Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co.
1 / 10

Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co.

4.6
·491k reviews·,

Renowned for its creative burgers on house-baked buns and unique pizzas, this bustling Custer spot is a must-visit for foodies.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co.

Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Renowned for its creative burgers on house-baked buns and unique pizzas, this bustling Custer spot is a must-visit for foodies.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"Consistently rated as one of the best burger joints in America, the wait is always worth it!"

TIP

Visit Early or Off-Peak

To avoid long waits, try visiting early on non-weekend days, especially during the off-season.

Consider Online Ordering

For added convenience, take advantage of their online ordering system.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens Friday 5PM

Cuisine

American (Burgers & Pizza)

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(605) 673-3411

Address

441 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD 57730, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Award-Winning Burgers

Award-Winning Burgers

Consistently ranked as a top burger joint, their house-baked buns and unique toppings create unforgettable flavors.

Top Stops in CusterExperiencing the Custer State Park Buffalo RoundupGoogle Review+1
Creative Pizza Creations

Creative Pizza Creations

Beyond burgers, their pizzas feature unique combinations, including a popular Thai pizza and a spicy bacon cheeseburger option.

Google Review+1
Unique Appetizers

Unique Appetizers

Don't miss out on their crispy fried pickles or cheese curds, perfect for sharing or as a personal treat.

Google Review+1
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Took a little visit to Mount Rushmore in South Dakota! Found this diamond in the rough right next to it! Black Hills Burger and Bun Co #foodie
@foodyfellowship
92 likes • 6.4K views

Visit Early or Off-Peak

To avoid long waits, try visiting early on non-weekend days, especially during the off-season.

Consider Online Ordering

For added convenience, take advantage of their online ordering system.

Ask for Server Recommendations

Servers like Jamie are known for great recommendations, enhancing your dining experience.

Try House-Baked Buns

Their burgers are elevated by delicious, freshly baked buns made in-house daily.

Tips

from all over the internet

Visit Early or Off-Peak

To avoid long waits, try visiting early on non-weekend days, especially during the off-season.

Consider Online Ordering

For added convenience, take advantage of their online ordering system.

Ask for Server Recommendations

Servers like Jamie are known for great recommendations, enhancing your dining experience.

Try House-Baked Buns

Their burgers are elevated by delicious, freshly baked buns made in-house daily.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Diners rave about the exceptional quality and creativity of the burgers, often citing them as the best they've ever had. The house-baked buns and unique toppings like fresh jalapeños and cream cheese receive special mention. While the pizza is also praised for its unique flavors, some long-time patrons miss the previous burger-centric menu. The atmosphere is described as welcoming and modern, though the restaurant's popularity can lead to significant wait times.

"Our family loved this place! You seat yourself and order at the counter… you can also order online! It was busy but the staffed worked hard to clear tables and seat people that were waiting! We ordered the terminator with no sausage and the cheese curds! So good!!"

Blair K

"Family of 7 stopped in for dinner after a day of hiking. We were hungry! Got some Classic burgers, one of them bison, a Hot Granny burger (pictured), and the Betty White Pizza (pictured). We liked it all very much! Fries were just ok-a little underwhelming and bland. The pizza was good, but a bit rich to eat alone (to be expected with the white sauce). The burgers were very good, and the absolute winner was the Hot Granny burger. Highly recommend that if you’re interested in flavors beyond the typical!"

Aaron Johnson

"Amazing food! Owner was so friendly. Thai pizza was beyond impressive! I wish we had pictures from before!
So good we went back the next day… burgers were as great as the pizza! Took pictures today! If you are in Custer, or even close by, this is a must!!
Mr and Mrs Pizza 🍕. Bacon blue burger 🍔 Hot honey burger so good best and unique must try!!!!🍯 the heat was perfectly balanced! Do yourself a favor and just try this place."

Elizabeth Hart

What People Like

Award-winning burgers with house-baked buns
Creative and delicious pizza options
Unique toppings and flavor combinations

What People Dislike

Long wait times due to popularity
Occasional menu shifts

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, many reviewers agree that the award-winning burgers and unique pizzas make the wait worthwhile. Consider visiting during off-peak hours or weekdays.

Restaurants in CusterTop Stops in CusterGoogle Review

The signature burgers, especially the 'Hot Granny' and 'Bacon Blue Burger', are highly recommended. The unique pizzas, like the Thai pizza or 'Betty White', are also popular.

Best Restaurants in Custer, SDGoogle Review+2

Yes, the restaurant is known to offer vegetarian options for their burgers, catering to a wider range of preferences.

Google Review

To avoid long waits, it's recommended to visit early on non-weekend days, especially during the off-season.

Google Review

Yes, online ordering is available for added convenience, allowing you to skip the line.

Google Review

Fries and tater tots are popular sides. Sweet potato fries and fried pickles are also highly recommended appetizers.

Google Review+1

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

Fodor’s Travel

Restaurants in Custer

The focus on simple, fresh, and delicious food at affordable prices has made this very small establishment into a phenomenon with one of the best reputations of any restaurant in the Black Hills. It's located in a renovated, downtown building with exposed brick walls and stained-glass accents. The only problem here is the difficulty getting a seat in the small dining area: hours are limited, the place fills up fast, and because the reputation is so stellar, people are willing to endure long waits outside on the bench or even just standing on the sidewalk.

Visit Source →
Heyn Real Estate

Best Restaurants in Custer, SD

Best quality ingredients with minimal processing are hallmarks of this family-owned restaurant. Highlights on the menu consist of, you guessed it, their burgers on their house baked buns. (That are out-of-this-world!) Entree’s such as The Hot Granny which features USDA chunk beef (ground in house daily), cream cheese, fresh jalapeno’s, and sweet-spicy jalapeno sauce await you in this glorious burger haven right on Mt. Rushmore Rd.

Visit Source →
city-data.com

Hiking recommendations? (Custer: camping, to live in, centers) - South Dakota (SD)

My favorite book for hiking in this area is "Hiking the Black Hills Country: A guide to more than 50 hikes in South Dakota and Wyoming" by Bert and Jane Gildart. It gives good descriptions, detail locations of trail markers, and interest flora and fauna to see. You should be able to pick this book up in Rapid or any local bookstore in the area.

Visit Source →
Black Hills Visitor

Top Stops in Custer

With renowned food and service around the country, the Black Hills Burger & Bun Co. is a place you must visit when you stop into Custer. Several years ago Trip Advisor named them the top burger joint in the country, but you better get there early, because Dolsee shares that most times there’s a line out the door!

Visit Source →
Our Wander-Filled Life

Experiencing the Custer State Park Buffalo Roundup

For this trip, we were happy Black Hills Burger and Bun, regarded as one of the best burger joints in America, was open.

Visit Source →
605 Magazine

605 Road Trip | Custer State Park Buffalo Roundup

Visit Source →