Mariner Pizza
A long-standing pizza institution known for its classic pies with fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and a beloved cinnamon stick dessert.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Mariner Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A long-standing pizza institution known for its classic pies with fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and a beloved cinnamon stick dessert.
"The best pizza in all of BC! I still always order from Mariner’s every time I’m on the island."
Order Online for Discounts
Take advantage of 10% off for pick-up orders when you order through their convenient online system.
Hawaiian Supreme or Mexicana
Highly recommended by reviewers for those looking for a flavorful and satisfying pizza choice.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
The Classic House Special Pizza
A local legend for decades, featuring fresh dough, homemade sauce, and quality toppings that have delighted generations.
Seamless Online Ordering & Pickup Deals
Enjoy a hassle-free online ordering experience with convenient pickup options and exclusive discounts.
Cinnamon Sticks Dessert
A sweet and cinnamony treat that's the perfect way to end your pizza feast.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Order Online for Discounts
Take advantage of 10% off for pick-up orders when you order through their convenient online system.
Hawaiian Supreme or Mexicana
Highly recommended by reviewers for those looking for a flavorful and satisfying pizza choice.
Beware of Parking
Parking can be very limited, so consider picking up your order if space is a concern.
Peak Hour Patience
Expect potential delays during busy times, but reviewers agree the delicious pizza is worth the wait.
Tips
from all over the internet
Order Online for Discounts
Take advantage of 10% off for pick-up orders when you order through their convenient online system.
Hawaiian Supreme or Mexicana
Highly recommended by reviewers for those looking for a flavorful and satisfying pizza choice.
Beware of Parking
Parking can be very limited, so consider picking up your order if space is a concern.
Peak Hour Patience
Expect potential delays during busy times, but reviewers agree the delicious pizza is worth the wait.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Mariner Pizza has been a beloved local institution for decades, lauded for its delicious, generously topped pizzas made with quality ingredients and a fantastic crust. While the food consistently receives high praise, some reviewers note that the restaurant's ambiance and facilities could use an update. Despite this, the friendly service and the long-standing reputation for great pizza keep customers returning.
"Mariner Pizza has been a Sidney institution for as long as I can remember. The best pizza in all of BC! I live on the mainland now but still always order from Mariner’s every time I’m on the island. The House Special is exactly what a good pizza should be. Mexicana Supremo is also highly recommended if you like things a little on the spicy side"
Cam
"Great flavor, properly assembled with plenty of toppings and baked perfect. Couldn't ask for a better pie. We regularly order pizzas when my family is visiting my parents in Sidney and it's actually better than any pizza n Vancouver. Price is incredible as well!"
Jeremy Gawryluk
"On out way out to the ferry we stopped to grab some pizza in Sydney. We ordered online from Mariner. The online ordering website was great. Very smooth and easy checkout process. You can pay online or pay when you pick up your order. You can choose a pick up time online as well. Pick up orders get 10% off. We ordered the house pizza with regular crust. Pizza was ready upon pickup and was done to perfection. Veggies were fresh and pizza wasn't too greasy or overly salty. Definitely would go back and try it their other pizzas and lasagna."
Kandoo Ooo
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Mariner Pizza is celebrated for its delicious pizzas made with fresh dough, homemade sauce, and quality toppings, a tradition upheld for decades.
Yes, customers can enjoy a 10% discount on pick-up orders when they place their order online.
The House Special, Hawaiian Supreme, and Mexicana Supremo are frequently recommended by reviewers.
Parking can be very limited, especially during peak hours, so picking up your order might be more convenient.
Don't miss the cinnamon sticks, which are a popular and sweet way to end your meal.
Absolutely! Mariner Pizza offers a 'create your own' option with a wide variety of toppings to choose from.
The restaurant is open late, with some mentions indicating they are open until 2 AM, making it a great late-night option.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Walk-ins Welcome! Best Restaurants in Sidney, BC
For twenty years, Mariner has been offering customers delicious, quality pizza made with fresh pizza dough, homemade sauce, and high quality toppings!. With so many flavour combos, it’s no wonder why this pizza spot has such a loyal customer base!. So come and try one of their specialty pizzas or make your own but be sure to order the cinnamon sticks for dessert!
The Best Restaurants in Sidney, B.C.
This style of pizza is similar to pizza chains, except the quality level has been boosted way up. Their menu contains specialty pizzas as well as the option to create your own based on your favourite toppings. Prices are fair, staff are friendly, and service is fast, even on busy nights.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit