Tommy's Pizza
A beloved Gettysburg institution since 1973, serving delicious Greek-style pizza, subs, and a vast craft beer selection in a nostalgic, family-friendl...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Tommy's Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved Gettysburg institution since 1973, serving delicious Greek-style pizza, subs, and a vast craft beer selection in a nostalgic, family-friendly setting.
"For a pizza place, it does the job remarkably well and is truly very good. "
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long waits by visiting during non-busy times, especially during lunch and dinner rushes.
Try the Greek Pizza
Don't miss the house specialty: the sauce-free Greek pizza with its distinctive, flavorful toppings.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza, Italian
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(717) 334-8966
Address
105 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325, USA
Website
tommyspizzainc.com/menu.phpHighlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Greek-Style Pizza
Savor unique Greek-style pizzas topped with feta, spinach, tomatoes, garlic, and olive oil. A must-try!
Old-School Pizzeria Ambiance
Experience a relaxed, family-run atmosphere reminiscent of an 80s pizza parlor. [^M4]
Extensive Craft Beer Selection
Enjoy a wide array of craft beers at outside tables while waiting for your freshly prepared meal. [^M2]
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Cheese Pizza
Pizza
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long waits by visiting during non-busy times, especially during lunch and dinner rushes.
Try the Greek Pizza
Don't miss the house specialty: the sauce-free Greek pizza with its distinctive, flavorful toppings.
Communicate Crust Preference
If you prefer a thinner crust, let the staff know to ensure your pizza is made to your liking.
Delivery Option Available
Opt for delivery services to enjoy your meal comfortably at your accommodation.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long waits by visiting during non-busy times, especially during lunch and dinner rushes.
Try the Greek Pizza
Don't miss the house specialty: the sauce-free Greek pizza with its distinctive, flavorful toppings.
Communicate Crust Preference
If you prefer a thinner crust, let the staff know to ensure your pizza is made to your liking.
Delivery Option Available
Opt for delivery services to enjoy your meal comfortably at your accommodation.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Tommy's Pizza is a highly-rated, family-run establishment in Gettysburg known for its delicious pizzas, especially the Greek-style. While many praise the generous toppings, good cheese, and friendly service, some reviews mention issues with pizzas being overcooked or underbaked. Despite occasional inconsistencies, the restaurant remains a popular choice for its classic pizza parlor feel and craft beer selection. +2
"My friend told me to try out Tommy's Pizza. I am so glad we did. We did pick up. We got fries, mozzarella sticks and pizza. It was so delicious. If I wasn't full I would have eaten it all. I wish they were in my area because it was legitimately so good. I haven't had a real good pizza in a long time. The crust was perfect not too thick not too thin, they had a perfect amount of cheese and sauce and a good amount of mushrooms. The gentleman who took our order was also very nice and courteous. We will definitely go back before we leave here and go home, I saw a white pizza on the menu I really wanted to try too."
Melissa Phillips
"I put this place on my ‘want to visit’ list when I knew I was coming to Gettysburg. Today was my first day touring the battlefields and I broke off for a lunch break at Tommy’s. It was almost 3pm but the place was hopping.
I want to say that everyone I’ve encountered in Gettysburg has been very friendly and the staff at Tommy’s was no exception. Very nice people.
Since I was a party of one, I had a small supreme pizza. It was ready in about 15 minutes. Very nice pizza. The taste of everything reminded me of the Round Table chain back on the west coast, which is my favorite pizza chain. It was a good pizza. I ate half for lunch and the second half when I got back to my room in the evening.
The things that stood out to me on the pizza were the cheese (very, very good) and the sausage. It had nice seasoning and good flavor. The sauce was a little lacking in oomph, but it was decent. The crust, while cooked about as crispy as you could get it, was a little overwhelmed by the amount of ingredients that a supreme carries. It would have been perfect with a two or three topping pie."
Jack Batty (Voracious_Vagabond)
"I don't know what happened, the pizza used to be great. Always come here while in the area. Drove over 2 hours to get the pizza and a T-shirt on my husband's birthday. Get home and pizza was horribly over cooked. It was worse then gas station pizza. Quality has definitely taken a huge nose dive."
Jennifer Young
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The Greek-style pizza is a standout, known for its unique toppings like feta, spinach, and tomatoes. Classic pizzas and cheesesteaks are also popular choices. [^M2]
Yes, it's a long-standing family-run pizzeria with a relaxed atmosphere, making it a great spot for family dining. [^M4]
Yes, Tommy's Pizza has outside tables where you can enjoy your meal and craft beer selections. [^M2]
They offer one of the largest craft beer selections in town, perfect for enjoying while you wait for your food. [^M3]
Yes, delivery services are available, making it convenient to enjoy Tommy's Pizza at your accommodation. [^datatip4]
The menu includes options like veggie pizzas and salads, and many pizzas can be customized with vegetable toppings. [^datamenuitem_1]
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
8 Great Places To Eat, Explore, And Stay In Gettysburg, Pennsylvania
If you’re looking to try some of the best burgers in Gettysburg, then head to Fourscore Beer Co. Other fan favorites on the menu include the wings, mac & cheese, catfish tacos, Wagyu hotdog, and salads. There’s plenty of outdoor seating in the shade—they set up a large tent over picnic tables so people can enjoy outdoor dining while still social distancing. Adults will be tempted by the 14 beers on tap that range from IPAs to Pilsner-style beer and ales.
5 Top Spots for Outdoor Dining in Gettysburg
Take a seat at one of Tommy’s outside tables and enjoy a brewed beer while you wait for your pizza (or sub) to be cooked to perfection. Round, black tables line the side of the building, situated right on the sidewalk of Steinwehr Avenue. A small red awning covers a bit of the sky to shield those who want to sit out of the sun, but it doesn’t hinder people-watching on one of the most popular streets in Gettysburg.
10 Places for Outdoor Dining in Gettysburg
Time and time again we hear that a visit to Gettysburg isn’t complete without a stop at Tommy’s Pizza, Inc. located on Steinwehr Avenue. Tommy’s serves pizzas, subs, salads and an impressive selection of craft beer – all of which can be enjoyed outside. If you’ve ever wondered how Tommy’s makes their pizza SO delicious, check out our Cooking with a Gettysburg Chef segment at Tommy’s.
Gettysburg With Kids | History, Haunts and Horses
Tommy’s Pizza is also a favorite family dining spot on Steinwehr Avenue and always packed, they have the best pizza in town along with subs, salads and sandwiches. You can never go wrong with a stop at Tommy’s when you visit Gettysburg. If you are looking for something sweet take a short walk to Mr. G’s ice cream shop on Baltimore Street, their scoops are huge!
Best Historical Places to Visit on a Pennsylvania Road Trip
For a Colonial dining experience complete with historic dishes, dine at either the Dobbin House Tavern or Farnsworth House. Make a reservation as both are very popular. Dobbin House dates back to 1776 and is reputedly the oldest home in Gettysburg.
12 Things to Do in Gettysburg That Make It the Perfect Autumn Getaway
Evening: After an intense day, relax at Tommy’s Pizza, a Greek-style pizza joint that has welcomed families since 1973. As a reward for their attentiveness, treat everyone to a waffle cone at Mr. G’s Ice Cream Parlor.
15 Best Restaurants in Gettysburg, PA for 2025 (Top Eats!)
105 Steinwehr AveGettysburg, PA 17325(717) 334-8966 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Opened in 1973, this relaxed, family-owned pizzeria is the place to go in town for subs, pasta, pizza and craft beer.
Highest-rated Restaurants in Gettysburg by Diners
- Rating: 3.5/5 (296 reviews)- Price level: $- Address: 105 Steinwehr Ave. Gettysburg, Pennsylvania - Categories: Pizza- Read more on Yelp
Dining in Gettysburg, PA | The Keystone Inn
This family-run pizza joint serves up subs, hot wings, specialty pies, and draft beer to wash it all down with.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit