Old City BBQ
Laid-back Williamsburg spot serving nose-to-tail BBQ with hearty sides and a friendly vibe. A must-try for meat lovers!
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Freshly smoked meats
Old City BBQ
Best Time
Freshly smoked meats
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Laid-back Williamsburg spot serving nose-to-tail BBQ with hearty sides and a friendly vibe. A must-try for meat lovers!
"This place was recommended to me by several locals… and I am so glad. Wow. I love a good BBQ joint!"
🤤 Must-Try Meats
Don't miss the pulled pork and brisket, often cited as the best in Williamsburg!
🌶️ Sauce Exploration
Try the different sauces – Tidewater and vinegar offer a nice contrast to the sweet main sauce.
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Smoked Brisket
Tender, flavorful brisket that melts in your mouth. A true BBQ classic done right.
Pulled Pork
Juicy, slow-smoked pulled pork, a staple for any BBQ enthusiast.
Poblano Mac & Cheese
Creamy mac and cheese with a hint of poblano pepper for a unique kick.
Burnt Ends BLT
A decadent sandwich featuring flavorful burnt ends, a must-try for meat lovers.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Planning Your Visit
Embrace the Smoke
Sauce Savvy
Best Times
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
🤤 Must-Try Meats
Don't miss the pulled pork and brisket, often cited as the best in Williamsburg! +1
🌶️ Sauce Exploration
Try the different sauces – Tidewater and vinegar offer a nice contrast to the sweet main sauce.
💯 Local Recommendation
Locals highly recommend this spot for authentic BBQ and great service.
💰 Value for Money
Generous portions make it a good value, though some find it a bit pricey.
Tips
from all over the internet
🤤 Must-Try Meats
Don't miss the pulled pork and brisket, often cited as the best in Williamsburg! +1
🌶️ Sauce Exploration
Try the different sauces – Tidewater and vinegar offer a nice contrast to the sweet main sauce.
💯 Local Recommendation
Locals highly recommend this spot for authentic BBQ and great service.
💰 Value for Money
Generous portions make it a good value, though some find it a bit pricey.
💨 Wood Smoke Aroma
You'll smell the delicious wood smoke before you even walk in!
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Old City BBQ is a highly recommended spot in Williamsburg for its delicious, generously portioned BBQ and friendly service. While some find the main sauce a bit too sweet and the pricing slightly high with added fees, the overall experience is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the tender meats and flavorful sides. It's a solid choice for a satisfying and casual dining experience.
"We were at the rec center across the street for some basketball games. Had a break in between games. We could smell and see the wood smoke coming from the restaurant. Upon walking in I was pleasantly surprised. Nice bar and dining area with also outside seating. Our waitress was absolutely amazing! Personable and knowledgeable. Seemed to enjoy her job. Some of the best baked beans I've had. Fries were great and seasoned well with a good crisp. My girlfriend was making mmmm sounds as she bit into the blt with burnt ends. We will definitely be back to try more selection of meats and sides."
Brian Price
"This place was recommended to me by several locals… and I am so glad. Wow. I love a good BBQ joint and I love pork belly, when it’s cooked correctly. Here it was cooked and seasoned to perfection. Beyond that the sides were delicious. The service was awesome. I’m a huge fan of the food and the people."
Mary DeMasters
"Server was great and friendly. Helped me accidentally order off the secret menu. It was a touch pricey but that’s kind of just the way BBQ Joints are going these days.
The sauces on the table were pretty good. The main sauce is realllllly sweet for a bbq sauce but the tidewater had a nice mustard kick and the vinegar sauce was standard in a good way."
Jack Honaker
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
🚇 🗺️ Getting There
Old City BBQ is conveniently located in Williamsburg, VA. It's easily accessible by car and is within walking distance of some local attractions and accommodations.
Yes, parking is generally available at Old City BBQ, though it can get busy during peak hours.
Information on public transport routes to Old City BBQ can be limited. Driving or ride-sharing services are often the most reliable options.
Absolutely! It's right across the street from the rec center, making it a perfect spot for a meal during breaks.
Old City BBQ is situated in Williamsburg, Virginia, often mentioned in the 757 area code. +1
🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry
No, Old City BBQ is a restaurant, not an attraction requiring tickets. You simply order and pay for your food.
Opening hours can vary, but it's generally open for lunch and dinner. It's best to check their official website or social media for the most up-to-date hours.
There is no dress code. Old City BBQ has a laid-back, casual atmosphere, so come as you are!
Reservations are typically not required, as it's a casual dining establishment. However, for larger groups, it's always a good idea to call ahead.
Yes, Old City BBQ offers outdoor seating options, perfect for enjoying your meal on a nice day.
🍽️ 🍽️ Food & Dining
Visitors highly recommend the smoked brisket, pulled pork, and the poblano mac & cheese. The BLT with burnt ends is also a standout. +3
They offer a variety of sauces, including a sweet main sauce, a mustard-based Tidewater sauce, and a classic vinegar sauce.
Yes, the portions are generally considered generous, offering good value for the quality and quantity of food.
Some reviews suggest the meats might be more oven-roasted than traditionally smoked, lacking a deep smoky flavor for some palates.
Popular sides include baked beans, fries (seasoned well), cornbread (soft and cake-like), and fried Brussels sprouts. +1
📸 📸 Photography
Capture the mouth-watering BBQ platters, the rustic interior, and the vibrant sauces. The outdoor seating area can also offer nice shots. +1
Definitely! The colorful sides and generously portioned meats make for excellent food photography. +1
Yes, you're welcome to take photos inside the restaurant to capture your dining experience.
The 4-meat platter, the poblano mac & cheese, and any dish featuring their signature brisket or pulled pork are highly photogenic. +1
The restaurant has a modern, rustic interior with good lighting, suitable for casual photography.
For Different Travelers
Tailored advice for your travel style
👨👩👧 Families with Kids
While the main BBQ sauce is sweet, it's generally well-liked by kids.
💰 Budget Travelers
Consider visiting during lunch hours when the atmosphere might be slightly less busy, potentially leading to quicker service.
Deep Dives
In-depth insights and expert knowledge
The Art of BBQ at Old City
TikTok creators often highlight the generous portions and the visual appeal of the smoked meats, with videos showcasing platters piled high with brisket and pulled pork.
When it comes to the sauces, Old City BBQ offers a spectrum of flavors. The main BBQ sauce is described as quite sweet, which appeals to some but might be too much for others. However, the Tidewater sauce (a mustard-based option) and the vinegar sauce provide excellent alternatives for those who prefer a tangier or spicier profile.
Navigating the Menu and Value
However, some patrons have noted that the overall cost can add up, especially with additional taxes and surcharges.
Despite these minor concerns, the overall sentiment is positive, with many visitors praising the friendly service and the deliciousness of the food.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit