Wonderful, historic restaurant in Cleveland's Little Italy District. Great food, excellent servi
1 / 10

Guarino's Restaurant

4.6
·491k reviews·,

Cleveland's oldest Italian restaurant, offering timeless Victorian decor, a beloved garden patio, and classic comfort food.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Wonderful, historic restaurant in Cleveland's Little Italy District. Great food, excellent servi

Guarino's Restaurant

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Cleveland's oldest Italian restaurant, offering timeless Victorian decor, a beloved garden patio, and classic comfort food.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"Experience the charm and history of Little Italy with authentic Italian fare and a beautiful garden oasis."

TIP

Reservations Recommended

Book ahead to guarantee a table, especially given the restaurant's popularity and cozy seating.

Explore Unique Appetizers

Try less common starters like capri pizza or the artichoke and eggplant salad.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens 12PM

Cuisine

Italian

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(216) 231-3100

Address

12309 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106, USA

Insta-Factor

Medium

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Historic Victorian Charm

Historic Victorian Charm

Step back in time with warm, inviting Victorian decor that creates a truly unique dining atmosphere.

Enchanting Garden Patio

Enchanting Garden Patio

Dine al fresco in a charming garden patio, lauded as one of Cleveland's best, perfect for warm evenings.

30+ of the Best Patios in Cleveland Patios for Outdoor Dining16 Restaurants With Outdoor Dining in ClevelandBest patios in Cleveland, Ohio+1
Classic Italian Comfort Food

Classic Italian Comfort Food

Savor large portions of flavorful, old-school Italian dishes like lasagna and chicken Parmesan.

Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Reservations Recommended

Book ahead to guarantee a table, especially given the restaurant's popularity and cozy seating.

Explore Unique Appetizers

Try less common starters like capri pizza or the artichoke and eggplant salad.

Don't Skip Dessert

Save room for house-made treats like tiramisu or cannoli.

Cocktail Creations

Indulge in signature cocktails, such as the barrel-aged cherry bourbon Manhattan.

Tips

from all over the internet

Reservations Recommended

Book ahead to guarantee a table, especially given the restaurant's popularity and cozy seating.

Explore Unique Appetizers

Try less common starters like capri pizza or the artichoke and eggplant salad.

Don't Skip Dessert

Save room for house-made treats like tiramisu or cannoli.

Cocktail Creations

Indulge in signature cocktails, such as the barrel-aged cherry bourbon Manhattan.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Guarino's Restaurant is celebrated for its charming Victorian ambiance and a delightful garden patio that evokes a grandparent's backyard. Diners rave about the history and warmth of the establishment, with many calling the lasagna the best they've ever had. However, some guests have found the food to be inconsistent, with a few describing it as bland and not up to par for true Italian cuisine, while service has also received mixed reviews.

"The oldest restaurant in Cleveland! The atmosphere is amazing and the food can’t be beat! Soooo glad we came here! I had the lasagna- and it is the best lasagna I’ve ever had. The menu said the recipe is 60 years old! SO GOOD! We were visiting the area, and happened upon Little Italy. Worth the visit for sure!"

Nicole Bishop

"Had dinner at Guarino’s on 7/12 and had such a great experience. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was cozy and classic, and the staff were super friendly. Huge shoutout to the valet drivers around 7:30/8:30—they were honestly the nicest and made the night even better. If you’re looking for great Italian place in Cleveland with charm and history, this is the place!"

Katarina D

"🌟 A Meal to Remember – Thank You for Making It Special 🌟

After finishing my last round of chemo, we wanted to mark the occasion with something meaningful (a good meal shared with my husband). We chose Guarino's in Little Italy, and it turned out to be the perfect! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel welcomed and cared for. They didn’t just serve us food — they gave us an experience filled with warmth, kindness, and that meant more than words can express. My lasagna and my husband's spaghetti and meatballs were absolutely delicious! The atmosphere was calm and inviting, just what we needed after such a long and emotional day. Thank you to everyone for taking care of us! Your hospitality and excellent food turned a simple lunch into something truly memorable. We will never forget your kindness! We’ll definitely be back, this time to celebrate health and new beginnings!"

Sarah Mccoy

What People Like

Historic Victorian decor and ambiance
Charming garden patio
The lasagna is a standout dish

What People Dislike

Inconsistent food quality
Some find the flavors bland
Mixed reviews on service

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, Guarino's Restaurant is widely recognized as the oldest restaurant in Cleveland, with a history dating back to 1918.

30 of the Most Romantic Restaurants In Cleveland9 Best Restaurants To Try In ClevelandCleveland, Ohio's Best Global Restaurants

Popular choices include the lasagna, chicken Parmesan, pesto gnocchi, and fettuccine Alfredo. Don't forget to try their house-made desserts like tiramisu or cannoli.

Google Review

Yes, the restaurant features a charming garden patio that is highly praised and considered one of the best in Cleveland.

30+ of the Best Patios in Cleveland Patios for Outdoor Dining16 Restaurants With Outdoor Dining in ClevelandBest patios in Cleveland, Ohio+2

Yes, Guarino's has its own private parking lot adjacent to the restaurant, which is very convenient for diners.

Google Review+1

Live piano music is often featured in the lounge, and live music can also be enjoyed on the garden patio.

Google Review

It is recommended to make reservations ahead of time, especially on weekends, as the restaurant can get busy.

Google Review

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

The Cleveland Traveler

30+ of the Best Patios in Cleveland Patios for Outdoor Dining

Opened in the early 1900s by Italian immigrant Vincenzo Guarino, what started out as a tavern slowly evolved into a restaurant. It was Vincenzo’s son Sam who had the garden out back built for formal dining, and the patio even has a trumpet vine that was planted by Vincenzo still standing today. While you’ll enjoy the Victorian-style decor inside this establishment in Little Italy, this place is also well-known as having one of the best patios in Cleveland!

Visit Source →
Cleveland Magazine

Summer Patios: Cleveland's 28 Best Spots to Eat and Drink Outside

**Why we love it: For more than 30 years, this upscale restaurant has made a name for itself as a top Italian fine dining spot. Floor-to-ceiling windows overlook the Cuyahoga River and the patio has matching views. Try this: The simple greens salad ($8) with English cucumber, carrot and balsamic, coupled with grilled salmon ($18), makes for a perfect lunch al fresco.

Visit Source →
Restaurant Clicks

16 Restaurants With Outdoor Dining in Cleveland

12309 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106216-231-3100 Visit Website. After spending your afternoon at the Cleveland Botanical Garden, the best place to visit and enjoy old-school Italian cuisine in a vintage setting is Guarino’s Restaurant, one of the city’s oldest eateries. Their patio is a great place to unwind on the sunniest days.

Visit Source →
Fox 8 Cleveland WJW

Best patios in Cleveland, Ohio

When it’s time to get that old-school Italian food fix and you’re going out to Little Italy, you’d be remiss to not consider the Guarino’s back patio. It feels like your grandparents’ backyard, but packed in with a lot more tables. The place has been running for more than 100 years, they must know what they’re doing.

Visit Source →
foodsofjane

Hidden Food Gems in Cleveland

Guarino’s might be a little more well known since it's the oldest restaurant in Cleveland, but I’m pretty sure that since I had no idea how awesome their patio is, most people within my network don’t know either. It’s basically an Italian garden with string lights, greenery everywhere, and live music.

Visit Source →
Cleveland Scene

30 of the Most Romantic Restaurants In Cleveland

Guarino’s 12309 Mayfield Rd., Cleveland Established in 1918, Guarino’s in Little Italy is Cleveland’s oldest restaurants and is still a family operation. The old world decor tends toward Victoriana and the kitchen’s pasta, veal and seafood dishes are all Italian. Photo via Guarino’s/Facebook

Visit Source →
TravelAwaits

9 Best Restaurants To Try In Cleveland

Cleveland’s oldest restaurant is Guarino’s, located in Little Italy; you can feel the history coming from every part of the building. While the years have passed, the menu hasn’t changed too much. Everything is house-made and as authentic as when the doors first opened in 1918.

Visit Source →
heremagazine.com

Cleveland, Ohio's Best Global Restaurants

In Cleveland’s Little Italy you’ll find the historic Guarino’s, which first opened in 1898. Vincenzo Guarino came from Sicily and purchased the tavern, including an apartment upstairs. After getting married, his wife began serving meals to patrons.

Visit Source →

How to spend 48 hours in CLE

Have lunch at one of the local favorites like Mama Santa's for Sicilian pizza, Mia Bella for upscale Mediterranean, or Guarino's for Italian home cookin'. Don't forget to leave room for dessert from Presti's Bakery or (...and?) Corbo's Bakery.

Visit Source →
Stacker

Highest-rated Italian Restaurants in Cleveland, According to Tripadvisor

- Rating: 4.0 / 5 (331 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.0/5), Service (4.0/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.0/5)- Type of cuisine: Italian- Price: $$ - $$$- Address: 12309 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106-1927- Read more on Tripadvisor

Visit Source →
cleveland

Highest-rated Italian restaurants in

Lasagna – Broken meatballs, ricotta, mozzarella, Sunday Premier from Stancato’s Italian Restaurant located at 7380 State Rd, Parma - Photo by Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com

Visit Source →
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty

Cleveland Food Guide: The Best Restaurants with the Best Outdoor Seating

Get a taste of “Little Italy” that will take you back to Cleveland’s roots with Guarino’s. They even feature a gluten-free menu!

Visit Source →
guarinoscleveland.com

Cleveland's Oldest Restaurant

Visit Source →
WKYC

10 restaurants in Cleveland's Little Italy & University Heights

Visit Source →
Eating Expired

Does Cleveland have Michelin star restaurants?

Visit Source →