Bella Mozzarella Pizza & Grill
A beloved local spot serving delicious, thin-crust New York-style pizza and a variety of Italian-American favorites.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Bella Mozzarella Pizza & Grill
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved local spot serving delicious, thin-crust New York-style pizza and a variety of Italian-American favorites.
"Bella Mozzarella might be small, but it's hands-down one of the best spots for great food and drinks!"
Try the NY Pepperoni
The NY style pepperoni pizza is a customer favorite and highly recommended.
Calzone is Filling
Consider sharing the Calzone, as it's delicious but very filling.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza, Italian-American
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(239) 401-0555
Address
80 Old San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic NY-Style Pizza
Experience delicious pizza with wonderfully thin crusts and generous, fresh toppings. A must-try for pizza lovers!
Warm & Welcoming Atmosphere
Dine in a fun, casual atmosphere with friendly and attentive service, making it a great spot for families and pups.
Beyond Pizza Delights
Enjoy a wide variety of delicious dishes beyond pizza, including subs, pasta, and fresh salads.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the NY Pepperoni
The NY style pepperoni pizza is a customer favorite and highly recommended.
Calzone is Filling
Consider sharing the Calzone, as it's delicious but very filling.
Off-Peak Dining
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid potential short staffing issues.
Homemade Marinara
Don't miss the fresh, homemade marinara sauce – it's a standout!
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the NY Pepperoni
The NY style pepperoni pizza is a customer favorite and highly recommended.
Calzone is Filling
Consider sharing the Calzone, as it's delicious but very filling.
Off-Peak Dining
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid potential short staffing issues.
Homemade Marinara
Don't miss the fresh, homemade marinara sauce – it's a standout!
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Bella Mozzarella Pizza & Grill is praised for its authentic New York-style pizza with thin crusts and generous toppings. Reviewers also highlight the friendly and attentive service, as well as a warm atmosphere that makes it a great casual dining spot. While most experiences are positive, some mention occasional service hiccups during busy periods.
"First time in the area and stopped by for a quick lunch. Everything was delicious (they have way more than just pizza), the server was polite and prompt, and they let you bring your pups. We will absolutely be back again!"
Ashley Garcia
"We go to Ft. Myers Beach often. We went here for the first time today! We just wanted something different, and pizza sounded good! I'm not normally a NY Style Pizza fan, but we thought we'd try it. We ordered the 18' Meat Lover's Pizza and so e Garlic Bread with Mozzarella on top. What can I say??? Wow! It was EXCELLENT! Our server Evan was prompt and pleasant. He put up with a couple of weirdos (Us!) The pizza was WELL topped with toppings and the garlic bread was AMAZING! We ESPECIALLY liked the marinara that came with it!! Wow! It wasn't some "run of the mill" typical marinara sauce! It tasted FRESH, and there were chunks of tomato in it!!! It tasted homemade! All in all, it was a five star experience! Evan was really good too. He had to put up with us!!! 🤣 We will DEFINITELY be coming back, and we will let everyone know of a good place to eat at Ft. Myers Beach! I ALSO like that they are still there as a "Mom and Pop" type local place! I fear that Ft. Myers Beach businesses will go away with all the rebuilding that continues. So PLEASE STAY around! We will keep supporting!"
Paul Martin
"The food was great and the waitress Tyler was amazing. She was able to remember our order without writing it down and everything came out perfect. My husband is not one to usually finish his plate although he ordered the breakfast burrito and finished one half before I was able to take the picture. We also got the mozzarella sticks which were amazing and the cinnamon roll was pretty good too. I recommend this place!"
Heather Dake
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
They specialize in New York-style pizza with thin crusts and generous toppings. [^M2]
Yes, Bella Mozzarella offers a variety of dishes including subs, calzones, strombolis, pasta, salads, and burgers.
Yes, the atmosphere is fun and welcoming, and they even allow dogs on their patio. [^M3]
The NY style pepperoni pizza, calzones, strombolis, mozzarella sticks, and steak and cheese subs are highly recommended.
The restaurant is located in a convenient area, making it easy to walk to from nearby resorts and attractions.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The Best Restaurants at Fort Myers Beach, FL
Voted Best Waterfront Dining since 2004, Parrot Key Caribbean Grill offers delicious Caribbean inspired seafood, Florida favorites and tropical cocktails in an open air, waterfront atmosphere. Serving lunch and dinner 7 days a week, come discover why Parrot Key is your key to paradise!
Fort Myers Beach restaurants: 21 delicious reasons to go to the beach
This little corner of Times Square has been slinging pizza slices since Fort Myers Beach's earliest days. Bella Mozzarella took over the space in 2016. Its pies are simple with wonderfully thin crusts and a nice chew.
The Best Things to do in Fort Myers Beach for Families
Bella’s Mozzarella Pizza & Grill, where you can eat in on their welcoming patio or carry out and enjoy a delicious pizza with your family in the comfort of your hotel room or AirBnB.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit