The Gray Mare - Image 1
1 / 3

The Gray Mare

4.5
·405 reviews·New York, United States

A vibrant East Village pub offering delicious American bar plates, creative cocktails, and lively entertainment like live music.

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Weekends, early evening

Lively atmosphere, live music

CrowdMedium
Loading map...
The Gray Mare - Image 1

The Gray Mare

Best Time

Weekends, early evening

Lively atmosphere, live music

CrowdMedium

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A vibrant East Village pub offering delicious American bar plates, creative cocktails, and lively entertainment like live music.

4.5
(405 reviews)

"Amazing service, food, and drinks. Can’t recommend this place enough!"

Vertical photo
TIP

🎯 Frozen Cocktail Alert!

Score all-day happy hour on frozen cocktails when it's 89°F+! :cocktail:

🎶 Live Music Vibes

Check for live music, especially Sunday sessions for a chill vibe. :musical_note:

Third hero image

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Frozen Cocktail Happy Hour

Frozen Cocktail Happy Hour

Bar Area

Beat the heat with all-day happy hour on frozen cocktails when temps soar above 89°F!

Instagram
Rustic Pub Ambiance

Rustic Pub Ambiance

Main Dining Area

Enjoy a laid-back vibe with rustic decor, perfect for casual nights out or date nights.

Reddit
Live Music Sessions

Live Music Sessions

Main Stage/Bar Area

Catch smooth jazz and other live performances, especially on Sundays.

Instagram
Delicious Bar Plates

Delicious Bar Plates

Dining Tables

Don't miss the highly recommended mac and cheese, birria tacos, and wings.

Reddit
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Planning Your Visit

Beat the Crowds for Happy Hour

The Gray Mare is known for its lively atmosphere, especially during happy hour. Arrive early, particularly on weekends, to snag a good spot. They offer all-day happy hour on frozen cocktails when temperatures hit 89 degrees or higher, so keep an eye on the weather! Instagram

Reservations & Group Events

While walk-ins are welcome, consider reservations for larger groups or if you're planning a special occasion. The back room is a popular spot for private events, and booking in advance is recommended to secure your date. Reddit

Best Times

When
Weekends, early evening
Why
Lively atmosphere, live music
Crowd
Medium
When
Weekdays, during happy hour
Why
Great deals on drinks
Crowd
Low
When
Hot summer days (89°F+)
Why
All-day frozen cocktail happy hour
Crowd
High

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

The new summer cocktail menu is almost here at The Gray Mare Stay tuned for updates… 🍸 • • • • #nychappyhour #nyccocktails #coctails #ev #eastvillagenyc #summer #fyp #explorepage #nyc
thegraymarenyc
19 likes • 848 views

🎯 Frozen Cocktail Alert!

Score all-day happy hour on frozen cocktails when it's 89°F+! Instagram :cocktail:

🎶 Live Music Vibes

Check for live music, especially Sunday sessions for a chill vibe. Instagram :musical_note:

🍹 Pina Colada 📍 The Gray Mare ( @thegraymarenyc ) | 61 2nd Ave East Village NY NY . . The Gray Mare is celebrating the arrival of summer and any time the temperature surpasses 89 degrees, they will offer all day happy hour on frozen cocktails! Check out one my favorite East Village Pubs today!
tameekaeats
202 likes • 2.4K views
Smooth jazz times in the Old Grey Mare this bank holiday Sunday 😎 Grab a pint, pull up and chair and come chill with us! @thejazzvilleduo #livemusic #livemusicinyork #bankholidayvibes #sundaysessions
oldgreymare.york
34 likes • 2.1K views

🧀 Must-Try Mac & Cheese

This dish is a crowd-pleaser and highly recommended by visitors. Reddit :cheese_wedge:

🗣️ Music Volume

Be aware that music can be loud inside, so be prepared to raise your voice. Reddit :speaker:

“The Old Gray Mare ain’t what she used to be!!!” Lol! Follow @evangelistmikedyal
evangelistmikedyal
1 likes • 67 views

Tips

from all over the internet

🎯 Frozen Cocktail Alert!

Score all-day happy hour on frozen cocktails when it's 89°F+! Instagram :cocktail:

🎶 Live Music Vibes

Check for live music, especially Sunday sessions for a chill vibe. Instagram :musical_note:

🧀 Must-Try Mac & Cheese

This dish is a crowd-pleaser and highly recommended by visitors. Reddit :cheese_wedge:

🗣️ Music Volume

Be aware that music can be loud inside, so be prepared to raise your voice. Reddit :speaker:

✨ Great for Groups

The space is great for parties and celebrations, with a lively atmosphere. Reddit :confetti_ball:

What Travellers Say

4.5
(405 reviews)

Reviews Summary

The Gray Mare is a highly-rated East Village pub praised for its lively atmosphere, delicious food, and creative cocktails. Visitors rave about the friendly service, especially from staff like Hailey and Alesha, and the fun vibe, often enhanced by live music. While generally positive, some guests have encountered rude management and slow service during peak times.

"My brother and I came here tonight with our cousins to celebrate our birthday. We had such a fun time in the front of the bar and then in the back room. Beautiful space. The food was amazing. I highly recommend the mac and cheese. The drinks were fantastic. They even had non alcoholic beers. Our waitress Hailey was the best. She was really sweet and attentive to all of us. Thank you so much for having us. We'll be back! 🤗"

Jonathan R.

"Amazing service, food, and drinks. Can’t recommend this place enough. Alesha (Elisha) is a gem, give her a raise. She let us watch F1 and was super attentive to your group. So thankful to have found this great spot in NYC!"

Malvina Gasco

"Upon entering this establishment on a Friday night, the buzz and excitement was immediately tangible. Playing mid 2000’s hits like Mr. Brightside kept the mood light and expectant.

This bar-restaurant I imagine would be great for a date night or just fun evening with friends.

I ordered the delicious birria tacos and wings. Both were gluten free. Music is a bit loud inside, so had to raise my voice for anyone to hear me. The bartender was very friendly."

Jasmine Mitchell

What People Like

Friendly and attentive staff
Delicious food and cocktails
Lively atmosphere and live music

What People Dislike

Rude management experiences
Slow service at times

Frequently Asked Questions

🚇 🗺️ Getting There

The Gray Mare is located at 61 2nd Ave in the East Village, NYC. It's accessible via several subway lines, including the L train to First Avenue or the N, Q, R, W, J, Z, 4, 5, 6 trains to the Canal Street or Prince Street stations, followed by a short walk. Instagram

Street parking in the East Village can be challenging. It's often easier to use public transportation or ride-sharing services. There are also parking garages in the vicinity, but they can be pricey.

For events like watching Michigan football games, the subway is highly recommended. It avoids traffic and parking hassles, allowing you to get to the bar quickly. Reddit

🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry

No, tickets are not typically required for general entry to The Gray Mare. It operates as a bar and restaurant. However, for private events or special ticketed performances, arrangements may differ. Reddit

Opening hours can vary, especially for happy hour specials. It's best to check their social media or website for the most up-to-date information, particularly for their summer frozen cocktail happy hour. Instagram

Yes, reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups or if you're planning a special occasion. The back room is available for private events. Reddit

Generally, there is no cover charge for regular entry. However, for specific live music events or private parties, there might be associated costs. Instagram

As a bar and restaurant, patrons must be 21 years or older to consume alcohol. Valid identification will be required.

🎫 🧭 Onsite Experience

The Gray Mare offers a laid-back pub setting with rustic decor. It's known for its lively buzz, especially on weekends, and can be a great spot for dates or nights out with friends. Reddit

Yes, The Gray Mare is a popular spot for watching sports, with patrons mentioning they've watched F1 and other games there. They are accommodating to sports fans. Reddit

Yes, The Gray Mare often features live music, including smooth jazz sessions, particularly on Sundays. Instagram

The music inside can be quite loud, especially during peak hours or live performances, so be prepared to raise your voice if you're in a group. Reddit

Yes, The Gray Mare offers non-alcoholic beer options, making it a good choice for those who prefer not to drink alcohol. Reddit

🍽️ 🍽️ Food & Dining

The Gray Mare serves American bar plates. Popular recommendations include the mac and cheese, birria tacos, and wings. They also offer gluten-free options. Reddit

Yes, The Gray Mare offers gluten-free options, with birria tacos and wings specifically mentioned as being gluten-free. Reddit

The mac and cheese is frequently highlighted as a must-try dish. The birria tacos and wings are also highly recommended. Reddit

Yes, The Gray Mare is a bar and restaurant, so you can order drinks at the bar without necessarily ordering food, though their food is well-regarded. Reddit

Prices are typical for a New York City bar and restaurant, with appetizers and main dishes falling into a moderate range. Specific pricing can be found on their menu.

📸 📸 Photography

The rustic decor and lively atmosphere provide great photo opportunities. The bar area, especially during happy hour or live music, and the food presentations are popular subjects. Instagram

Generally, yes. Patrons often share photos of their food, drinks, and the ambiance. However, be mindful of other guests' privacy and avoid intrusive photography, especially during busy times. Instagram

The bar itself, with its rustic charm, and the beautifully presented cocktails and dishes are popular for Instagram shots. The overall ambiance also makes for great lifestyle photos. Instagram

If you are attending a private event, photography is usually permitted, but it's always best to confirm with the event organizer or venue staff if you have any doubts.

The lighting is generally warm and inviting, creating a cozy pub atmosphere. It's suitable for most photography, though low-light conditions might require flash or a camera with good low-light performance.

For Different Travelers

Tailored advice for your travel style

👨‍👩‍👧 Families with Kids

The Gray Mare can be a good option for families, especially during earlier hours or for those looking for a casual meal. They offer non-alcoholic beer options, which is a plus for parents who prefer not to drink. Reddit The food menu features crowd-pleasers like mac and cheese and wings, which are generally kid-friendly. Reddit

However, be mindful that the atmosphere can become quite lively and the music volume can be high, particularly in the evenings and on weekends. Reddit It might be best suited for families with older children or those who don't mind a more energetic environment. Consider visiting earlier in the day or on a weekday to ensure a more relaxed experience.

💰 Budget Travelers

For budget-conscious travelers, The Gray Mare shines during its happy hour specials. They are particularly known for offering all-day happy hour on frozen cocktails when temperatures reach 89°F or higher, providing a great way to enjoy unique drinks at a lower price. Instagram This is a fantastic opportunity to experience their cocktail offerings without breaking the bank. Instagram

While food prices are typical for NYC, focusing on happy hour deals for drinks and perhaps sharing appetizers can help manage costs. The gluten-free options like wings and tacos can also be a good value. Reddit Opting for weekday visits over weekends can also sometimes lead to a more relaxed and potentially less expensive experience, though happy hour deals are often consistent.

👫 Couples

The Gray Mare offers a charming and lively setting that can be perfect for a date night. The rustic decor and cozy pub atmosphere create an intimate yet fun environment. Reddit You can enjoy delicious American bar plates, like the highly recommended mac and cheese, and explore their creative cocktail menu. Reddit

Consider visiting during a live music session for an added touch of romance and entertainment. Instagram The option to watch sports also adds a casual, shared activity element if that's something you both enjoy. Reddit The attentive service, as noted by many reviewers, ensures a pleasant and memorable experience for couples looking for a vibrant night out in the East Village.

Deep Dives

In-depth insights and expert knowledge

The Gray Mare's Cocktail Culture

The Gray Mare is a destination for cocktail enthusiasts, with a focus on both classic and innovative drinks. Their summer cocktail menu often features refreshing options, and they are particularly known for their frozen cocktails. Instagram During hot weather, when temperatures exceed 89 degrees Fahrenheit, they offer an all-day happy hour on these frozen concoctions, making it a prime spot to cool down and enjoy a unique drink special. Instagram

Beyond the seasonal specials, the bar staff is praised for their attentiveness and skill. Whether you're looking for a non-alcoholic option or a perfectly crafted classic, the bartenders are noted for their friendly service and ability to cater to diverse preferences. Reddit The mid-2000s hits often playing in the background add to the fun, relaxed vibe, making it a great place to socialize over drinks. Reddit

For those interested in the bar's offerings, keeping an eye on their social media is key. They often tease new menu items and specials, ensuring patrons are always in the loop about the latest drink creations. Instagram

A Culinary Haven in the East Village

The Gray Mare offers a satisfying menu of American bar plates that have garnered significant praise from visitors. Among the standout dishes, the mac and cheese is frequently cited as a must-try, lauded for its deliciousness and comforting qualities. Reddit Other popular choices include birria tacos and wings, which are noted for being flavorful and, importantly, available as gluten-free options, catering to a wider range of dietary needs. Reddit

The culinary experience at The Gray Mare is often described as a highlight of the visit, contributing to its reputation as a great spot for a fun evening with friends or even a date night. Reddit The quality of the food, combined with the lively atmosphere and attentive service, makes it a well-rounded dining destination. Even when hosting private events, the food quality remains a consistent positive point. Reddit

While the music inside can be loud, the food itself is consistently well-received, making it a worthwhile stop for anyone looking for hearty and tasty bar fare in the East Village. Reddit

The Gray Mare: A Hub for Entertainment

Beyond its food and drinks, The Gray Mare cultivates a vibrant entertainment scene. The establishment frequently hosts live music, creating an engaging atmosphere for patrons. Smooth jazz sessions, particularly on Sunday afternoons, are a recurring feature, offering a relaxed yet sophisticated vibe. Instagram This makes it an appealing destination for those looking to unwind with good music and company. Instagram

The bar also serves as a popular spot for watching live sports. Visitors have noted their positive experiences watching events like Formula 1 races there, appreciating the accommodating staff who allow patrons to tune into their preferred games. Reddit This dual focus on live music and sports viewing positions The Gray Mare as a versatile venue catering to diverse entertainment preferences. Reddit

The overall ambiance, often enhanced by a soundtrack of mid-2000s hits, contributes to a lively and enjoyable experience. Reddit Whether you're there for a birthday celebration, a casual night out, or to catch a game, the entertainment options add significant value to a visit. Reddit