The Custer Wolf - Food & Drink
A warm, casual eatery in Custer known for hearty American pub grub, craft beers, and a cozy atmosphere adorned with local art.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
The Custer Wolf - Food & Drink
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A warm, casual eatery in Custer known for hearty American pub grub, craft beers, and a cozy atmosphere adorned with local art.
"Experience big city quality with a small town vibe - a deadly good combination!"
Visit during off-peak hours
The restaurant can get busy, especially during peak times. Consider visiting during less crowded hours.
Reservations recommended
It's a small place, so arriving early or making a reservation is advised to secure a table.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American (Pub Fare)
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Award-Winning Fish & Chips
Crispy, hand-battered cod served with french fries and a zesty tartar sauce. A local favorite!
Cozy Atmosphere & Local Art
A warm, casual eatery adorned with local artwork and a unique wall of beer steins.
Exceptional Burgers
Juicy burgers made with quality ingredients, often cited as the best by diners.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit during off-peak hours
The restaurant can get busy, especially during peak times. Consider visiting during less crowded hours.
Reservations recommended
It's a small place, so arriving early or making a reservation is advised to secure a table.
Don't skip the sides
The potato smashers are a must-try, described as golden, crispy perfection.
Ask staff for local tips
Engage with the friendly staff for recommendations on local artwork or outdoor activities.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit during off-peak hours
The restaurant can get busy, especially during peak times. Consider visiting during less crowded hours.
Reservations recommended
It's a small place, so arriving early or making a reservation is advised to secure a table.
Don't skip the sides
The potato smashers are a must-try, described as golden, crispy perfection.
Ask staff for local tips
Engage with the friendly staff for recommendations on local artwork or outdoor activities.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners consistently praise The Custer Wolf for its delicious and hearty American pub fare, with many highlighting the exceptional burgers and fish and chips. The friendly and attentive service contributes to a warm, welcoming atmosphere. While the menu might not be extensive, the quality of the dishes and the cozy ambiance make it a highly recommended spot.
"Everything about The Custer Wolf was amazing. We had the fried green beans as a starter and they were light and crisp with a very good dipping sauces. For the main courses, I had the salmon and my wife had the flatbread taco, which was the special of the day. Finally, we split a chocolate mousse and it was fantastic.
We’re from Ohio and we really wish someday to return. It was a great stop!"
Andy Kachelmeier
"Nice place! Offers inside and outside seating. Food was extremely fresh and hot. We got the Fish & Chips (comes with an amazing tartar sauce) and the Chicken Tenders with Potato Smashers. Very hefty serving sizes and well worth the money. Menu was not as big as I had hoped for, but it definitely made the decisions easier. Service was very attentive."
Kimberly Bautista
"The food was great overall! The salad dressing stood out—very good and clearly homemade. The dessert with caramelized bacon wasn’t quite to my taste, but my son really enjoyed it. My husband absolutely loved the fish and chips, especially the tartar sauce.
What truly made the experience special was the service. The staff were outstanding—friendly, attentive, and welcoming. They really make this place a wonderful one!"
Fabiana Castle
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Many diners rave about the burgers, fish and chips, and the bread pudding. The Smoked Trout BLT and Walleye Chermoula are also popular choices.
Yes, it's recommended to make a reservation or arrive early as it's a small place and can get busy.
Yes, the restaurant features an outdoor patio seating area, perfect for enjoying good weather.
While not extensively detailed, there are some vegetarian options and a gluten-free designation on some menu items.
The atmosphere is warm, cozy, and casual, adorned with local artwork and a unique collection of beer steins.
Yes, the restaurant offers a good selection of craft beers on tap, with some local brews featured.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Restaurants in Custer
This bar and grill is in a renovated brick building with wood floors and a long, wooden bar, where the food is elevated a bit beyond standard pub fare. It's a great spot for a casual, affordable meal during a day of exploring the southern Black Hills.
best restaurants in custer Archives
Named after a legendary wolf who tormented the area in the 1920s, the restaurant is anything but scary. A local hotspot full of craft beer and fresh-made menu items, the Wolf is known for its wall of beer steins, each assigned to a regular customer. Stop in for Walleye Ceviche, added to the menu after the owners traveled to Belize, it’s a fresh South Dakota take on the popular seafood dish, the Shredded Buffalo Sandwich or their signature Bread Pudding topped with Whiskey Caramel Sauce.
Best Hikes In Custer State Park: Black Elk Peak And Cathedral Spires Loop Hike
We liked Maria’s Mexican for inexpensive but good Mexican, Custer Wolf for more foodie fare and a nice patio for kicking back with a beer, and Horatio’s for excellent ice cream. But you will also find pizza places, burger places, and even a super foodie place (Skogen Kitchen) all packed in and around Main Street. It is a great little town that is touristy but not completely overdone.
Best Places to Eat in Custer
If you love a local atmosphere and classic food, you’ll find it here!. The restaurant is casual dining in the front with a pub in the back and additional outdoor seating on the patio in the summer. Local artwork and cave maps line the walls and the staff can give you beta on some of the best rock climbing routes in the area.
Best Restaurants in Custer, SD
The Custer Wolf atmosphere is fun and casual with charming, thoughtful touches in every corner. But what really got the Custer Wolf on the list of the best restaurants in Custer, SD, is their passion for fresh food. And they know how to cook it, too.
The Best Things to Do in Custer State Park (+ where to stay & itineraries!)
As we mentioned above, we feel like you really need 2 days to experience all of the best things to do in Custer State Park, but it is possible to see the major highlights in 1 day or have a more relaxed itinerary with 3 days!
Explore Custer, South Dakota - Your Gateway to the Black Hills
A visit to the 1881 Courthouse Museum is a must for anyone interested in the history of the town and the region. This historic site offers insights into the evolution of Custer and its role in the American West.
Your Dawn-to-Dusk Guide to Custer
After a morning of hiking and trailblazing, you’ll definitely need something to eat. The Custer Wolf is a gastropub guaranteed to extinguish your hunger. Try the fish and chips, they’re a local favorite.
The Essential Guide To Visiting Custer State Park [With Itinerary!]
Custer Wolf: Another great spot with outdoor dining and yummy plates including fresh burgers and creative sandwiches. Has a nice outdoor patio as well
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit