Mimmo's Pizza Shoppe - Image 1
1 / 3

Mimmos Pizza Shoppe

4.8
·90 reviews·, United States

Staten Island's culinary gem, Mimmos Pizza Shoppe, offers inventive pizzas and sandwiches with bold flavors like hot honey.

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Weekday evenings

Fewer crowds, more relaxed vibe

CrowdMedium
Loading map...
Mimmo's Pizza Shoppe - Image 1

Mimmos Pizza Shoppe

Best Time

Weekday evenings

Fewer crowds, more relaxed vibe

CrowdMedium

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Staten Island's culinary gem, Mimmos Pizza Shoppe, offers inventive pizzas and sandwiches with bold flavors like hot honey.

4.8
(90 reviews)

"This stuffed pizza from @mimmospizzashoppe really blew us away. Dare I call it the best new pizza spot on Staten Island?"

Vertical photo
TIP

🎯 Try the Signature Pizzas

Don't miss the Hot Honey Sicilian or Stuffed Ricotta! They're crowd favorites.

💡 Ask for Recommendations

Staff are friendly and happy to guide you through the menu.

Third hero image

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Hot Honey Sicilian Pizza

Hot Honey Sicilian Pizza

A divine Sicilian slice with a sweet and spicy kick, layered with mozzarella, tomato sauce, and vodka sauce.

TikTok
Hot Honey Cheesesteak Pinwheels

Hot Honey Cheesesteak Pinwheels

Savory pizza dough rolled with steak, peppers, onions, cheese, and a sweet hot honey drizzle.

TikTok
Stuffed Ricotta Pizza

Stuffed Ricotta Pizza

An intensely flavorful Sicilian pizza generously stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, vodka sauce, and pesto.

TikTok
Street Corn Pizza

Street Corn Pizza

A unique and creamy pizza topped with fresh mozzarella and a vibrant street corn mixture.

TikTok
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Planning Your Visit

Embrace the Flavor Adventure

Mimmo's is a Staten Island hotspot known for its creative pizzas and sandwiches. Expect bold flavors like hot honey and unique combinations. It's a popular spot, so be prepared for a lively atmosphere and potentially a wait, especially during peak hours. TikTok

Staten Island's Culinary Gem

This family-owned shop is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking innovative twists on classics. From stuffed Sicilians to hot honey cheesesteak pinwheels, Mimmo's offers a memorable culinary experience. TikTok

Best Times

When
Weekday evenings
Why
Fewer crowds, more relaxed vibe
Crowd
Medium
When
Weekend afternoons
Why
Experience the buzz
Crowd
High

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

The MVP HOT HONEY SICILIAN PIZZA from @mimmospizzashoppe on Staten Island NYC! 🍕🔥🤤 Incredible! #DEVOURPOWER #fyp #foryou #mimmospizzashoppe #statenisland
@devourpower
4.2K likes • 50.3K views

🎯 Try the Signature Pizzas

Don't miss the Hot Honey Sicilian or Stuffed Ricotta! They're crowd favorites. TikTok+1

💡 Ask for Recommendations

Staff are friendly and happy to guide you through the menu. Reddit

HOT HONEY CHEESESTEAK PINWHEELS from @mimmospizzashoppe on Staten Island, NYC! 🧀🥩🍯🍕🔥🤤 Insane! #DEVOURPOWER #fyp #foryou #pinwheels #cheesesteak
@devourpower
18.2K likes • 175.6K views
This stuffed pizza from @mimmospizzashoppe really blew us away. Dare I call it the best new pizza spot on Staten Island? 👀🍕 #statenisland #food #foodie #pizza #nypizza #ny #newyork #nyc #si #italian #italianfood
@ftmoming
559 likes • 12.2K views

🚗 Parking can be tricky

Street parking is available but can be competitive. Reddit

✨ Pinwheels are a must-try

The cheesesteak and dessert pinwheels are incredibly popular. TikTok+1

STUFFED RICOTTA PIZZA for the WIN from @mimmospizzashoppe on Staten Island NYC! 🧀🍕🔥🤤 #DEVOURPOWER #fyp #foryou #pizza #nycpizza
@devourpower
66K likes • 648.1K views

Tips

from all over the internet

🎯 Try the Signature Pizzas

Don't miss the Hot Honey Sicilian or Stuffed Ricotta! They're crowd favorites. TikTok+1

💡 Ask for Recommendations

Staff are friendly and happy to guide you through the menu. Reddit

🚗 Parking can be tricky

Street parking is available but can be competitive. Reddit

✨ Pinwheels are a must-try

The cheesesteak and dessert pinwheels are incredibly popular. TikTok+1

🤏 Limited Seating

It's a small shop, so be prepared for standing room or takeout. Reddit

What Travellers Say

4.8
(90 reviews)

Reviews Summary

Mimmos Pizza Shoppe is a highly-rated Staten Island gem, celebrated for its innovative and delicious pizzas and sandwiches. Visitors rave about the unique flavor combinations, especially the hot honey pizzas and stuffed specialties. The friendly service and lively atmosphere add to the positive experience, though limited seating is a minor drawback.

"Such a hidden gem! Busy with locals, but the staff was so friendly and welcoming. They even guided us with some must-try options for our first visit. Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious, and we left completely full!

We tried:
• Staten Italy sandwich
• The Mort sandwich
• Buffalo BBQ pizza
• Hot Honey pizza
• Cheesesteak pinwheel

Every bite was amazing. Great restaurant—I’d definitely go back again!"

Mena

"Been seeing this place on Instagram & had to cross that 440 bridge! They DID NOT disappoint! Wow everything was amazing !
I had the 3 sauce focaccia garlic sandwich, the corn Sicilian, the vodka slice, plain slice for my son & the hot honey Sicilian!
Everything was 5 out 5 here! Small inside but great service! I’ll be back in 2 weeks!!"

Marisella Mendoza

"I found out about Mimmo’s Pizza Shoppe on TikTok and decided to include it in our trip to try it — and wow, it was so worth it! I ordered the chicken parm sandwich, and honestly, it was life changing. The taste, smell, and texture were all absolute perfection — everything you’d want in a sandwich and more.

The service was amazing too. The guys working there were super friendly, quick, and really made the experience even better.

This is definitely a sandwich I’ll be dreaming about until I get to have it again. Can’t wait to go back — Mimmo’s totally lives up to the hype!"

Juliana Vergara

What People Like

Creative and delicious pizzas
Unique flavor combinations
Friendly and welcoming staff

What People Dislike

Limited seating

Frequently Asked Questions

🚇 🗺️ Getting There

From Manhattan, you can take the Staten Island Ferry to St. George Terminal. From there, you can take a bus or a taxi/rideshare to Mimmos Pizza Shoppe. Driving is also an option, but be aware of potential traffic and parking challenges. TikTok

Parking is primarily street parking, which can be competitive, especially during busy hours. It's advisable to be patient or consider public transport if you're not familiar with the area. Reddit

If you're on Staten Island, local buses are a convenient option. Alternatively, a short taxi or rideshare trip will get you there quickly. TikTok

Yes, public transportation is a viable option. Buses serve the area, and the Staten Island Ferry is a great way to reach the island if you're coming from Manhattan. TikTok

While accessible by car, navigating and finding parking can be a challenge. Many visitors opt for rideshares or public transport to avoid parking hassles. Reddit

🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry

No, Mimmos Pizza Shoppe operates on a walk-in basis. You don't need to purchase tickets in advance. TikTok

Opening hours can vary, but they are typically open for lunch and dinner. It's best to check their social media or website for the most up-to-date hours before your visit. TikTok

There is no admission fee. You pay for the food and drinks you order. TikTok

Due to its popularity and small size, Mimmos Pizza Shoppe does not typically take reservations. It's first-come, first-served. Reddit

Visiting during off-peak hours, such as weekday afternoons or early evenings, can help minimize wait times. Weekends and peak dinner hours tend to be very busy. Reddit

🍽️ 🍕 Food & Dining

The Hot Honey Sicilian Pizza, Stuffed Ricotta Pizza, and Street Corn Pizza are highly recommended and frequently featured on social media. TikTok+3

Absolutely! Mimmos offers a variety of delicious sandwiches, including the Staten Italy and chicken parm, as well as popular cheesesteak pinwheels. TikTok+2

The Hot Honey pizza combines sweet and spicy elements, often drizzled over a classic pizza or sandwich, creating a unique flavor profile that's a hit with customers. TikTok+1

While many pizzas can be customized, Mimmos is known for its meat-centric creations. It's best to inquire about specific vegetarian options when ordering. TikTok

Mimmos offers sweet pinwheels, such as Oreo and Nutella stuffed versions, which are a delightful treat. Reddit

📸 📸 Photography

The Stuffed Ricotta Pizza, Hot Honey Sicilian, and the vibrant Street Corn Pizza are visually stunning. The cheesesteak pinwheels also make for great photos. TikTok+3

The interior is small and can be crowded, which might make photography challenging. However, the food itself is very photogenic, so focusing on your order is key. Reddit

Natural light from the windows can be helpful, but the shop's ambiance is more about the food than the setting. Consider visiting during off-peak hours for a less rushed photo opportunity. Reddit

Close-ups highlighting the cheese pulls, the drizzle of hot honey, or the layers of ingredients in the stuffed pizzas are very popular and effective. TikTok+2

It's always best to be respectful of other patrons and staff. Focus on your food and ask permission if you wish to photograph individuals. TikTok

For Different Travelers

Tailored advice for your travel style

👨‍👩‍👧 Families with Kids

Mimmos offers a fun and flavorful experience for families. Kids will likely enjoy the creative pizzas like the Street Corn Pizza TikTok or the sweet dessert pinwheels.Reddit The cheesesteak pinwheels are also a crowd-pleaser for all ages. TikTok While seating is limited, the friendly staff are accommodating, and the vibrant atmosphere can be exciting for children. Consider ordering a variety of items to share, ensuring there's something for everyone's taste. Reddit

💸 Budget Travelers

While Mimmos offers gourmet flavors, it remains relatively affordable for the quality and portion sizes. Sharing pizzas or pinwheels can be a cost-effective way to sample multiple items. Reddit Opting for a few slices or a sandwich instead of a whole specialty pizza can also help manage costs. The generous portions mean you might get more than one meal out of your order. Reddit

🍕 Pizza Aficionados

For true pizza lovers, Mimmos is a pilgrimage site. They excel in creative Sicilian styles, like the Stuffed Ricotta TikTok and Hot Honey Sicilian,TikTok showcasing unique flavor combinations. Don't shy away from their more unconventional offerings like the Street Corn Pizza.TikTok The quality of ingredients and the execution of their dough are consistently praised, making it a must-try for anyone serious about pizza. Reddit

Deep Dives

In-depth insights and expert knowledge

The Art of Mimmos' Signature Pizzas

Mimmos Pizza Shoppe has carved out a niche by reinventing classic pizza concepts with bold, innovative toppings. Their Hot Honey Sicilian Pizza is a prime example, layering traditional sauces with the sweet heat of hot honey for a flavor explosion. TikTok Similarly, the Stuffed Ricotta Pizza takes the Sicilian base and aggressively stuffs it with a creamy ricotta and mozzarella blend, enhanced by pesto and vodka sauce, creating a decadent and rich experience. TikTok+1

Beyond these stars, the Street Corn Pizza offers a unique fusion, bringing the popular street food flavor profile to a pizza base with fresh mozzarella and a creamy topping. TikTok+1 These creative combinations are a testament to Mimmos' commitment to pushing culinary boundaries and delighting their customers with unexpected yet delicious flavor pairings. The attention to detail in stuffing, layering, and balancing sweet, savory, and spicy elements makes each signature pizza a standout. Reddit

Beyond Pizza: Sandwiches and Pinwheels

While Mimmos is celebrated for its pizzas, their sandwiches and pinwheels are equally noteworthy and have garnered significant praise. The Hot Honey Cheesesteak Pinwheels are a fan favorite, combining the savory goodness of cheesesteak with the sweet kick of hot honey, all wrapped in a delightful pizza dough. TikTok+1 Other popular sandwich options include the Staten Italy and the Chicken Parm sandwich, which one reviewer described as 'life changing.' TikTokReddit

These non-pizza offerings showcase Mimmos' versatility and their ability to apply their signature flavor profiles to different formats. The use of fresh focaccia for sliders, like the Chicken Vodka Pepperoni Hot Honey Garlic Butter Focaccia Sliders, further demonstrates their creativity. TikTok Whether you're craving a classic pizza or something entirely different, Mimmos ensures a high-quality, flavor-packed experience across their entire menu. Reddit

The Mimmos Experience: Atmosphere and Service

Mimmos Pizza Shoppe is a family-owned establishment that prides itself on a welcoming and friendly atmosphere, despite its compact size. Many visitors highlight the staff's warmth and helpfulness, noting that they are eager to guide first-time visitors through the extensive menu and offer recommendations. TikTokReddit This personal touch significantly enhances the dining experience, making customers feel valued and well-cared for. Reddit

The shop's interior is described as small, with limited seating primarily consisting of barstools by the window. Reddit This intimate setting contributes to its 'hidden gem' status, often bustling with locals. While the lack of extensive seating might be a drawback for some, it also fosters a lively and energetic vibe. The focus remains squarely on the exceptional food, with the friendly service complementing the culinary delights. Reddit