"Food, Service and atmosphere were awesome! Our server Chuck was amazing and took great care of my wife and I. We shared The Pretzel with cheese dip and it was filling and flavorful. My wife had the Shrimp pasta and it was a good serving size with plenty of shrimp and enough for left overs. I had the French dip, probably the best French dip I’ve ever had and the onion rings were a good pick for the side. To finish we shared the German Chocolate Cake and it was decadent and not overwhelmingly sweet. Thank y’all for a fantastic experience, we will certainly be coming back in the future!"

Riley Jones

"This place was Amazing! We order way too much food as the portions were enormous! Sesame crusted Ahi Tuna was melt in your mouth, fish and shrimp amazing, wedge salad was a work of art and the pretzels and cheese just Fabulous! Recommend this restaurant to all visitors!"

Michelle Edwards

"We searched up good places to eat in Eureka Springs and this was on the list. Due to parking and service hours of other establishments, McGaritys was the winner this day. The reviews were great, but the parking lot was half-empty and the leprechaun out front seemed to over promise. We were skeptical but brave. So glad we did! The decor is charming, the staff super friendly and professional and the food was ah-mazing! Highly recommend."

Kimberly Henrie