Gettysburg Eddie's
A casual American sports bar paying homage to baseball Hall of Famer Edward Plank, serving hearty comfort food with a lively atmosphere and baseball m...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Gettysburg Eddie's
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A casual American sports bar paying homage to baseball Hall of Famer Edward Plank, serving hearty comfort food with a lively atmosphere and baseball memorabilia.
"Huge portions and great drinks make this a must-try Gettysburg treasure!"
Off-Peak Hours Recommended
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid longer wait times for your food. Wednesdays offer half-price wings.
Large Parties Caution
Seating can be challenging for parties larger than 6, so consider other options or call ahead.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Generous Portions & Cozy Atmosphere
Enjoy hearty American fare with substantial portions in a charming, baseball-themed, hole-in-the-wall setting.
Signature Club Sandwich
A perfectly stacked club sandwich, praised for its generous layers and classic taste, served with a side of coleslaw.
Amazing Wings
Crispy, flavorful chicken wings are a must-try, especially with their half-price specials on Wednesdays.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Off-Peak Hours Recommended
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid longer wait times for your food. Wednesdays offer half-price wings.
Large Parties Caution
Seating can be challenging for parties larger than 6, so consider other options or call ahead.
Don't Skip the Coleslaw
The coleslaw is praised for its perfect seasoning and is not too heavy on mayonnaise.
Vegetarian Options Available
Dedicated menu section with vegetarian options like veggie quesadillas and portabella melts.
Tips
from all over the internet
Off-Peak Hours Recommended
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid longer wait times for your food. Wednesdays offer half-price wings.
Large Parties Caution
Seating can be challenging for parties larger than 6, so consider other options or call ahead.
Don't Skip the Coleslaw
The coleslaw is praised for its perfect seasoning and is not too heavy on mayonnaise.
Vegetarian Options Available
Dedicated menu section with vegetarian options like veggie quesadillas and portabella melts.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Gettysburg Eddie's is a beloved casual American restaurant and sports bar known for its generous portions and lively, baseball-themed atmosphere. Diners rave about the flavorful wings, substantial club sandwiches, and overall value. While the food is generally well-received, some find certain dishes could use a bit more flavor, and seating can be tight for larger groups.
"Absolute great food. There have a separate menu to show allergen and alternatives for their menu, the cocktails aren't heavy on the syrups, and the food is delicious. Hole-in-the-wall kinda joint and it serves up that vibe nicely. I got the club sandwich (swapped tomato for onion) and my mom got the portabella burger with salad wrap since she can't have meat or gluten; at the end of the meal she didn't have any leftovers. The coleslaw made me the most excited, mainly because it's not mayo heavy and only needed a little bit of pepper to get it perfect perfect. Definitely recommend if you're in the area and looking for a great place to eat."
Felicia Hardee
"Neat little bar and grill kind of place. Parking in the back with a door in between the buildings into the bar. Front entrance into the dining area. The blacked chicken was incredible, flavorful, and had just the right amount of spice/heat to make it perfect on tacos. The portions were great and the lettuce and other ingredients were fresh! The price was very affordable too."
William Merritt
"Came here for nostalgia sake and when we arrived, it definitely had an uplift from when we last visited back in 2019. The menu changed too which made us nervous but the food we ordered was soooooo good! Highly recommend for a great meal."
Sam Waterman
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Gettysburg Eddie's is known for its hearty club sandwich, crispy chicken wings, and portabella burger. Generous portions are a common theme.
Yes, Gettysburg Eddie's offers a dedicated menu section for vegetarians, including items like veggie quesadillas and portabella melts.
The restaurant can have difficulty accommodating parties larger than six, so it might be best to call ahead or consider smaller groups.
It's a casual American restaurant and sports bar with a lively atmosphere and baseball-themed decor, often described as a cozy hole-in-the-wall.
Wednesdays are a popular night with half-price wings, making them an even more enticing option.
Parking is available around the back, but can be an issue, especially for larger vehicles.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Top Five Spots for Vegetarian Dining in Gettysburg
Gettysburg Eddie’s unique décor and lively atmosphere make it a fun dining destination. Their menu is sure to please everyone, including vegetarians, as the menu at Gettysburg Eddie’s features an entire section of food that is friendly to those who don’t eat meat. Try the veggie quesadilla platter or vegetarian grinder, and don’t miss the delectable portabella melt – sautéed portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers and caramelized onions are topped with melted provolone and mozzarella cheeses and sandwiched on grilled rye bread.
How to Visit Gettysburg With Kids| Pennsylvania
My kids’ interest picked up when we stopped by Gettysburg Eddie’s, an eatery dedicated to the baseball player Edward Stewart Plank who was born locally and played for Gettysburg College. It was nice to enjoy a quick bite while the kids studied the memorabilia on the walls. Later during our stay we dined at The Dobbin House and I would recommend adding it to your visit as well!.
18 Top Things To Do In Gettysburg, PA
This sports bar and restaurant pays tribute to Baseball Hall of Fame pitcher, Eddy Plank who was born 10 years afar the Civil War on his parents farm north of Gettysburg. He had quite the illustrious career ranking 13th on the All Time Win List. Gettysburg Eddies specializes in homestyle dishes, NY-style deli sandwiches, Maryland crab cakes, and burgers.
Gettysburg Travel Guide | U.S. News Travel
Gettysburg's location in Adams County (a region known for its apple orchards and vineyards) makes it a popular spot in Pennsylvania for sipping local wines, ciders, spirits and beers. Oenophiles recommend checking out nearby wineries like Adams County Winery and Reid's Orchard & Winery, which has a tasting room in central Gettysburg.
20 Best Restaurants in Gettysburg
217 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325Phone: 717-334-1100 Visit Website. A post shared by @rockyroadtripz. Located a block from the historic Gettysburg National Cemetery in Gettysburg National Military Park, Gettysburg Eddie’s is named the iconic post-World War I baseball hall-of-fame pitcher Edward Stewart Plank.
10 Best Places to Eat in Gettysburg With Kids
⭐️ RATING: 4.5/5 Stars | 📍 LOCATION: 217 Steinwehr Ave | 🌭 KID’S MENU: YES. Gettysburg Eddie’s is named after Eddie Plank, a professional baseball player born in Gettysburg. This sports bar is a great place to eat in Gettysburg with kids since it offers a cozy atmosphere and a nice kid’s menu.
Haunted Pub Crawl
At first glance, Gettysburg Eddie’s is a good ol’ sports bar dedicated to left-handed pitcher Eddie Plank, Gettysburg’s famed baseball player. Step inside, order a Gettysburg Haze, and get ready to hear about the bar’s disturbing history and who or what may be pulling up a chair next to you.
Gettysburg Nightlife | Girls Night Out
Another option is Gettysburg Eddie’s, a casual American sports bar and restaurant, offering salad sensations, sandwiches, and homemade soups. Or you can also drop by the Gettysburg Company, an old-school restaurant, serving burgers with other home-style classics paired up with draft beer.
Top 10 Places To Get Food In Gettysburg
A classic American diner with a sports bar vibe, Gettysburg Eddie’s offers hearty comfort food at decently affordable. Its burgers, sandwiches, and milkshakes are local favorites. Also offering homemade soups and sandwiches, the laidback atmosphere is a fun way to relax and dine.
The 7 Best Gluten-Free American Restaurants in Gettysburg
I called ahead to see if they offered gluten-free menu and everything is cooked in the same fryer and is cross contaminated - Not Actually Gluten Free!. I wish they were honest about their options, people can get very sick. They are not Gluten Free despite advertising they are.
Gettysburg with kids: where to eat and tour in town
This family-friendly restaurant is named for baseball Hall of Famer Eddie Plank. No, it has nothing to do with Civil War history, but it’s a fun diversion, and the food is great. Fare ranges from fish and chips and burgers to pasta and sandwiches.
Good Eats Guide: Gettysburg
Locals love it for the great bar food and as a break from the Civil War experience that pays tribute to Gettysburg’s own baseball hall of famer, Eddie Plank. Enjoy America’s favorite pasttime with access to up to 80 Major League games per week.
16 Fun Things to Do in Gettysburg With Kids
Before you head out on your Gettysburg adventure, be sure to print out a Li’L Lincoln to explore with you. Then snap a photo and share with hashtag #LilLincoln to share your adventures with the world!. (Or just keep them as a family memory!)
Top Food & Drink Spots in Gettysburg, PA
Lastly, Gettysburg Eddie’s, a restaurant with historical significance stemming from a local baseball player, offers an intimate dining experience. Make your trip memorable by indulging in the diverse food and drink available in Gettysburg!
Savor Scrumptious Pie on the Adams County Pie Trail
At Gettysburg Eddie’s, the peanut butter pie is a can’t miss dessert for peanut butter lovers. This restaurant serves homemade peanut butter pie topped with chocolate sauce, whipped cream and crushed peanuts.
Gettysburg PA Restaurant Listings
Gettysburg Eddie’s is a Gettysburg restaurant that has something for everyone from burgers to a full dinner menu. We feature homemade soups, a variety of salad sensations and a wide v …
Highest-rated Restaurants in Gettysburg by Diners
- Rating: 4.0/5 (249 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 217 Steinwehr Ave. Gettysburg, Pennsylvania - Categories: New American, Sports Bars, Cheesesteaks- Read more on Yelp
Dining in Gettysburg, PA | The Keystone Inn
Large screen TVs line this casual spot where American fare is on the menu and Major League Baseball is the main course.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit