
Highest-rated Pizza Restaurants in Green Bay, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4 / 5 (113 reviews) - Detailed ratings: Food (4.0/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.5/5) - Cuisine: Pizza - Price: $$ - $$$ - Address: 416 Dousman St, Green Bay, WI 54303-2716 - Read more on Tripadvisor
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit