Old Homestead Steak House
A legendary NYC steakhouse with a rich history, serving iconic cuts in an elegant, contemporary setting at Borgata.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Old Homestead Steak House
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A legendary NYC steakhouse with a rich history, serving iconic cuts in an elegant, contemporary setting at Borgata.
"The best steakhouse in AC. Their signature steak is out of this world!"
Book in Advance
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, as the restaurant can get quite busy.
Order the Specials
Consider trying the daily specials for fantastic steak and meat options.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Steak House
Price
$$$
Phone
(609) 317-1000
Address
Borgata Hotel, Casino & Spa, 1 Borgata Way, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Signature Steaks
Indulge in perfectly cooked, signature steaks, including the Gotham Rib steak and Porterhouse for two. A true steak lover's paradise.
Lobster Mac and Cheese
A rich and creamy indulgence, this decadent dish features tender lobster mixed with perfectly cooked macaroni.
Classic Elegance
Experience a classic and elegant ambiance with dark wood and leather booths, perfect for a sophisticated dining experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Book in Advance
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, as the restaurant can get quite busy.
Order the Specials
Consider trying the daily specials for fantastic steak and meat options.
Communicate Issues
If you encounter any service or order issues, politely express your concerns; staff are known to resolve problems.
Large Portions
Salads and side dishes are generously portioned; consider sharing.
Tips
from all over the internet
Book in Advance
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, as the restaurant can get quite busy.
Order the Specials
Consider trying the daily specials for fantastic steak and meat options.
Communicate Issues
If you encounter any service or order issues, politely express your concerns; staff are known to resolve problems.
Large Portions
Salads and side dishes are generously portioned; consider sharing.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Old Homestead Steak House is consistently praised for its exceptionally cooked steaks and classic, elegant ambiance. Diners highlight the attentive service and generous portions, making it a memorable dining experience. While most reviews are glowing, a few mention instances of slow or inattentive service and the upscale pricing.
"The best steakhouse in AC. Their signature steak, bone in ribeye, is out of this world. That was the best steakhouse I've ever had. Prime rib was awesome too. Be careful when you order salad as the portion is huge, enough for 2 people. Our servers were great, super friendly and very knowledgeable. You must try this place."
Samuel Hahn
"Loved our experience here. We didn't have reservations at prime-time hours, yet were seated immediately. They offered the option of sitting at a bar counter overlooking the kitchen, or getting put on a list. We agreed to the bar seating. It was an amazing and unique experience. We were able to watch dinners, seafood apps, and salads as they were prepared by a VERY professional staff. It was great! I ordered the rack of lamb and was not disappointed. Seriously, it was the most perfectly cooked lamb I've ever had. My guy was a bit disappointed in his pasta dish, but he doesn't like tomatoes, which were integral to the dish. I ate his tomatoes and thought the dish was great. I hope to dine here again."
L L
"Upon walking to front desk it took a moment to be noticed as what I could ascertain was an employee and her family leaving after dining . The front desk girls seemed more interested in her leaving then with us waiting . It’s a very nice steakhouse. Atmosphere was on the upscale. Decor was appealing. Tables were spaced far enough apart where it was private for each group Waiters were attentive. A nice list of wines was provided as was drink menu. All priced accordingly to the restaurants in AC so prepare for 2x the normal . We ordered the porterhouse for two ($155) and a few appetizers with a side. Steak was cooked to perfection and very nicely spiced. A side of the bernaise complimented the steak and didn’t overpower it. The sides were generous and very flavorful. The calamari was extremely fresh and very delicious. Lightly breaded and served with a side sriracha and a marinara- nice touch giving two sauce choices. The Caesar salad was huge fresh, and the dressing was on point. Saved a little room for dessert ordered the crème brûlée, which was quite delicious. The coffee came with a decanter to enjoy more than one cup without asking. And an unusual serving of sweets to stir in. A Little Rock candy stick or whole sugar cube. Nice touch. Overall a very good meal definitely will return for a great steak! A must go if in the Borgata!
Re-visit on 9/1/25 and food again on point. Service was top notch and everything was well worth the price. The steaks are top quality and cooked to perfection. Everything you could want in a great steakhouse! Dessert was very good as well. The mile high strawberry shortcake was indeed a mile high."
Sherry Jankowsky
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, the classic ambiance and excellent steaks make it a popular choice for birthdays and celebrations.
The signature steaks like the Gotham Rib and Porterhouse, as well as the Lobster Mac and Cheese, are highly recommended.
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, as the restaurant is popular.
Yes, many diners note that the portion sizes for steaks, salads, and sides are generous and can be shared.
The restaurant features a classic and elegant ambiance with dark wood and leather booths, creating a sophisticated dining experience.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
With an end in sight to the pandemic, we rediscover some of the best high-end restaurants in South Jersey | Food and Drink
Old Homestead Steak House Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa is packed with amazing, upscale restaurants, but the crown jewel is its Old Homestead Steakhouse, a classic steakhouse by menu, a modern by décor. The New York City institution is one of the country’s oldest steakhouses, serving the finest cuts in the Big Apple for about 150 years, and it took nearly that long for its owners – Marc and Greg Sherry – to expand to a second location at Borgata when it opened in 2013. Ever since, Atlantic City has never been the same as every steakhouse that has opened since has tried to replicate its success – it’s still difficult to get a table there nearly 20 years after opening.
Old Homestead Steakhouse Atlantic City Restaurant on Best Steakhouse Restaurants. 2024
The iconic steakhouse known as Old Homestead--which has been around since 1868--opened its first outpost in the Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa. Brothers Marc and Greg Sherry, whose family has been associated with the original location for decades, let Atlantic City get a taste of its fine cuts and legendary history. Complemented by sultry décor, dark wood and burgundy leather booths, Old Homestead's urban dining room and bar feels like a familiar favorite.
The Best Steakhouses in Atlantic City
Like a lot of restaurants in Atlantic City, Old Homestead started off as a New York City eatery. However, the owners (Marc and Greg Sherry) decided there were fortunes to be made on the boardwalk and opened a second Old Homestead in the Borgata Hotel, Casino & Spa. They claim that their AC menu is exactly the same as their New York menu, which is good because it will let hungry New Yorkers know what to expect when they stop by.
The Best Restaurants In Atlantic City, NJ
Also found in Borgata, Old Homestead is one of the country’s oldest steakhouses. It’s been serving irresistible steaks for nearly 150 years in NYC and Atlantic City is its second location. Relish trademarked domestically raised Wagyu beef, jumbo lump crab cakes, chicken parmesan, the Gotham rib steak, or fried calamari.
7 Atlantic City Romantic Restaurants Your Significant Other Will Love
The Old Homestead has only two locations, New York City and the Borgata Casino. The steak house was one of the first in the country and now their famous trademarked domestically raised, hand-massaged Kobe beef can be enjoyed in Atlantic City. The ambience is upscale and their prices go along with the environment.
2 Atlantic City Casino Restaurants Named Among the Best in the U.S.
Old Homestead Steak House at Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa has been serving prime-aged beef since 1868. It’s one of the longest continually operating steakhouse brands in the U.S. The Atlantic City location delivers the same commitment to quality as its original New York City counterpart.
15 Atlantic City Restaurants for a Great Meal
A classic New York steakhouse, Old Homestead is known for being the best of the best. At its Atlantic City location in the Borgata, Old Homestead continues its 150-year history of serving the finest steaks around. Service here is consistently good, and we’ve never had a bad meal.
Highest-rated Restaurants in Atlantic City, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4.0 / 5 (784 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.0/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (3.5/5), Atmosphere (4.0/5)- Type of cuisine: American, Steakhouse- Price: $$$$- Address: 1 Borgata Way The Borgata Hotel, Casino, & Spa, Atlantic City, NJ 08401-1946- Read more on Tripadvisor
The Best Steakhouses in NJ
They say every casino needs a steakhouse, and for years the Borgata had two: Bobby Flay Steak and the Old Homestead, sister to the original in Manhattan’s Meatpacking District, the oldest continuously operating steakhouse in the nation. But in 2021, Flay’s flickered out.
Things To Do in Atlantic City: Endless Fun by the Shore!
For a luxurious steak dinner with a panoramic view, the Old Homestead Steakhouse provides an unforgettable setting. If you’re in the mood for something more casual, many eateries along the Boardwalk offer beachfront seating perfect for people-watching.
Atlantic City to open Nobu; Borgata, Hard Rock get new eateries
American Bar & Grille is just the latest restaurant at Borgata to open, joining a lineup that already includes Old Homestead Steak House, Italian spot Angeline by Michael Symon and Japanese eatery Izakaya by Michael Schulson.
Bobby Flay Steak / Atlantic City - New Jersey: Dining
Has anyone eaten at both the Old Homestead and Bobby Flay’s in the Borgata?. I’ve only been to the Old Homestead and had a great steak there, but I’d like to hear from someone who can compare them to each other.
Our Listeners Pick Their Favorite Atlantic City Area Restaurants
Listeners also selected these great Atlantic City restaurants … “Hell’s Kitchen” for Beef Wellington, “Old Homestead” for Steaks, “Dock’s Oyster House” for seafood and the legendary ”Chef Vola’s.
Discover Best Atlantic City Local Dining Spots
The Old Homestead Steak House is a top spot in Atlantic City for a traditional steakhouse meal. It’s in a lively area, drawing both locals and visitors with its great food and classy feel.
Joe Kelly's 10 Favorite Atlantic City Casino Restaurants
They give you knives to cut your steak, but the meat is always so tender, I think that you could almost do without. The perfect place for a relaxing evening!
Some Of NJ's Best Steakhouses Are In Atlantic City: Report
Featured in the list are American Cut, Knife & Fork Inn, Morton's the Steakhouse and Old Homestead, all of which are in AC or have a location in AC.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit