Goodfellas Restaurant
An authentic Italian eatery renowned for generous portions, delicious pizzas, and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere with exceptional service.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Goodfellas Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
An authentic Italian eatery renowned for generous portions, delicious pizzas, and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere with exceptional service.
"The best Italian restaurant in Rotherham. The food is beautiful and soo hot, the service is welcoming and very friendly!"
Reservations Recommended
It's wise to book your table in advance as the restaurant is popular and can get quite busy.
Start with Garlic Bread
The garlic bread starter is a fresh, tasty, and highly recommended way to begin your meal.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
Mid-range
Phone
+44 1709 837373
Address
53 Sheffield Rd, Rotherham, S60 1DA, United Kingdom
Website
goodfellasrestaurant.co.uk/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Italian Flavors
Experience genuine Italian cuisine with generous portions of pizzas and pasta dishes made with love and fresh ingredients.
Warm & Welcoming Atmosphere
A family-run business with friendly, attentive staff creating a cozy and inviting ambiance perfect for any occasion.
Off-Menu Surprises
Don't be afraid to ask for off-menu delights like linguine with meatballs for a truly special and delicious experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Reservations Recommended
It's wise to book your table in advance as the restaurant is popular and can get quite busy.
Start with Garlic Bread
The garlic bread starter is a fresh, tasty, and highly recommended way to begin your meal.
Ask for Off-Menu Items
Inquire about special requests like linguine with meatballs; they're happy to accommodate.
Perfect for Celebrations
Consider Goodfellas for special occasions, group dinners, or romantic evenings.
Tips
from all over the internet
Reservations Recommended
It's wise to book your table in advance as the restaurant is popular and can get quite busy.
Start with Garlic Bread
The garlic bread starter is a fresh, tasty, and highly recommended way to begin your meal.
Ask for Off-Menu Items
Inquire about special requests like linguine with meatballs; they're happy to accommodate.
Perfect for Celebrations
Consider Goodfellas for special occasions, group dinners, or romantic evenings.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Goodfellas Restaurant is praised for its authentic Italian flavors, generous portions, and warm, family-run atmosphere. Diners often highlight the friendly service and delicious food, making it a popular spot for both casual meals and special occasions. However, a few reviews mention high prices for some dishes and a negative experience with the owner.
"My wife and I recently visited this lovely restaurant. It looked to be a family-run business. The staff were very friendly and attentive and the atmosphere was really good. The menu was not extensive but very adequate. Our food was served very hot and delicious. Overall, it was a lovely evening out and I personally would highly recommend a visit."
Solid Rock
"Been a couple of times, always booked ahead, we've had a lovely warm welcome both times. The food is quality, cooked to order & delicious. Highly recommended, lovely atmosphere & great for dining with friends or as a couple."
Deborah Senior
"The best Italian restaurant in Rotherham. The food is beautiful and soo hot, the service is welcoming and very friendly, its a family run restaurant and you really get that feeling from the atmosphere. Priced fairly its the second time we've been but certainly won't be the last. Keep doing what your doing!"
Mikey Flanaghan
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, it is recommended to make a reservation ahead of time as the restaurant can get busy.
Diners highly recommend the authentic Italian flavors, pizzas, and pasta dishes. Don't hesitate to ask for off-menu items like linguine with meatballs.
The restaurant offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, often described as family-run with friendly and attentive staff.
Yes, it's considered a great option for group dining, celebrations, and romantic meals.
Yes, diners can ask for off-menu items such as linguine with meatballs, which are prepared with pleasure.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best of 9 Mediterranean restaurants in Rotherham
Authentic Italian cuisine made with love and fresh ingredients. Indulge in the delectable symphony of flavors at Goodfellas Restaurant, where every bite transports you to the vibrant heart of Italy. Awaken your senses with an aromatic medley of freshly prepared dishes, each a testament to the culinary prowess that has made Italian cuisine a beloved masterpiece.
Ready for Rotherham? 8 Reasons to Move to Yorkshire’s Booming Town
Ranging from rustic Italian dishes at Goodfellas (the number one rated restaurant in Rotherham on TripAdvisor), authentic Thai cuisine at Chaobaby Meadowhall or traditional Yorkshire classics at The Venus Restaurant. There really is something for everyone and no excuse to not try something new!
THE 30 BEST Restaurants in Rotherham
This restaurant is situated in an unfashionable area in an unfashionable town. The food is Italian, the head waiter is Pakistani, the waitresses are Yorkshire/sicilian or Yorkshire/Maltese. You are right, it’s an absolute melting pot that weirdly gives off a family vibe.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit