Piece A Cake
A bright, industrial cafe on Staten Island serving delicious cakes, cookies, sandwiches, and coffee with a touch of New York history.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Enjoy breakfast with friendly service
Piece A Cake
Best Time
Enjoy breakfast with friendly service
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A bright, industrial cafe on Staten Island serving delicious cakes, cookies, sandwiches, and coffee with a touch of New York history.
"Praised for delicious coffee and amazing strawberry cake, it's a Staten Island gem with friendly service."
⚠️ Beware of Moving Scams
TikToks warn of 'Piece of Cake' moving scams. Research thoroughly and be cautious of hidden fees.
🍰 Confirm Custom Cake Designs
Reviews mention custom cakes not matching website photos. Confirm details for important events.
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
Crispy, flavorful cookies that are a standout treat. A must-try for cookie lovers!
Italian Egg Sandwich
A delicious breakfast option with a runny fried egg, pesto, and ricotta on a croissant.
Strawberry Cake
Praised for its fresh, rich, and perfectly balanced flavor with a moist texture.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Planning Your Visit
Moving Scams to Watch Out For
Cake Orders: Manage Expectations
Best Times
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
⚠️ Beware of Moving Scams
TikToks warn of 'Piece of Cake' moving scams. Research thoroughly and be cautious of hidden fees. +2
🍰 Confirm Custom Cake Designs
Reviews mention custom cakes not matching website photos. Confirm details for important events.
☕ Delicious Coffee & OJ
Enjoy their coffee and freshly squeezed orange juice, highly recommended by patrons.
🍪 Standout Cookies
White chocolate macadamia nut cookies are a must-try, earning rave reviews.
My first attempt at baking and frosting a layered cake... I could definitely use some tips 😅
Tips
from all over the internet
⚠️ Beware of Moving Scams
TikToks warn of 'Piece of Cake' moving scams. Research thoroughly and be cautious of hidden fees. +2
🍰 Confirm Custom Cake Designs
Reviews mention custom cakes not matching website photos. Confirm details for important events.
☕ Delicious Coffee & OJ
Enjoy their coffee and freshly squeezed orange juice, highly recommended by patrons.
🍪 Standout Cookies
White chocolate macadamia nut cookies are a must-try, earning rave reviews.
🍳 Great Breakfast Options
The Italian Egg Sandwich and zucchini frittata are delicious and satisfying.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Piece A Cake receives mixed reviews. While many praise their delicious coffee, fresh juices, and standout baked goods like the strawberry cake and white chocolate macadamia nut cookies, some customers have had negative experiences with sandwiches and custom cake orders not meeting expectations. The friendly service is a consistent positive point.
"Extremely disappointed. I went by others people reviews, only to find a sandwich with tiny pieces of sausage thrown in with feta cheese and ricotta cheese not melted so that the sausage and cheese rolled out. Extremely salty which I knew due to the sausage and cheese however they just threw it in the bread
Their coffee was delicious as well as their freshly squeezed orange juice, but i wouldn't order again. Their home fries were basic with not much taste but pepper."
Rashonda
"this has to be the worst bait and switch. ordered a pistachio cake for a birthday and it came completely different from what piece of cake has posted on the website. it looks like slimer threw up on it and it tasted similar with this gelled nickelodeon slime on it. definitely not trusting them with another important event unless its a kids Minecraft party."
devon
"I decided to try this place as I live pretty close by and a neighbor of mine was talking it up. Absolutely delicious and staff was so friendly. My knee is not good and they made something that is usually a hassle enjoyable and easy. Allie which is one of the workers was helpful and nice making this an overall 10/10 experience. Food was great (i got the zucchini frittata). Wish I took some pictures but It was so delicious I couldn’t put it down."
Misa Amane
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
🚇 🗺️ Getting There
Piece A Cake is located at 177 New Dorp Lane in Staten Island. The bakery is accessible by car, and reviews mention ample parking available.
While specific public transport routes aren't detailed in reviews, Staten Island has bus services. Checking local transit apps for routes to New Dorp Lane is recommended.
Reviews indicate that there is ample parking available at the bakery, making it convenient for visitors arriving by car.
Delivery options are not explicitly mentioned in the provided reviews or social media content. It's best to contact the bakery directly to inquire about delivery services.
TikTok videos mention Piece of Cake trucks in New York, Miami, and LA, suggesting a larger company. However, the bakery reviews specifically refer to the Staten Island location at 177 New Dorp Lane.
🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry
Piece A Cake operates daily from 8 AM to 8 PM, offering a convenient window for breakfast, lunch, or dessert.
No tickets are required to visit Piece A Cake. It is a counter-serve cafe and bakery, so you can walk in and order.
There is no admission fee to enter Piece A Cake. You pay for the food and drinks you order.
Reservations are typically not needed for a counter-serve cafe. For custom cake orders, it's advisable to contact them in advance to discuss your needs.
Prices are not detailed, but reviews suggest a range from delicious coffee and pastries to full sandwiches and custom cakes. Expect typical cafe pricing.
🎫 🍰 Cakes & Desserts
Piece A Cake offers a variety of cakes, including strawberry cake and pistachio cake. They also have cookies, cannoli, and zeppole.
Yes, custom cakes can be ordered, but be aware that reviews suggest they may not always match website photos. Confirm design details carefully.
One reviewer described the strawberry cake as 'perfectly balanced — not too sweet, just right.' However, sweetness can vary by cake type.
The white chocolate macadamia nut cookies and strawberry cake are highly praised. Italian pastries like cannoli and zeppole are also recommended.
One customer reported a significant discrepancy between a custom cake ordered and its appearance, describing it as 'slimer threw up on it.' It's crucial to have detailed discussions and possibly visual confirmations for important events.
🍽️ 🍽️ Food & Dining
Piece A Cake offers sandwiches, cookies, and a breakfast menu. Popular items include the Italian Egg Sandwich and zucchini frittata.
One review was highly disappointed with a sandwich, describing it as 'extremely salty' with ingredients not properly melted. Another reviewer enjoyed their zucchini frittata.
The coffee is described as delicious, and their freshly squeezed orange juice is also a highlight.
Home fries are described as basic with not much taste beyond pepper.
Yes, Piece A Cake is recommended for breakfast, with the Italian Egg Sandwich and zucchini frittata being popular choices.
📸 📸 Photography
The bakery has a bright, industrial space and a nostalgic ambiance, with decor reminiscent of "Lunch atop a Skyscraper." This could make for interesting photos.
The beautifully presented cakes and pastries, the unique decor, and the vibrant coffee and juices would make for great photo opportunities.
There are no restrictions mentioned regarding photography inside the cafe. Visitors are encouraged to capture their delicious food.
The 'Lunch atop a Skyscraper' inspired decor might serve as a unique backdrop for photos. The display of cakes and pastries is also visually appealing.
A smartphone with good low-light capabilities would be sufficient for capturing the ambiance and food. Natural light from the bright space will be helpful.
For Different Travelers
Tailored advice for your travel style
👨👩👧 Families with Kids
For a satisfying breakfast or snack, consider the Italian Egg Sandwich or their delicious cookies. If ordering a custom cake for a child's party, be sure to have very clear discussions about the design to avoid disappointment, as one review noted a significant mismatch with a custom order.
💰 Budget Travelers
For a more substantial meal, the sandwiches and breakfast items are available. However, one review found a sandwich to be overly salty and disappointing, so individual experiences may vary. Custom cakes are likely to be the most expensive items on the menu.
couples
The nostalgic ambiance, inspired by historical New York imagery, adds a unique touch to a casual outing. Consider trying their Italian pastries or a breakfast sandwich together for a delightful start to the day.
Deep Dives
In-depth insights and expert knowledge
Navigating Moving Company Red Flags
It's crucial to be vigilant when hiring any moving company. Look for companies with transparent pricing, clear contracts, and a solid reputation. Avoid those that demand large upfront payments, have vague estimates, or pressure you into tipping. Always read recent reviews from multiple sources and be prepared to walk away if something feels off. The 'piece of cake' moving experience often turns into a nightmare for unsuspecting customers.
Custom Cake Ordering: What to Expect
For important events, it's highly recommended to have detailed conversations with the bakery about the design, ingredients, and expected outcome. Requesting visual confirmations or mock-ups can help ensure the final product aligns with your vision. While the bakery is praised for its friendly service and delicious cookies and pastries,
A Taste of Staten Island History and Flavor
The menu features a delightful mix of classic bakery items and hearty breakfast options. Their white chocolate macadamia nut cookies are a standout, alongside authentic Italian pastries like cannoli and zeppole. For breakfast, the Italian Egg Sandwich, a flavorful combination of egg, pesto, and ricotta on a croissant, is a local favorite.
With convenient daily hours from 8 AM to 8 PM and ample parking, Piece A Cake serves as a welcoming spot for both locals and visitors looking for delicious food and a touch of history. It's a place where community members and food enthusiasts can gather and enjoy quality treats.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit