Molly's Shebeen
A classic Irish pub with sawdust floors, a fireplace, and authentic cultural touches. Serves hearty comfort food and perfectly poured pints.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Fewer crowds, more relaxed vibe
Molly's Shebeen
Best Time
Fewer crowds, more relaxed vibe
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A classic Irish pub with sawdust floors, a fireplace, and authentic cultural touches. Serves hearty comfort food and perfectly poured pints.
"A true gem and a delightful throwback to a bygone era!"
🎯 Get there early for a table
Popular spot! Arrive before peak hours to snag a table, especially on weekends.
🍺 Perfect Guinness pour
Known for their excellent Guinness. It's a must-try for any stout lover.
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Shepherd's Pie
A hearty, comforting classic with tender beef, savory gravy, and perfectly cooked vegetables. Hits the spot on a rainy day.
Fish and Chips
Crispy, golden batter encases moist, tender fish. Served with delicious tartar sauce for a satisfying meal.
Guinness Pour
Experience a perfectly poured pint of Guinness with a flawless creamy head. A true delight for beer enthusiasts.
Irish Spice Bag
A flavorful and filling dish that perfectly complements a few pints of beer. A local favorite for a reason.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Planning Your Visit
Authentic Irish Ambiance
Timing is Key for Tables
Best Times
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
🎯 Get there early for a table
Popular spot! Arrive before peak hours to snag a table, especially on weekends.
🍺 Perfect Guinness pour
Known for their excellent Guinness. It's a must-try for any stout lover.
Does anyone know if Red Hook Tavern has a good Guiness pour?
St Patrick’s day
🍲 Hearty comfort food
Shepherd's Pie and Sausage with Mash are highly recommended for a filling meal.
🎶 Nostalgic music vibe
Enjoy 70s & 80s tunes that add to the cozy, lively ambiance.
Wine and good times
Tips
from all over the internet
🎯 Get there early for a table
Popular spot! Arrive before peak hours to snag a table, especially on weekends.
🍺 Perfect Guinness pour
Known for their excellent Guinness. It's a must-try for any stout lover.
🍲 Hearty comfort food
Shepherd's Pie and Sausage with Mash are highly recommended for a filling meal.
🎶 Nostalgic music vibe
Enjoy 70s & 80s tunes that add to the cozy, lively ambiance.
🌶️ Try the English Mustard
Don't miss this bold, tangy condiment that elevates many dishes.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Molly's Shebeen is lauded as a classic Irish pub offering an authentic, cozy experience with a wood-burning fireplace and sawdust floors. Visitors rave about the hearty, delicious food, particularly the Shepherd's Pie and Fish and Chips, and the perfectly poured Guinness. While some found wing portions disappointing, the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the great atmosphere and friendly, often Irish, staff.
"Great Irish Pub in NYC! I was in town for a work event and I had a day off. As a player of Irish Sports, I wanted to visit a great Irish Pub in NYC and the reviews on Reddit all pointed to Molly Shebeen's. After a stroll through Madison Park, I made it to Molly's and was greeted with a smile from the bartender.
I ordered a Guinness to start and it came out cold and quick. I looked at the menu and because of the rainy day, Shepherd's Pie seemed like the ticket. My food came out in less than 10 minutes and it was hot (the bartender warned me). It was delicious and hit the spot. No BS ingredients, hearty vegetables, good size chunks of ground beef, and very delicious.
I also appreciated all the Gaelic sport photos and Irish Cultural items on the walls, and not a bunch of green shamrocks and leprechauns.
Thank you for the Guinness, the Shepherd's Pie, and Slainte!"
Jared DeValk
"Yum! A great spot for comfort food and drinks that's open pretty late! The atmosphere is cozy and has pretty lighting, and there's both a bar and separate tables. The kitchen seems like it closes at 12am, so do keep that in mind (the bar is open quite a bit later).
I got the sausage with mashed potatoes and gravy and it was delicious! The gravy was rich and flavorful, the sausage springy and juicy, and the mash teetered on the perfect balance between creamy and fluffy. Loved the onions on top too! Everything together made for some wonderful bites. A comforting and hearty meal for sure.
I didn’t order any drinks this time but I would imagine that a tall glass of beer would've completed the experience. Maybe next time!
Update: I came back and tried the fish and chips with a couple of beers. Also really good! The batter was crispy and the fish was tender and juicy. The tartar sauce was delicious, sweet and tangy, although I do wish it came with some more. The guiness beers had the perfect layer of foam on top of them too!"
Firestrike
"A true gem and a delightful throwback to a bygone era! The moment you step inside, you’re instantly enveloped by the charm and rich history of this wonderful establishment. While I came for the lfish and chips, I found myself completely captivated by the incredible atmosphere. The nostalgic 70's and 80's tracks set the perfect vibe, making the experience feel both cozy and lively.
The fish and chips were very good—crispy, golden, and perfectly cooked, just as you’d hope for. I also had the pleasure of trying the corned beef sandwich, which, while slightly drier than I anticipated, was still flavorful and satisfying. The real star of the meal, however, was the introduction to the English mustard—its bold, tangy kick elevated every bite and left me wanting more.
This place is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience filled with great food, fantastic music, and a warm, welcoming ambiance. I can’t wait to return and explore more of the menu!"
David Chin
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
🚇 🗺️ Getting There
Molly's Shebeen is located in the Flatiron District. The closest subway stations are the 23rd Street stations for the 4, 5, 6, N, Q, R, W lines, and the 23rd Street station for the F, M lines. It's also a pleasant walk from Madison Square Park.
Yes, it's very accessible via multiple subway lines, making it convenient to reach from various parts of NYC.
Street parking can be challenging in this area. It's generally recommended to use public transportation or ride-sharing services.
Absolutely! It's a short walk from Madison Square Park and other nearby attractions.
Taking the subway to the 23rd Street station and then walking is a straightforward and common approach.
🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry
No, Molly's Shebeen is a pub and restaurant, so no tickets are required for entry. You pay for your food and drinks.
The kitchen typically closes around midnight, but the bar stays open quite a bit later, making it a good late-night spot.
There is no admission fee to enter Molly's Shebeen.
Reservations are generally not taken, as it operates on a first-come, first-served basis. Arriving early is recommended.
Molly's Shebeen has a casual dress code. Come as you are and enjoy the relaxed atmosphere.
🍽️ 🍽️ Food & Dining
The Shepherd's Pie, Fish and Chips, and Sausage with Mashed Potatoes are highly recommended. The Irish Spice Bag is also a popular choice.
Yes, they offer classic Irish pub fare, including Shepherd's Pie and other hearty dishes, alongside American pub favorites.
Their Guinness pour is exceptional and a must-try. They also offer a selection of other beers and drinks.
Yes, reviews indicate that the portion sizes are very generous, offering great value for money.
The kitchen is open until around midnight, making it a great option for a delicious late-night meal.
📸 📸 Photography
Capture the cozy interior with its sawdust floors, wood-burning fireplace, and walls adorned with Irish cultural items and Gaelic sport photos. The food presentation, especially the Guinness, also makes for great shots.
The warm, inviting atmosphere lends itself well to candid shots of friends enjoying drinks and meals.
Absolutely! The hearty dishes and perfectly poured pints are very photogenic.
The pub has a cozy, ambient lighting, which can create a warm and inviting mood in your photos.
The rustic sawdust floors, the crackling fireplace, and the authentic Irish memorabilia on the walls are all unique visual elements.
For Different Travelers
Tailored advice for your travel style
👨👩👧 Families with Kids
Dishes like the Shepherd's Pie and Sausage with Mashed Potatoes are often kid-pleasers, offering familiar and comforting flavors. The pub's traditional Irish decor also provides a unique visual experience. Just be mindful that it can get busy, so an earlier visit might be more relaxed with younger children.
🍻 Beer Enthusiasts
Beyond Guinness, the pub offers a selection of other beers that pair wonderfully with their robust food menu. The lively yet unpretentious atmosphere makes it an ideal spot to savor a few rounds and enjoy the authentic pub experience.
🚶 Solo Travelers & Day-Trippers
It's conveniently located, making it an easy addition to a day of sightseeing, especially after a stroll through Madison Square Park. The hearty food ensures you're refueled for further exploration, and the authentic Irish vibe offers a unique cultural experience without needing to travel far.
Deep Dives
In-depth insights and expert knowledge
The Authentic Irish Experience
The ambiance is further enhanced by the nostalgic music, often featuring 70s and 80s tracks, which perfectly complements the cozy and lively vibe. The staff, many of whom sound genuinely Irish, contribute to the welcoming and friendly environment. It’s this blend of rustic decor, cultural touches, and warm hospitality that makes Molly's Shebeen a delightful throwback to a bygone era and a must-visit for those appreciating a true Irish pub experience.
Culinary Delights: Beyond the Pint
For seafood lovers, the Fish and Chips are a consistent hit, boasting a crispy, golden batter and moist, tender fish, complemented by a sweet and tangy tartar sauce. Even dishes like the corned beef sandwich, while noted as slightly drier by one reviewer, are still described as flavorful. Don't overlook the Irish Spice Bag, a popular choice that pairs exceptionally well with their pints, offering a flavorful and filling experience.
Generous portion sizes are a recurring theme, ensuring you get great value for your money. The kitchen's late closing time (around midnight) also makes it an excellent destination for a satisfying late-night meal. Whether you're craving traditional Irish comfort food or classic pub fare, Molly's Shebeen delivers a delicious and hearty dining experience.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit