Sage Creek Grille
A charming cafe offering Western American fare with local bison and elk, praised for its unique dishes, cozy ambiance, and attentive service.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Sage Creek Grille
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A charming cafe offering Western American fare with local bison and elk, praised for its unique dishes, cozy ambiance, and attentive service.
"Highly recommend this restaurant for a great vibe and fantastic food!"
Bike Week Parking
Additional motorcycle parking is available during Bike Week.
Savvy Entree Choices
If entrees seem pricey, consider trying different ones to sample more offerings.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Western American Fare with Local Flair
Savor unique dishes featuring local bison and elk, crafted with fresh produce for a true taste of the West.
Sophisticated Yet Casual Ambiance
Enjoy a comfortable atmosphere with historical decor, offering a refined dining experience.
Exceptional Desserts
Indulge in delightful sweet endings like cheesecake and creamy posset.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Bike Week Parking
Additional motorcycle parking is available during Bike Week.
Savvy Entree Choices
If entrees seem pricey, consider trying different ones to sample more offerings.
Avoid Cheesy Grits
Cheesy grits might be dry; opt for recommended dishes like walleye cakes.
Address Service Issues
Don't hesitate to inform your server about any dish or drink temperature concerns.
Tips
from all over the internet
Bike Week Parking
Additional motorcycle parking is available during Bike Week.
Savvy Entree Choices
If entrees seem pricey, consider trying different ones to sample more offerings.
Avoid Cheesy Grits
Cheesy grits might be dry; opt for recommended dishes like walleye cakes.
Address Service Issues
Don't hesitate to inform your server about any dish or drink temperature concerns.
Salt & Garlic Caution
Some dishes can be heavily salted or garlicked; ask for recommendations.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Sage Creek Grille is lauded for its exceptional food quality and unique Western American fare, with many praising the bison and elk dishes, as well as the attentive service and pleasant atmosphere. While most diners have a fantastic experience, a few have noted that some dishes can be overly salty or garlicky, and the prices are on the higher side, though generally considered reasonable for the quality.
"Excellent service.
Astonishing food.
Highly recommend trying the elk stuffed mushrooms and walleye cakes.
Loved the atmosphere.
Had the bison strip it was exquisite.
Wife had the salmon linguine it was also to die for.
Even the kids mac and cheese was excellent 👌.
We will be back."
Cory Baker
"This is a very nice restaurant, with a more sophisticated menu than many places in Custer. Service was excellent and attentive. The kids' meals were well received and both the salmon and buffalo ribeye were wonderful. The vibe is still somewhat casual and the prices aren't cheap but are reasonable. The wine list was also very good. I'd definitely recommend this restaurant if you're looking for a great meal."
Joanna O
"Great spot with a good selection of tasty options. Atmosphere was great, service was great and most importantly, the food was delicious! We'll definitely come back next time we are in the area."
Veder Garcia
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Signature dishes include elk stuffed mushrooms, bison ribeye, and walleye cakes. Many guests also rave about the salmon and various pasta dishes.
Yes, the restaurant offers well-received kids' meals and a welcoming atmosphere for families.
Reservations are not always necessary, especially on weeknights. One reviewer visited on a Tuesday at 6:45 PM without needing one.
The restaurant offers a casual yet upscale atmosphere with unique decor featuring historical prints.
The menu indicates vegetarian and vegan options are available.
Popular desserts include creme brule cheesecake and naval orange posset.
During Bike Week, additional motorcycle parking is made available.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit