Casey Stamp - Image 1
1 / 3

Casey Stamps

4.6
·254 reviews·New York, United States

A tiny East Village institution offering thousands of handcrafted rubber stamps and custom design services, a true gem for stationery lovers.

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Weekday mornings

Beat the crowds

CrowdLow
Loading map...
Casey Stamp - Image 1

Casey Stamps

Best Time

Weekday mornings

Beat the crowds

CrowdLow

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A tiny East Village institution offering thousands of handcrafted rubber stamps and custom design services, a true gem for stationery lovers.

4.6
(254 reviews)

"This is one of the coolest stores in East Village, where you can get a custom stamp with any design you want."

Vertical photo
TIP

🎯 Browse Catalog First

Save time by checking their catalog online before you go, especially for custom stamp ideas!

⏳ Custom Orders Take Time

Custom stamps have a longer turnaround. Plan ahead if you need them for a specific event.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Hours

Rating

4.6 · 254 reviews

Type

Store

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Handcrafted Rubber Stamps

Handcrafted Rubber Stamps

Main shop floor

Discover thousands of unique, handcrafted rubber stamps for every occasion, from whimsical designs to intricate patterns.

Custom Stamp Creation

Custom Stamp Creation

Behind the counter

Bring your own design or choose from their extensive catalog to create a personalized stamp for business, weddings, or personal use.

Nostalgic East Village Vibe

Nostalgic East Village Vibe

The entire shop

Experience a piece of NYC history in this charming, old-school shop that's been a neighborhood staple for decades.

Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Planning Your Visit

Embrace the Charm of a Tiny Treasure

Casey Rubber Stamps is a beloved East Village institution, but it's tiny. Expect to share the space with fellow enthusiasts. Browsing the catalog online beforehand can save time, especially if you're eyeing custom designs which have a longer turnaround.

Patience is a Virtue Here

Due to recent viral fame, this shop can get incredibly busy. While they're known for quick turnaround on catalog stamps, custom orders and peak times require patience. Arriving early or on a weekday can help avoid the longest waits.

Best Times

When
Weekday mornings
Why
Beat the crowds
Crowd
Low
When
Late afternoons
Why
Tour groups thin out
Crowd
Medium

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

It is a small shop so be prepared to squeeze in with a lot of folks! You can also look at the catalog online! They will do custom stamps for both personal and business use and there is a longer turn around time for those. When I was in the store I saw some le labo stamps, as well as examples of wedding address stamps! Casey Rubber Stamps 322 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003 #stationery #stationerys...
@hellofromshruthi
124 likes • 1.1K views

🎯 Browse Catalog First

Save time by checking their catalog online before you go, especially for custom stamp ideas! TikTok

⏳ Custom Orders Take Time

Custom stamps have a longer turnaround. Plan ahead if you need them for a specific event. TikTok

Casey Rubber Stamp East Village NYC🪲📯⚜️ #design #historytok #history #nostalgia #nostlagiatok #nostalgic #interiordesign #nyc #cute
@dspacestv
2.1K likes • 14.9K views
Casey’s Rubber Stamps is my go to for anything stamp or block printing related! I’ve been coming here for 7 years and it’s a neighborhood staple 🫶🏻 stop buying your stamps from companies on Etsy pretending to be small businesses and support your local stamp shop. My stamp was ready the next day for pick up! #stamps #eastvillage #nyc #pottery
@meanmuggin_ceramics
1.6K likes • 11.8K views

🐾 Say Hi to Ratty!

Don't forget to look for Ratty the cat, a beloved resident of the shop! Reddit

💰 Support Local

Choose this local gem over online giants and support a true neighborhood staple. TikTok

Romanticizing everything in my life including these custom rubber stamps for our mail club😍😍 If you're ever in NYC you gotta stop by #caseyrubberstamps you won't be disappointed🥹 ---- #snailmail #printclub #mailclub #personalizedgifts
@comadresmail
1.9K likes • 10.5K views

Tips

from all over the internet

🎯 Browse Catalog First

Save time by checking their catalog online before you go, especially for custom stamp ideas! TikTok

⏳ Custom Orders Take Time

Custom stamps have a longer turnaround. Plan ahead if you need them for a specific event. TikTok

🐾 Say Hi to Ratty!

Don't forget to look for Ratty the cat, a beloved resident of the shop! Reddit

💰 Support Local

Choose this local gem over online giants and support a true neighborhood staple. TikTok

💌 Perfect for Snail Mail

Elevate your mail game with unique stamps for letters, journals, and more. TikTok

What Travellers Say

4.6
(254 reviews)

Reviews Summary

Casey Rubber Stamps is a highly recommended, charmingly small East Village shop offering a vast selection of handcrafted rubber stamps and custom design services. Visitors praise the unique products, excellent craftsmanship, and the nostalgic atmosphere, though some note it can get very crowded due to its recent popularity. The dedication of the owner and staff, especially for custom orders, is frequently highlighted.

"Casey Rubber Stamp is the real deal. Old fashioned rubber stamps, ink and ink pads. They don’t have any or every thing in stock, by any means. But they can create any stamp in their catalog within 10 minutes for you. Custom stamps available as well, with very reasonable flat shipping available if you don’t want to venture out to the shop again. Unfortunately (and fortunately) they are tremendously busy these days due to a few famous videos and articles. Just keep this is mind before you go and pack your patience."

E M

"We couldn’t be more thrilled with the incredible service and craftsmanship! John went above and beyond to help us create custom rubber stamps for our wedding name cards, he turned around four fully custom designs in just 72 hours. And he even worked through technical difficulties until 1am to make sure they arrived on time for our big day.

The stamps were absolutely exceptional; beautifully made, perfectly detailed, and such a hit with our guests. His dedication, responsiveness, and attention to detail truly set him apart. We’re so grateful for his extraordinary effort and talent. Highly, highly recommend!"

Stephanie Bigelow

"Such an amazing store with every stamp you can imagine….and if they don’t have it, they’ll make it. So happy we stopped in and met the owner and the precious Ratty the cat."

Amanda of the South

What People Like

Unique handcrafted stamps
Custom design service
Nostalgic atmosphere

What People Dislike

Can be very crowded
Small shop space

Frequently Asked Questions

🚇 🗺️ Getting There

Casey Rubber Stamps is located at 322 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003. The closest subway stations are Astor Place (6 train) and 3rd Ave (L train), both a short walk away. Many visitors arrive via subway as it's the most efficient way to navigate NYC. TikTok+1

Yes, it's very accessible by public transport. The L train stops at 1st Ave, and the 6 train stops at Astor Place, both within walking distance. TikTok

The East Village is well-served by subway lines. Consider the L, 6, N, Q, R, W, and F trains, depending on your starting point. Walking or biking are also great options if you're in nearby neighborhoods. TikTok

Street parking in the East Village can be very challenging and metered. It's generally recommended to use public transportation or ride-sharing services to avoid parking hassles. TikTok

Absolutely! Casey Rubber Stamps is part of a great stationery crawl in NYC, with other shops like Goods for the Study and Greenwich Letterpress nearby. TikTok+1

🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry

No, there are no tickets required to enter Casey Rubber Stamps. It's a retail shop, and you can browse freely. TikTok

Opening hours can vary, but they are typically open daily. It's always a good idea to check their most current hours online or call ahead, especially around holidays. TikTok

There is no admission fee. You pay for the stamps you purchase. Prices are generally considered reasonable for the quality and craftsmanship. Reddit

Yes, you can browse their catalog online and even place custom orders in advance. This is highly recommended for custom designs due to longer turnaround times. TikTok

While they don't typically advertise major sales, their appeal lies in their unique product and the experience of visiting. Keep an eye on their social media for any announcements. TikTok

🎫 🛍️ Shopping & Products

They sell a vast array of rubber stamps, from everyday designs to intricate artistic patterns. They also offer custom stamp creation for personal and business use. TikTok+1

Absolutely! They specialize in custom stamps. You can provide your own design or work with them to create one. TikTok+1

Catalog stamps can often be made within minutes to the next day. Custom stamps typically have a longer turnaround time, ranging from a few days to a week, depending on complexity. TikTokReddit

Prices are generally very reasonable, especially considering they are handcrafted. You can find stamps for a few dollars, with custom designs varying based on size and complexity. Reddit

Yes, they offer a selection of ink pads and other essential stamping supplies to complement their rubber stamps. Reddit

📸 📸 Photography & Experience

While not explicitly forbidden, it's a small shop with limited space. Be mindful of other customers and staff. Capturing the unique atmosphere is encouraged, but avoid blocking aisles or taking extensive photos of other patrons without permission. TikTok+1

It's a rare, old-school shop where stamps are still handcrafted. Its small size and unique offerings, combined with its East Village location, contribute to its hidden gem status. TikTok+2

The vibe is nostalgic, charming, and a bit quirky. It smells faintly of rubber and ink, and the shelves are packed with thousands of stamps, creating a delightful sensory experience. Reddit

While service animals are always welcome, the shop is very small. It's best to check their policy or leave pets at home unless they are service animals to ensure a comfortable experience for everyone. Reddit

NYC has a fantastic stationery scene! Other notable shops include Yoseka Stationery, Greenwich Letterpress, Goods for the Study, and Niconeco Zakkaya. TikTok+1

Casey Stamps (2026) – Best of TikTok, Instagram & Reddit Travel Guide