Carlo & Johnny By Jeff Ruby
An upscale steakhouse in a historic mansion, offering world-class steaks, fine seafood, and a captivating atmosphere with live entertainment.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Carlo & Johnny By Jeff Ruby
Highlights
Must-see attractions
An upscale steakhouse in a historic mansion, offering world-class steaks, fine seafood, and a captivating atmosphere with live entertainment.
"This is by far one of the best restaurants in the area, perfect for celebrating a special occasion."
Reservations Essential
Book your table in advance, as this popular spot fills up quickly, especially on weekends.
Generous Portions
Portions are substantial; consider sharing dishes or planning for leftovers.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American Steakhouse
Price
$$$
Phone
(513) 936-8600
Address
9769 Montgomery Rd, Montgomery, OH 45242, USA
Website
jeffruby.com/carlo-johnnyHighlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Historic Gangster Hideout Turned Upscale Steakhouse
Dine in a former 1933 gangster hideout, speakeasy, and casino, offering a unique historic atmosphere with impeccable service and exquisite food.
USDA Prime Steaks and Fine Seafood
Indulge in world-class USDA Prime steaks and exceptional seafood, including raw bar selections and unique sushi rolls.
Live Entertainment and Supper Club Vibe
Experience a supper club atmosphere enhanced by live entertainment, creating a memorable and vibrant dining experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Reservations Essential
Book your table in advance, as this popular spot fills up quickly, especially on weekends.
Generous Portions
Portions are substantial; consider sharing dishes or planning for leftovers.
Dress Code Guidance
Casual to business casual attire is recommended. Valet parking is available.
Splurge for a Special Occasion
Expect to spend around $200+ for two; it's a great choice for celebrations.
Tips
from all over the internet
Reservations Essential
Book your table in advance, as this popular spot fills up quickly, especially on weekends.
Generous Portions
Portions are substantial; consider sharing dishes or planning for leftovers.
Dress Code Guidance
Casual to business casual attire is recommended. Valet parking is available.
Splurge for a Special Occasion
Expect to spend around $200+ for two; it's a great choice for celebrations.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners consistently praise Carlo & Johnny for its impeccable food quality, particularly the USDA Prime steaks, and the unique, historic atmosphere. While many rave about the excellent service and overall special occasion feel, some reviews mention occasional service lapses and a few specific dishes not meeting high expectations.
"So glad to have given this place a second chance! Grace and her team really made the experience special. The food was exceptional. From the appetizers all the way through to dessert I was amazed by the flavors and freshness. The oysters Rockefeller were delicious, the steak was cooked perfectly and seasoned well! The butter pie left me wanting to take another slice to go! Highly recommend. A perfect meal and nice location for a special occasion."
Nara Arnold
"Very nice venue. I like the ambiance and the decorations. The management try to their best to provide the best experience. I enjoyed my visit, drinks, appetizer, and the food. There are plenty of parking near by. Free parking and valet device is available . Google Maps would guide to a wrong entrance. So just following the sign if the restaurant."
Zag
"This was my first time at Carlo & Johnny and it did not disappoint. The Valet Parking attendants are incredible. I left my glasses in my truck and it was raining. The attendant insisted that he would go get them for me. The host that seated us was very friendly and thanked us for coming in. Then the server came to the table and she was very friendly and provided excellent service. Then the food came out, and oh my, the food was amazing. The steaks were cooked to perfection. I highly recommend the Joe Burrow and the Asparagus. The Anthony Munoz was delicious as well."
rich williams
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The restaurant is set in a historic mansion, offering a unique gangster-themed ambiance with a supper club feel and live entertainment.
The restaurant is renowned for its USDA Prime steaks, raw bar selections, and unique dishes like the 'Who Dey??' sushi roll.
The recommended dress code is casual to business casual. Valet parking is available.
Yes, it is highly recommended to make reservations in advance as the restaurant is very popular.
Carlo & Johnny is an upscale dining establishment, with expectations of spending around $200+ for a table of two.
Absolutely! It's highly regarded as a fantastic place for celebrations and special occasions.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
See which Ohio restaurants are among the 'Top 100 Romantic Restaurants' in America
Located in a historic Montgomery mansion that was once a stagecoach stopover, a speakeasy, an illegal casino and a gangster hideout, Carlo & Johnny by Jeff Ruby bills itself as being known for world-class U.S.D.A. Prime steaks, a raw bar honored as one of Cincinnati’s finest and live entertainment. OpenTable says it has a classic style paired with Ruby's steaks and exceptional seafood. It has a rating of 4.8 stars from 8,379 reviews, and is tagged "good for special occasions," "fancy" and "charming." Its most popular dishes, according to the site, are steak Diane and cowboy steak.
6 Cincinnati restaurants land on OpenTable's Top 100 in the US list
This fine dining spot, owned by esteemed local restaurateur Jeff Ruby, is nestled inside a historic Montgomery mansion. The eclectic steakhouse features Jeff Ruby's USDA Prime steaks, live entertainment and extensive seafood offerings (a special shoutout goes to the "Who Dey??" sushi roll with grilled shrimp and salmon). Located at 9769 Montgomery Road, Carlo & Johnny is open Monday through Thursday, 5 to 9 p.m., Fridays from 4:30 to 10 p.m., Saturdays from 4 to 10 p.m.
Foodie News You Can Use
The award goes to restaurants “whose wine lists feature a well-chosen selection of quality producers, thoughtfully paired to complement the menu in both price and style.” Three additional restaurants—The Precinct, Alfio’s Buon Cibo, and Jeff Ruby’s Carlo & Johnny—placed in the Best of Award of Excellence category, “destinations for serious wine lovers, showing a deep commitment to wine, both in the cellar and through their service team.
Carlo & Johnny | Cincinnati Fine Dining
Like each of Jeff Ruby’s restaurants, Carlo & Johnny tells quite a story. Housed in a historic mansion that was once a stagecoach stopover, a speakeasy, an illegal casino, and a gangster hideout, this award-winning steakhouse oozes intimacy and character. We’re known for world-class U.S.D.A. Prime steaks, a raw bar honored as one of Cincinnati’s finest, live entertainment, and service that leaves guests feeling like royalty.
23 of Cincinnati's Most Romantic Restaurants to Take Your Sweetheart
Carlo & Johnny 9769 Montgomery Road, Montgomery Carlo & Johnny is another upscale steakhouse from the team behind Jeff Ruby’s. Located in Montgomery, this restaurant is situated in a historic mansion that was formerly a gangster hideout, stagecoach stopover and casino. They offer over 14 U.S.D.A Prime steaks as well as a variety of fresh seafoods and impeccable service.
Highest-rated restaurants for special occasions in Cincinnati, according to Tripadvisor
– Rating: 4.5 / 5 (350 reviews)– Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.5/5)– Type of cuisine: American, Steakhouse– Price: $$$$– Address: 9769 Montgomery Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45242-7215– Read more on Tripadvisor. You may also like: Highest-rated Chinese restaurants in Cincinnati, according to Tripadvisor
Ohio Has the Most Romantic Restaurants in the Country, OpenTable Finds | Cleveland
As for the rest of the Buckeye state: Cincinnati received a strong shout out for its contemporary American restaurant Orchids at Palm Court, along with Restaurant L and Carlo & Johnny. Meanwhile, Columbus' French Refectory Restaurant & Bistro got that city's only mention, while Jag’s Steak & Seafood in West Chester also made the cut.
Cincinnati’s 25 Most Romantic Restaurants To Take Your Sweetheart
Carlo & Johnny is another upscale steakhouse from the team behind Jeff Ruby’s. Located in Montgomery, this restaurant is situated in a historic mansion that was formerly a gangster hideout, stagecoach stopover and casino. They offer over 14 U.S.D.A Prime steaks as well as a variety of fresh seafoods and impeccable service.
The 8 Best Steakhouses in Cincinnati
Located on the northern outskirts of Cincinnati in Montgomery, Carlo & Johnny is another steakhouse owned by Jeff Ruby that offers high quality food, excellent service, and an upscale atmosphere. Location: 9769 Montgomery Rd, Montgomery, OH 45242. Website: Carlo & Johnny
Cincinnati's 8 Best Steakhouses
Carlo & Johnny, a steakhouse owned by Jeff Ruby and located on the outskirts of Cincinnati near Montgomery, serves high-quality food, outstanding service, and an upmarket setting. Address: 9769 Montgomery Rd, Montgomery, OH 45242. Website Address: Carlo & Johnny
40 Best Restaurants in Cincinnati, OH for 2025 (Top Eats!)
9769 Montgomery RoadCincinnati, OH 45242(513) 936-8600 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Jeff Ruby’s Carlo & Johnny is a circa-1930, Chicago-style chophouse serving world-class prime steaks, fresh seafood, a raw bar, and live entertainment.
Highest-rated Restaurants in Cincinnati, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4.5 / 5 (348 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (4.0/5), Atmosphere (4.5/5)- Type of cuisine: American, Steakhouse- Price: $$$$- Address: 9769 Montgomery Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45242-7215- Read more on Tripadvisor
Best Steakhouses in Cincinnati (OH), Prime Steakhouse Cincinnati, Steak Restaurants Cincinnati
Jeff Ruby’s first restaurant, Precinct, is housed in a former police station. Meanwhile, Carlo & Johnny has found a home in a venue that’s lived many lives. The historic mansion was once a stagecoach stopover, casino and gangster hideout.
Coldwater Cafe in Tipp City makes top 10 list for Best Overall Restaurants in Dayton/Cincinnati area
Main St. in Tipp City, was spotlighted alongside nine Cincinnati-area restaurants including Nolia Kitchen, Sotto, Pepp & Dolores, BOCA, Oriental Wok - Cincinnati, Salazar, Alfio’s buon cibo, Carlo & Johnny and Wodka Bar.
Pepp & Dolores, Sotto and Carlo & Johnny listed among OpenTable's '100 Most Romantic Restaurants in America'
OpenTable named Jeff Ruby's Carlo & Johnny, Pepp & Dolores and Sotto as three restaurants on its "100 Most Romantic Restaurants in America for 2023" list.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit